Skip to main content
Join The Community
- Join our community
Commenting
Join the discussion
Exclusive Articles
Member-only articles
Weekly Newsletters
Weekly gaming & entertainment news
Member Badges
Earn badges as you go
Exclusive Competitions
Members-only prize draws
Curated Deals Coming Soon
Tech and gaming deals worth grabbing
GET COMMUNITY ACCESS QUICK
For the quickest way to join, simply enter your email below and get access. We will send a confirmation and sign you up to our newsletter to keep you updated on all your gaming news.
By submitting your information you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy and are aged 16 or over.
FIND OUT ABOUT OUR MAGAZINE
Want to subscribe to the magazine? Click the button below to find out more information.
Find out more
GET Community ACCESS QUICK

Join the GamesRadar community for quick access. Enter your email below and we'll send confirmation, and sign you up to our newsletter.

By submitting your information you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy and are aged 16 or over.

Welcome to GamesRADAR+ Community !
Hi ,

Your membership journey starts here.

Keep exploring and earning more as a member.

MY ACCOUNT

Earn your first badge
Read 1 article to unlock your first badge.
Keep earning badges
Explore ways to get more involved as a member.
Latest Games News

Latest Games News

Breaking gaming news and updates

Read Now
Latest Games Reviews

Latest Games Reviews

Expert verdicts on the newest releases

Read Now

See what you’ve unlocked.

Explore your membership benefits.

Explore
Member Exclusives

Stay Ahead with GamesRadar+

Get the biggest gaming news, reviews, and releases straight to your inbox.

Explore
Sign Out
GamesRadar+
US EditionUS CA EditionCanada UK EditionUK AU EditionAustralia
Sign in
  • View Profile
  • Sign out
  • Games
    • Game Insights
      • Games News
      • Games Features
      • Games Reviews
      • Games Guides
      • Big in 2026
      • Big Preview
      • Future Games Show
      • Golden Joystick Awards
    • Genres
      • Action Games
      • RPGs
      • Action RPGs
      • Adventure Games
      • Third Person Shooters
      • FPS Games
    • Platforms
      • PS5
      • Xbox Series X
      • PC
      • Nintendo Switch
      • Nintendo Switch 2
      • Tabletop Gaming
    • Franchises
      • Grand Theft Auto
      • Pokemon
      • Assassin's Creed
      • Monster Hunter
      • Fortnite
      • Cyberpunk
      • Red Dead
      • The Elder Scrolls
      • The Sims
  • Entertainment
    • TV Shows
      • TV News
      • TV Reviews
      • Anime Shows
      • Sci-Fi Shows
      • Superhero Shows
      • Animated Shows
      • Marvel TV Shows
      • Star Wars TV Shows
      • DC TV Shows
    • Movies
      • Movie News
      • Movie Reviews
      • Big Screen Spotlight
      • Superhero Movies
      • Action Movies
      • Anime Movies
      • Sci-Fi Movies
      • Horror Movies
      • Marvel Movies
      • DC Movies
    • Streaming
      • Apple TV Plus
      • Disney Plus
      • Netflix
      • HBO
      • Amazon Prime Video
      • Hulu
    • Comics
      • Marvel Comics
      • DC Comics
  • Hardware
    • Insights
      • Hardware News
      • Hardware Reviews
      • Hardware Features
      • Buying Guides
    • Computing
      • Desktop PCs
      • Laptops
      • Handhelds
    • Peripherals
      • Headsets & Headphones
      • TVs & Monitors
      • Gaming Mice
      • Gaming Keyboards
      • Gaming Chairs
      • Speakers & Audio
    • Accessories & Tech
      • Gaming Controllers
      • Tech
      • SSDs & Hard Drives
      • VR
      • Accessories
      • Retro
  • Deals
    • Toys & Collectibles
    • Lego
    • Dungeons and Dragons
    • Merch
  • Video
    • Videos
    • GR+ Replay - Submit Your Clips
    • G+RLS Podcast
  • Edge
  • Newsletters
    • Quizzes
    • About Us
    • How to pitch to us
    • How we score
    • Newsarama
    • Retro Gamer
  • Home
  • Games
    • View Games
      • Games News
      • Games Features
      • Games Reviews
      • Games Guides
      • Big in 2026
      • Big Preview
      • Future Games Show
      • Golden Joystick Awards
      • Action Games
      • RPGs
      • Action RPGs
      • Adventure Games
      • Third Person Shooters
      • FPS Games
    • Platforms
      • View Platforms
      • PS5
      • Xbox Series X
      • PC
      • Nintendo Switch
      • Nintendo Switch 2
      • Tabletop Gaming
      • Grand Theft Auto
      • Pokemon
      • Assassin's Creed
      • Monster Hunter
      • Fortnite
      • Cyberpunk
      • Red Dead
      • The Elder Scrolls
      • The Sims
  • Entertainment
    • View Entertainment
    • TV Shows
      • View TV Shows
      • TV News
      • TV Reviews
      • Anime Shows
      • Sci-Fi Shows
      • Superhero Shows
      • Animated Shows
      • Marvel TV Shows
      • Star Wars TV Shows
      • DC TV Shows
    • Movies
      • View Movies
      • Movie News
      • Movie Reviews
      • Big Screen Spotlight
      • Superhero Movies
      • Action Movies
      • Anime Movies
      • Sci-Fi Movies
      • Horror Movies
      • Marvel Movies
      • DC Movies
    • Streaming
      • View Streaming
      • Apple TV Plus
      • Disney Plus
      • Netflix
      • HBO
      • Amazon Prime Video
      • Hulu
    • Comics
      • View Comics
      • Marvel Comics
      • DC Comics
  • Hardware
    • View Hardware
      • Hardware News
      • Hardware Reviews
      • Hardware Features
      • Buying Guides
      • Desktop PCs
      • Laptops
      • Handhelds
    • Peripherals
      • View Peripherals
      • Headsets & Headphones
      • TVs & Monitors
      • Gaming Mice
      • Gaming Keyboards
      • Gaming Chairs
      • Speakers & Audio
      • Gaming Controllers
      • Tech
      • SSDs & Hard Drives
      • VR
      • Accessories
      • Retro
  • Deals
    • Toys & Collectibles
    • Lego
    • Dungeons and Dragons
    • Merch
  • Video
    • View Video
    • Videos
    • GR+ Replay - Submit Your Clips
    • G+RLS Podcast
  • Edge
  • Newsletters
    • Quizzes
    • About Us
    • How to pitch to us
    • How we score
    • Newsarama
    • Retro Gamer
Trending
  • GTA 6 review
  • Early Black Friday deals
  • GTA 6 News
  • Golden Joystick winners
  • RPG News
  • G+RLS Podcast
  • Win a GTA 6 collector's box
  • Deal of the Day
Want more Switch 2 news?

Sign up to our Switch 2 newsletter to make sure you get the very latest news on Nintendo's new console and its games every week


By submitting your information you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy and are aged 16 or over.

You are now subscribed

Your newsletter sign-up was successful


Want to add more newsletters?

GamesRadar+

Every Friday

GamesRadar+

Your weekly update on everything you could ever want to know about the games you already love, games we know you're going to love in the near future, and tales from the communities that surround them.

GTA 6 O'clock

Every Thursday

GTA 6 O'clock

Our special GTA 6 newsletter, with breaking news, insider info, and rumor analysis from the award-winning GTA 6 O'clock experts.

Knowledge

Every Friday

Knowledge

From the creators of Edge: A weekly videogame industry newsletter with analysis from expert writers, guidance from professionals, and insight into what's on the horizon.

The Setup

Every Thursday

The Setup

Hardware nerds unite, sign up to our free tech newsletter for a weekly digest of the hottest new tech, the latest gadgets on the test bench, and much more.

Switch 2 Spotlight

Every Wednesday

Switch 2 Spotlight

Sign up to our new Switch 2 newsletter, where we bring you the latest talking points on Nintendo's new console each week, bring you up to date on the news, and recommend what games to play.

The Watchlist

Every Saturday

The Watchlist

Subscribe for a weekly digest of the movie and TV news that matters, direct to your inbox. From first-look trailers, interviews, reviews and explainers, we've got you covered.

SFX

Once a month

SFX

Get sneak previews, exclusive competitions and details of special events each month!


Join the club

Get full access to premium articles, exclusive features and a growing list of member rewards.


An account already exists for this email address, please log in.
  1. Games
  2. Simulation Games
  3. Tales of the Shire

I should have loved playing Tales of the Shire, but this Stardew Valley and Lord of the Rings mash-up has a distinct lack of vibes

Features
By Andrew Brown
Published 22 September 2024

Preview | Life in Bywater isn't as charming as it sounds

When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here’s how it works.

A cozy Hobbit-hole by the river in Tales of the Shire
(Image credit: Private Division)
  • Facebook
  • X
  • Pinterest
  • Flipboard
  • Email
  • Instagram
Share this article
Join the conversation
Follow us
Add us as a preferred source on Google
Subscribe to our newsletter

I've lost count of how many times I've read The Hobbit. As a child, I lived for its action – for goblins, dragons, and life-or-death games of riddles – but with every re-read, I've fallen more and more in love with its first chapter about Hobbits. Middle-earth's laziest layabouts, Hobbits live only to furnish their cozy burrowed homes, eat voraciously, and enjoy the Shire's gorgeous countryside. I often fantasize about living there, and if given the chance to move to the Shire, I'd be smoking pipeweed in Bag End before you could say "second breakfast". 

Until then, I've lived out similar carefree fantasies in Stardew Valley and Animal Crossing, but living in a Hobbit-hole of my own has remained the ultimate fantasy. I'm saying all of this because in theory, Tales of the Shire, a life sim set in the Shire's village of Bywater, should be right up my street. But after playing it for a couple of hours, I'm left lukewarm. 

An unexpected party

A Hobbit man cooking in a cozy kitchen in Tales of the Shire

(Image credit: Private Division)
When is Tales of the Hobbit set?

A screenshot of the upcoming Switch game, Tales of the Shire.

(Image credit: Private Division)

Tales of the Hobbit is set in Middle-earth's Third Age - see where it fits in our Lord of the Rings timeline. 

Our anti-adventure begins with creating a Hobbit, who's just been woken up by Gandalf after falling asleep between Bree and Bywater. I'm thoroughly amused by the match-two naming system here – Bungo Underhill, how do you do – but less impressed with my attempt at character customisation, which results in poor Bungo looking like a strangely angular Miss Piggy. Luckily, it's only upward from there, as having inherited a home in Bywater, Bungo's got a whole new life ahead of him.

Latest Videos FromGamesRadar+
Watch full video here:

There's a lot of promise here. Bungo's new home is neglected and run-down, and as mossy as it looks now, I can already envision how satisfying it will be to clean things up and carve out my own snug corner of the Shire. Most importantly, there's a large, barebones pantry that I'm giddy at the thought of restocking. In fact, the first thing I have to do is search its shelves to cook a meal for local Hobbit Orlo Proudfoot, who appears to be on death's door because he missed his last meal. 

Cooking is surprisingly intricate. After selecting a recipe – earned by befriending Bywater's residents – you can chop, fry and season each ingredient to your liking. How long you chop rhubarb, for example, determines how chunky or smooth it will be for a pie, and it takes experimentation to work out the best combination of textures for each meal. Trial and error is worthwhile, as food is the quickest way to a Hobbit's heart, and serving delicious meals will befriend your neighbors quicker. Hosting more elaborate dinner parties with better food seems to be one of Tales of the Shire's driving features – in preparation for hosting two Hobbits for lunch, I found myself foraging in the forest for mushrooms, fishing in the Brandybuck, and whizzing through the village square's market to buy cream and bacon. Your time in each day is limited though (stay up too late and you'll be carted home à la Stardew), so keeping a well-stocked pantry is a trial in itself. 

You may like
  • A cast of cel-shaded characters looks hopefully over the horizon with pet companions in toe My new cozy obsession is a Lord of the Rings-inspired Animal Crossing riff blowing up on Kickstarter
  • Riding the bus in Toem 2, which is driven by a fluffy creature in a bowtie Toem 2 review: "Effortlessly charming with clever puzzling, this photography adventure is worth snapping up"
  • 4x4s in Over the Hill cross a river with canoes on the roof Over the Hill review: "The single most stressful game I’ve played in years and I think it hates me"

A Hobbit watering her plants and vegetables in Tales of the Shire

(Image credit: Private Division)

But as much as I enjoy putting together the perfect lunch, I'm not sure if these dinner parties alone are enough to keep Tales of the Shire engaging. You can customize your little Hobbit-hole and its garden, but there doesn't seem to be many longer-term goals to chase – think saving up to buy new buildings in Animal Crossing, or completing Stardew Valley's community center. There are quests to complete, but the ones I played were nearly all dull fetch quests and frustrating back-and-forth couriering between characters (no, you sniffly little Hobbit, I won't cross the Shire and back for a third time because the second cold remedy I've fetched for you didn't work). It's a shame, because the game's writing really surprised me with how funny it is – at one point I was roped into what felt suspiciously like a multi-level marketing scheme to sell "dwarven" silverware in weekly installments – but it's all mired in tedium.

I think my biggest issue with Tales of the Shire, though, is that it just doesn't feel cozy. A lot of this is a visual issue. Broader environments look lovely – I love the lush green forests and hills that surround Bywater – but up close, textures are flat and plasticky. When you're out in the forest picking mushrooms, or watching the evening's sunset drizzle into the Brandywine from afar, everything's gorgeous. But the legendary Green Dragon Inn, rather than feeling like the beating heart of Bywater, is bare and empty. Hobbits look too smooth to have any character. Rain – despite being my favorite weather in any game – is pixelated and ugly, seemingly designed for smaller screens like the Switch rather than the PC I'm playing on. I'm not usually one to complain about graphics, but these visuals lack the warmth that games like Stardew Valley sorely need. 

Want more Switch 2 news?

Sign up to our Switch 2 Spotlight newsletter to make sure you get the very latest news on Nintendo's new console and its games every week

By submitting your information you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy and are aged 16 or over.

Right now, Tales of the Shire feels like a generic life sim with a thin Middle-earth veneer. I don't want it to stay that way, because there's real potential here. The tone is brilliant, and I'm really keen to see how Hobbit-hole customization opens up further into the game. Even some of my biggest gripes aren't foundational issues, as things like boring quests and patchy graphics can hopefully be improved before launch. My lingering concern, though, is that Tales of the Shire currently has a distinct lack of charm – and without that, even the promise of a second breakfast won't be enough to win me back. 


Tales of the Shire is set to launch in 2025. Until then, here are the best Lord of the Rings games you can play now. 

CATEGORIES
PC Gaming PS5 Xbox Series X Nintendo Switch Platforms PlayStation Xbox Nintendo
Andrew Brown
Andrew Brown
Social Links Navigation
Features Editor

Andy Brown is the Features Editor of Gamesradar+, where he shares a lifelong love of games with delightful readers - that's you!

From strategy games to RPGs and shooters, Andy dabbles in a bit of everything. Just don't get him started on Total War, or his delightful two huskies.

Read more
A cast of cel-shaded characters looks hopefully over the horizon with pet companions in toe
Simulation Games My new cozy obsession is a Lord of the Rings-inspired Animal Crossing riff blowing up on Kickstarter
 
 
Riding the bus in Toem 2, which is driven by a fluffy creature in a bowtie
Adventure Games Toem 2 review: "Effortlessly charming with clever puzzling, this photography adventure is worth snapping up"
 
 
4x4s in Over the Hill cross a river with canoes on the roof
Open World Games Over the Hill review: "The single most stressful game I’ve played in years and I think it hates me"
 
 
Key art for The Expanse: Osiris Reborn showing a montage of character with a crystal explosion beneath them on a white background
RPGs The Expanse: Osiris Reborn swings for the Mass Effect crown, but struggles to match my enthusiasm for the TV show
 
 
Petit Planet screenshots
Simulation Games Genshin Impact devs' new cozy life sim feels like cosmic Animal Crossing, but that's not a bad thing
 
 
Long Rest tavern key art
Management Games Long Rest Tavern is the polar opposite of Warlock, but D&D pint-slinging is its own kind of magic
 
 
Latest in Simulation Games
A bus - sorry, a "coach" - in Euro Truck Simulator 2's Coaches DLC
Simulation Games Euro Truck Simulator 2 devs are in disbelief as DLC pushes the game over 100,000 concurrent players
 
 
A blonde NPC in Fields of Mistria standing in front of a windmill and cottage while her hair blows in the background.
Simulation Games I've wanted to play this anime-inspired farming RPG for years, and I might finally get my chance
 
 
Rob Run
Simulation Games Days before GTA 6, crime game for "thousands" blows up despite "Mixed" Steam reviews and gen AI
 
 
Press shot for Criminal Simulator codes showing a robber hiding behind a counter with a money back while a cop with a flashlight searches for them
Simulation Games Criminal Simulator codes (November 2026) and how to redeem them for Cash and more
 
 
Stardew Valley Sandy
Simulation Games Stardew Valley update 1.7 may be "largest" yet, ConcernedApe says – and come "sometime next year"
 
 
A group of teenagers laugh at another teenager in a trash can in Ishin on Roblox.
Simulation Games All Ishin codes (November 2026) and how to redeem them for Rerolls and Yen
 
 
Latest in Features
A piece of GTA 6 art showing a character looking surprised, with a Black Friday deals stamp over his shoulder
Grand Theft Auto These 13 Black Friday deals will help you upgrade your GTA 6 setup
 
 
A collection of sub-$100 controllers on a desk, with a Black Friday stamp in the middle of them
Gaming Controllers These are the budget controller deals I'd recommend this Black Friday that all fall under $100
 
 
Thanos in Avengers: Infinity War
Marvel Movies Robert Downey Jr., Chris Evans, the Russo brothers, and more on the making of Avengers: Infinity War
 
 
Marvel Phase 5: Deadpool and Wolverine standing in the Void during the movie Deadpool and Wolverine.
Marvel Movies Avengers: Doomsday sounds like the darkest Marvel movie yet, which is why it needs a pinch of Deadpool & Wolverine
 
 
Joseph Zada as Haymitch Abernathy in The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping
Action Movies The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping ending explained: who dies, how do Katniss and Peeta return, and more
 
 
Robert Pattinson as James Bond
James Bond Movies Bond 26 release date speculation, cast, story theories, and everything else we know about 007's next mission
 
 
LATEST ARTICLES
  1. The second car in Wyman's Classic Car Collection is a lush '70s Riata and it can be yours if you can head to these three locations
    1
    GTA 6 Riata locations: How to restore the second car in Wyman's Classic Car Collection
  2. 2
    GTA 6 Transgressor Locations: How to restore the first car in Wyman's Classic Car Collection
  3. 3
    The Binding of Isaac removes AI-generated music from new update, and designer Edmund McMillen is "looking into how that happened"
  4. 4
    How to get Arthur Morgan's Hat in GTA 6
  5. 5
    The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time's emotional final cutscene was something Nintendo "heavily discussed"

GamesRadar+ is part of Future US Inc, an international media group and leading digital publisher. Visit our corporate site.

Add as a preferred source on Google Add as a preferred source on Google
  • About us
  • Contact Future's experts
  • Terms and conditions
  • Privacy policy
  • Cookies policy
  • Advertise with us
  • Review guidelines
  • Write for us
  • Accessibility statement
  • Careers

© Future US, Inc. Full 7th Floor, 130 West 42nd Street, New York, NY 10036.

Please login or signup to comment

Please wait...