Unlike, say, Mass Effect or Fable, you won't find any outright, objectively good endings in Fallout: New Vegas. There are more morally justifiable outcomes, but none that are straight ahead bright and optimistic. But the RPG's director, Josh Sawyer, nonetheless has a preferred conclusion – based on power dynamics.
"I mean, some people would say like, 'I love Caesar,' and great, but it's kind of hard to hand everything over to an individual like Caesar or Mr. House," he tells The Examined Game. "It feels dangerous. And then with [New California Republic], you just realize like, man, they've got a lot of problems. Like, they have a lot of problems right now. They're doing things for a lot of very questionable reasons."
The NCR is a nebulous faction, within which you may find people who are using its resources and reach to build a better tomorrow for the Mojave. But Sawyer argues, "it's difficult to wrestle with that and come away and say like, yeah, I think NCR is great."
Thus, he thinks the most worthwhile Fallout: New Vegas outcome is to give New Vegas itself the independence it so desires. "I know it's going to be dysfunctional, I know it's going to be bureaucratic, I know there's going to be corruption, but also it hasn't been tried yet, right?" Sawyer muses. "Like we haven't organized this yet, so let's give it a try."
I won't argue, given how many political situations the real world is in where it seems like any sort of alternative would be an improvement to what's happening. Plus, a running theme of Fallout is how different factions are all perpetuating the same tribalism and constant desire for power. Going for an independent New Vegas ending breaks the region out of that back-and-forth.
It's not a conclusion I've personally gotten in any of my New Vegas playthroughs... mostly because I've only played to credits once. Usually, I like to play New Vegas just to disappear into the wasteland, pretending I'm in Mad Max and going where I'm needed.
If only there was a remaster of Fallout: New Vegas coming, so others and I could have an easy opportunity to experience New Vegas' ending as Sawyer most likes. One can dream, eh?
