Super Smash Bros. for Wii U review

  • Incredibly fun and eminently playable
  • Beautiful to behold at 60fps
  • More modes than you'll ever have time for
  • Online infrastructure feels dated
  • Amiibos aren't much more than a neat gimmick

I wish I was playing Super Smash Bros. for Wii U right now. From the moment I finished my first match, I knew I was hooked on this highly polished fighter. To even talk about Smash Bros. or hear it being played in my vicinity triggers feelings of rambunctious excitement and competitive spirit within me. I'll level with you, dear reader: the quicker I tell you all about the Wii U version's triumphs, the sooner I can go back to it. By the time we're done here, I hope you'll want to join me.

At this point, you should know the Smash Bros. drill: select a character from a staggering range of legendary game series, then beat the snot out of your opponents in an attempt to knock them off the screen. By default, items will continuously rain down from the sky, creating little battles where everyone races to snatch up the flashy, potentially tide-turning power-ups. And unlike your typical 2D fighter, the stages are wide open and usually multi-tiered, making Smash Bros. bouts much more vertical.

There are only two attack buttons, making it so that anyone can pick up and play - but mastering your favorite character could very well take years. Each fighter has their own distinct weight and momentum, turning every match into a fluid, fast-paced duel full of speedy, tense spacing and impactful combat. Because victory depends on ring-outs rather than health totals, you'll constantly bear witness to miraculous ledge-grabbing saves that seemed impossible, or gasp-worthy moments as you just barely avoid a haymaker smash attack that would've surely sent you rocketing towards oblivion. Each fight naturally creates these exciting, nail-biting exchanges, which will continue to surprise and entertain you even after playing hundreds of matches.

Of course, the fighting swings from strategic to chaotic the more players you add. Whether in teams or a wild free-for-all, up to eight players can join the fun in local play, amplifying the frantic bouts to new heights of cartoon violence hysteria. Admittedly, eight-player rumbles make it almost impossible to tell what's going on (or what item you're picking up). But there's an inherent appeal to the madness of giddily walloping the nearest enemy, hoping that you'll still be standing when the dust settles. The downside is that you're restricted to a smaller subset of maps, some of which feel overly big even for an octet of combatants. And while the novelty of 8P eventually wears off, it's great being able to include those players who would've otherwise had to wait their turn from the sidelines.

If you've been playing Super Smash Bros. for 3DS, the core of the Wii U version is functionally the same - gameplay is a supremely satisfying middle ground between the unrelenting speed of Melee and the floatiness of Brawl. The 51-character roster is nicely balanced; no character feels like they tower above or cower below the rest. Custom fighters let you tweak any fighter's stats and moveset; unfortunately, you'll have to unlock equippable items and alternate special moves at random (even if you've already collected them on the 3DS). It's a slow, discouraging prerequisite to what's otherwise an enjoyable diversion.

Playing on the big screen comes with some pretty obvious benefits. First and foremost: the gorgeous graphics, which will punch you directly in the eyes with fists formed from crystallized rainbows the moment you start a match. Each fighter has a sheen of detail and polish, and the striking use of color and perspective in the backgrounds makes them almost as eye-catching as the brawling. Best of all, the Wii U maintains a consistent, silky smooth 60fps in 1080p, save for some rare, ever-so-slight stutters when large stage elements (like Ridley in the Pyrosphere or the Boxing Ring's overhead lights) spawn in. Speaking of stages, the Wii U selection puts equal emphasis on captivating backdrops and unique, well-designed layouts.

In full control

The Wii U offers a bevy of controller options, so you're sure to find the one that fits you best. Playing on the GamePad feels fine, and the handling on the Pro Controller is even tighter. But nothing compares to the nostalgic, muscle-memory comfort of playing with a GameCube controller, courtesy of the sold-separately adapter. Its beefy joystick was seemingly made for Smashing, and the adapter supports Wavebirds if you've still got your old ones lying around. You can even sync up a 3DS to function as a wireless controller, provided you're some kind of nutjob who wants to smash on a circle pad. Hey, to each their own.

On top of the returning single-player modes from the 3DS version - the arcade-style Classic, All-Star's full-roster gauntlet, and the Stadium mini-games - you also get Event Mode, which is what single-player Smash Bros. was meant to be. It plops you in the middle of an expansive grid of addictive, bite-sized challenges, each with three difficulty levels and tricky bonus objectives. But the rest of the Wii U-exclusive solo content is nothing to high five your friends over. The board game-style Smash Tour is a disappointment, taking all the annoying bits of Mario Party - incessant randomness, the inability to strategically plan ahead, over-complicated rules - and sprinkling in the occasional brawl. You're better off just skipping the build-up and playing some traditional matches instead. There's also Special Orders, where you can risk in-game gold to attempt difficult missions with lucrative rewards - but the press-your-luck structure often ends in frustration.

Amiibos - Nintendo's line of data-saving statuettes - work with Smash Bros. as a neat gimmick, rather than an AI revolution. Tapping your $13/£11 figure on the GamePad summons that fighter as your new apprentice, letting you designate their name, costume, and ability set. But the end result is an computer-controlled buddy that feels more like a customizable drone than a disciple-in-training. Getting your Amiibo to the level 50 cap takes a few hours, with zero effort on your part - and from my experience, Amiibos never ‘learn’ anything from you. The real payoff is pitting your Amiibo against your pals', like some kind of Nintendo-endorsed cockfight. I may not feel like I truly ‘raised’ Amy Bo, my defense-specializing lady Villager, but I do enjoy a sense of pride when she wrecks house in multiplayer matches.

More Info

Release date: Nov 21 2014 - Wii U (US)
Available Platforms: Wii U
Genre: Fighting
Published by: Nintendo
Developed by: Namco Bandai
Franchise: Super Smash Bros
ESRB Rating:
Rating Pending

For those times when you don't have a group of willing competitors at your beck and call, there's always Smash Bros.' online component, which usually runs smoothly. Sadly, there are the occasional slogs through agonizingly erratic connections - and you have no way of knowing what you're in for lag-wise until the match starts. Unlike the online environment of, say, Ultra Street Fighter 4, where green-colored connection bars let you know that a lobby is worth joining, Smash Bros. haphazardly pairs you up with players based on a hidden ranking.

But when you do get a solid connection, it's fantastic being able to spar with players of your skill level, each one pushing your understanding of the game a bit further. The ingenious trick of making multiple versions of the bare-bones Final Destination level layout prevents fatigue for competitors and onlookers alike. It's also surprisingly easy to get hooked on the Spectator Mode, which lets you bet your coin stash on the outcome of other players' throwdowns (a bit like SaltyBet).

Super Smash Bros. for Wii U is the sequel you've been waiting for; a fighter that's as finely tuned and well-balanced as it is beautiful. The core experience of intense back-and-forth brawling is so spectacular that it makes the few lackluster modes feel more like unneeded extras than disappointments. Whether alone, with friends, or against equally skilled strangers, this Smash Bros. offers excellent fighting that's enduringly exciting.

Same great Smash Bros. gameplay, amazing new presentation on the Wii U. Whether you're looking for technical depth or enjoyable chaos, you'll find it here.


  • elmoro-mourad - December 30, 2014 6:51 p.m.

    tbh with u guys , i dont think u need a Wii or ps4 or xbox, im enjoying my time just playing FREE and no hussle
  • GamesRadarCollanderCooper - November 28, 2014 2:10 p.m.

    Instead of reviewing more episodes of shitty shows like Doctor Who, could you guys review Geometry Wars 3 and Freedom Wars?
  • DarkDoctor667 - November 27, 2014 9:33 a.m.

    I don't agree with the article's Pros and Cons part of the Amiibo's being a neat gimmick. it works with smash veryt well and it has many uses outside of Smash as well. The Amiibos are great to train with and to learn a character you might not be very good with. it is a nice addition.
  • GameManiac - November 25, 2014 11:42 a.m.

    It's criminal that I've bought this game (the $99 GameCube controller and adapter bundle) at midnight, and have YET to play it. Of course, in my defense, I've been playing Pokémon Alpha Sapphire.
  • pull-it-in - November 25, 2014 4:30 a.m.

    Smash Bros, Bayonetta 2, Pikmin 3, MarioKart 8. Is it worth me getting a Wii U? It's still pretty expensive.
  • WadeSlade - November 25, 2014 7:38 a.m.

    I will tell you that I bought the Wii U when it was in its infancy and I was actually pretty disappointed with my purchase because it was just a glorified paperweight. However now I can tell you I play my Wii U everyday. I strongly urge you to look into getting one. Tons of great games and a fun party system. Also you could maybe find a better deal if you waited for a bundle or bought refurbished directly from Nintendo
  • shawksta - November 24, 2014 7:52 p.m.

    Great review! The extra modes seem more of personal opinions, Special Order's risk taking gives you ecstasy. Smash Tour seems like a polar opposite of Smash Run while still keeping the main idea of the stat boosts. I liked it, in Smash Run you get to run around attacking Nintendo enemies, whereas Smash Tour actually gives you a lot more time and battles to actually use your stat boosts. Amiibo wasnt supposed to be revolutionary, its main focus is a action figure of your favorite character that has the added bonus of interacting with various games. I still want Amiibo money matches :3
  • GOD - November 24, 2014 7:28 p.m.

    I bought my GC controller adapter the night it came out and picked in store pick up. Apparently this was a good idea because they ran out of stock really fast and everyone else was trying to order them to no avail. It definitely feels better than the 3DS version, although when I'm not using the GC controller it is kind of annoying that I constantly have to reselect my custom controller setup and can't make it the default for all gametypes. Also since I can't pick a custom controller profile for challenges because there isn't a character select, I basically have to play them with a GC controller. Not a huge problem, but it means that unlike other games that I would just play on the gamepad, I need to play this on my TV so I can use my GC controller. Also online feels much more stable than it was on 3DS. Strangely classic mode difficulty levels feel easier on the WiiU version, but level 9 CPUs in regular smash mode seem stronger. Perhaps this is to make the overall game harder, but make it easier for people to get to the exclusive to WiiU Master Core level at difficulty 8.0 and up.
  • Shyplay - December 2, 2014 11:02 a.m.

    If by Challenges you mean Event mode, select an event and instead of pushing +, push Y. It opens a menu in the bottom left that lets you choose your name, allowing you to customize your controls. Without the menu open, it blends into the background, so It's easy to miss.
  • Jackonomics2.0 - November 24, 2014 7:09 p.m.

    Holy shit An actual game this month that isn't plagued by bugs and rushed out the door like garbage
  • Mastanvx - November 25, 2014 10:01 a.m.

    That's most Nintendo games for ya, they actually CARE about the quality of their work.
  • winner2 - November 24, 2014 6:39 p.m.

    Amiibos not actually adding anything No fuckin' shit guys, like who actually gives a damn about the amiibos anyway
  • BladedFalcon - November 24, 2014 6:30 p.m.

    WHAAAAT? Amiibos are not a lot more than glorified figurines? COLOR ME SHOCKED. Seriously, anyone who ever truly expected amiibos to add any significant value to any kind of gameplay experience is an idiot.
  • Jackonomics2.0 - November 24, 2014 7:08 p.m.

    Holy shit An actual good game this month that isn't plagued by bugs and rushed through the door.
  • Jackonomics2.0 - November 24, 2014 7:10 p.m.

    My bad, I seem to accidentally press reply to you and left, pressed back and the comment box was still glued as a reply despite not showing

Showing 1-20 of 114 comments

Join the Discussion
Add a comment (HTML tags are not allowed.)
Characters remaining: 5000