Should you choose Jacob or Benedict in Banishers Ghosts of New Eden

Guides
By Will Sawyer
published

For The Flesh Is Weak case in Banishers, you've got to choose between Blaming Jacob and Ascending or Banishing Benedict

Banishers: Ghost of New Eden The Flesh Is Weak Jacob and Benedict
(Image credit: Focus Entertainment)

The Banishers Ghosts of New Eden Blame Jacob or Banish Benedict choice comes right at the end of The Flesh Is Weak - the first proper case you'll complete as Red mac Raith. By now you will have learned that Jacob killed and ate his trapper companion Benedict in what might be one of the hangriest outbursts ever. It's up to you to judge him and the ghost of Benedict to bring an end to the haunting once and for all in this Banishers case.

Banishers Ghosts of New Eden Blame Jacob or Banish Benedict choice

Banishers: Ghost of New Eden The Flesh Is Weak final choice between Jacob and Benedict

(Image credit: Focus Entertainment)

Now that you've used a couple of Banishers Ghosts of New Eden rituals to get the Intents for both Jacob and Benedict, you can start the Closure phase of the Haunting Case: Blame Jacob for his misdeeds or Ascend/Banish Benedict:

  • Blame Jacob: Jacob asks for Benedict's forgiveness and is then executed by Red. Jacob also believes he deserved to die for killing and eating Ben. Meanwhile, Benedict peacefully fades away.
  • Ascend/Banish Benedict: Benedict forgives Jacob for killing him and passes on peacefully/Benedict curses Jacob and the forest before being violently exorcised. Jacob then moves to the Hunters' Camp where Thickskin Newsmith is in charge.
Banishers guides

How long is Banishers Ghosts of New Eden?
Banishers Ghosts of New Eden difficulty
Banishers Ghosts of New Eden Landfall

When making your choice, you'll notice that both options mention something to do with Antea – either Resurrecting or Ascending her. This is to with the Banishers Ghost of New Eden oath, which you will decide on after you have completed this Haunting Case. If you want to learn about the oath first, be sure to read the guide linked above before proceeding. Ultimately, the fact you swear the oath right after this case means your choice here doesn’t really matter in the long run, so choose whichever you think is morally most acceptable to you.

Banishers: Ghost of New Eden Red and Antea talking to Jacob

(Image credit: Focus Entertainment)

Furthermore, every Haunting Case in the game also has a follow-up activity to complete that changes based on your decision during the Closure. For The Flesh Is Weak, Ascending or Banishing Benedict leads to Jacob moving to the Hunters' Camp, then thinking he is in fact a werewolf, but Blaming Jacob later causes wolves to start appearing around his old lean-to camp.

© GamesRadar+. Not to be reproduced without permission.

Will Sawyer
Will Sawyer
Guides Writer

Will Sawyer is a guides writer at GamesRadar+ who works with the rest of the guides team to give readers great information and advice on the best items, how to complete a particular challenge, or where to go in some of the biggest video games. Will joined the GameRadar+ team in August 2021 and has written about service titles, including Fortnite, Destiny 2, and Warzone, as well as some of the biggest releases like Halo Infinite, Elden Ring, and God of War Ragnarok.

See comments