It turns out the future of law enforcement is also the past. The announcement that Little Monsters (opens in new tab)director Abe Forsythe is making a new RoboCop – one that reportedly pretends the sequels and 2014 reboot never happened – is clearly designed to get Generation X yelling “I’d buy that for a dollar!” And yet it seems a very risky proposition.
Sure, hardcore fans will probably lap it up, but will anyone else care? Recent history is not on RoboCop 5’s side… The evidence suggests the world has fallen out of love with movie franchises that hit big in the late ’70s and ’80s. Terminator: Dark Fate (opens in new tab) may have been the series’ best instalment since 1991’s Judgment Day, but it hardly made a killing at the box office. Alien: Covenant (opens in new tab) made a big thing of leaning closer into the parent movies than Prometheus, but ended up making 40 percent less cash.
Recent Predator (opens in new tab) and Ghostbusters (opens in new tab) reboots have also failed to do enough business to win sequels, while Halloween (opens in new tab) was considered a hit because its comparatively small budget and R-rating significantly lowered the bar for success. It’s not all about the money, of course. But ’80s reboots are often creative dead ends. Even when they’re hailed “a glorious return to form!”, films like Dark Fate are extremely limited in storytelling terms – it’s hard to stray too far from an easily recognisable formula without alienating fans.
Have any 21st-century instalments of Indiana Jones, Alien, The Terminator or Predator felt like essential additions to their respective sagas? Without them, would any of their mythologies be demonstrably weaker?
Solo (opens in new tab) and The Rise Of Skywalker (opens in new tab)'s disappointing performances showed that not even Star Wars can milk nostalgia indefinitely, so there’s a lesson here for custodians of smaller franchises. Just because people adore Stranger Things (opens in new tab) doesn’t mean they’re obsessed with the movies that inspired it – these days they’re much more interested in their stories, franchises like the MCU (opens in new tab) and Fast & Furious (opens in new tab).
As someone whose movie education began with ’80s classics, I’ll be as happy as anyone if 2020’s Ghostbusters (opens in new tab) and Top Gun (opens in new tab) sequels turn out to be must-sees. But most of the giants of that era have surely run out of exciting things to bring to the party. Or is it just me?
Each month our sister publication Total Film magazine (opens in new tab) (opens in new tab)argues a polarising movie opinion and gives you the opportunity to agree or disagree. Let us know what you think about this one in the comments below and read on for more.