Skip to main content
Games Radar Newsarama Total Film Edge Retro Gamer SFX
GamesRadar+ GamesRadar+ The smarter take on movies
flag of UK
UK
flag of US
US
flag of Canada
Canada
flag of Australia
Australia
Sign in
  • View Profile
  • Sign out
  • News
  • Reviews
  • Features
  • More
    • PS5
    • Xbox Series X
    • Nintendo Switch
    • Nintendo Switch 2
    • PC
    • Platforms
    • Tabletop Gaming
    • Comics
    • Toys & Collectibles
    • Newsarama
    • Retro Gamer
    • Newsletters
    • About us
    • Features
Gaming Magazines
Gaming Magazines
Why subscribe?
  • Subscribe from just £3
  • Takes you closer to the games, movies and TV you love
  • Try a single issue or save on a subscription
  • Issues delivered straight to your door or device
From$12
Subscribe now
Trending
  • Best Netflix Movies
  • Best movies on Disney Plus
  • Movie Release Dates
  • Best Netflix Shows
Don't miss these
David Corenswet as Superman
Superhero Movies After arguing over who would win in a fight, DC fans are debating which movie is better: Superman or Man of Steel?
David Corenswet as Superman
DC Movies Superman’s surprise message from Krypton twist changes everything we know about Kal-El’s origins in the DCU
Nicholas Hoult as Lex Luthor and David Corenswet as Superman
Superhero Movies James Gunn's Superman looks to one of the best Superman comics for inspiration, and is better for embracing its weirdness
David Corenswet as Superman inside the Fortress of Solitude in James Gunn's Superman.
DC Movies Superman review: "A triumphant reinvention and a promising start for the DCU"
David Corenswet as Superman in first look at James Gunn's new movie
DC Movies James Gunn says that controversial Superman lore change was because he allowed himself "to make changes where changes might work" and be "interesting for the DCU"
Hideo Kojima speaking at Sydney Film Festival about Death Stranding 2
DC Movies Hideo Kojima finally weighs in on James Gunn's Superman, a "heartwarming 'human' film": "It was neither dark nor stylish, cool or even 'super'"
James Gunn
DC Movies After embracing Superman's Silver Age heritage, James Gunn says some comic book movies can be "pretentious" and "distance themselves from the source material"
Henry Cavill as Superman in Man of Steel
Superhero Movies Superman discourse has already reached the playground argument stage: who would win in a fight – David Corenswet's Superman or Henry Cavill's Superman?
Henry Cavill as Superman
DC Movies James Gunn's Superman actor David Corenswet compares Man of Steel's Zack Snyder and Henry Cavill to Christopher Nolan's Batman because they showed "a side of Superman that hadn't been explored on the big screen"
David Corenswet as Superman
DC Movies Superman has his trunks in James Gunn's DC movie, but the decision was only made at the very last moment after one crew member "refused to give up"
David Corenswet as Superman in James Gunn's Superman
Superhero Movies James Gunn's Superman looks like a comics-accurate take on the Man of Steel at last – but will it be enough to revive DC at the box office?
David Corenswet as Superman with Krypto the dog and a robot in the Fortress of Solitude.
DC Movies James Gunn's Superman has finally found the cure to superhero movie fatigue: just make them more like comics
Superman movies ranked: Christopher Reeve as Superman flying through the sky during the 1978 movie Superman.
Superhero Movies All the Superman movies ranked from worst to best
David Corenswet as Superman kneels by a broken robot in the new Superman movie.
DC Movies Superman's big box-office takings prove the new superhero movie has done what it was supposed to: win "back the trust of our DC fans"
David Corenswet and Rachel Brosnahan in Superman
DC Movies Superman debuts to strong Rotten Tomatoes score, with critics calling James Gunn's new DC movie "charming," "playful," and "a breath of fresh air"
  1. Entertainment
  2. Movies
  3. Action Movies

Zack Snyder's Superman: Pros and Cons

Features
By Matt Maytum published 6 October 2010

Did Chris Nolan make the right choice?

When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here’s how it works.

Pro: He can handle 'difficult' properties

Pro: He can handle 'difficult' properties

Zack Snyder has been announced as the person to direct Christopher Nolan and David Goyer's Superman reboot. He emerged as the victor from one of the most varied shortlists of recent times (Darren Aronofsky, Matt Reeves, Tony Scott and Duncan Jones were all rumoured).

You can bet that that the word Watchmen was scribbled, underlined and highlighted on Nolan and Goyer's notepad. Adapting Alan Moore's masterpiece was no mean feat; Terry Gilliam and Paul Greengrass were among the directors who had previously failed in their attempts to bring the comic to the big screen.

Snyder delivered an extremely faithful adaptation of the source material, and created an effective alternate reality for the troubled superheroes. No-one quite knows what Nolan has planned for Kal-El, but Snyder has proved he can handle iconic characters in a grittily stylised environment.

Page 1 of 16
Page 1 of 16
Con: Not all of his comic adaptations are so good

Con: Not all of his comic adaptations are so good

For everyone who pulls out the Watchmen card in Snyder's favour, there's going to be someone slamming down the 300 trump with a smirk.

Yes, it made muchos bucks at the box office, despite being one of those films that seemingly no-one will admit to liking. 300 had Snyder at his most unrestrainedly adolescent: the characters had as much depth as shadow puppets, greasy abs abounded in a relentlessly homoerotic flurry, and casual racism snuck in amidst the endless, stylish-but-weightless battle scenes. And don't get us started on the slow-mo.

And we're praying that Snyder's involvement doesn't mean that Gerard Butler's name is going to be touted for Clark Kent.

Page 2 of 16
Page 2 of 16
Pro: He's great with action and FX

Pro: He's great with action and FX

If you've seen the trailer for Sucker Punch you'll know that Snyder has a pretty limitless imagination when it comes to large-scale smackdowns, and he's an authority on integrating CGI into live-action movies.

One of the things that was arguably lacking in Bryan Singer's Superman Returns was any kind of epic battle for Clark Kent's alter-ego. With the rumour mill claiming that General Zod is going to be The Man of Steel 's antagonist, we can just imagine Snyder dreaming up some suitably grandstanding face-offs.

If the Sucker Punch fight sequences are anything to go by, Snyder could well make Supes cool again.

Page 3 of 16
Page 3 of 16
Con: Is he concerned with style over substance?

Con: Is he concerned with style over substance?

Perhaps the key criticism to be levelled at Zach Snyder is that his movies often favour style over substance.

Even 300 actually looked good. It just struggled with little elements such as plot and characterisation. Watchmen looked awesome on the big screen, but most critics seemed to think that Snyder should have done a bit more adapting, rather than opting for an admittedly-beautiful straight rendering.

One of the enduring strengths of Nolan's Batmovies is his ability, and willingness, to really get under the skin of the Caped Crusader. We know Snyder can make Superman look awesome, but will The Man of Steel have any depth?

Page 4 of 16
Page 4 of 16
Pro: He's not too close to the project

Pro: He's not too close to the project

Zack Snyder has spoken candidly about his relationship with Superman. He told Entertainment Weekly: "I've followed Superman over the years. I wouldn't say I was a huge fan but I've kept an eye on the character in the pop culture, and as the pop culture has regarded him, for the past 10 years, especially."

Snyder is clearly not besotted with the character, which could position him as the right director to take a new look at the revered icon. He'll be entering the project as a filmmaker rather than a fanboy, and could use his unclouded judgment and filmmaking know-how to make decisions in the best interests of the movie (and the audience).

As he won't be carrying his own preconceptions, he should hopefully be open to Nolan and Goyer's apparently groundbreaking take on Krypton's favourite son.

Page 5 of 16
Page 5 of 16
Con: He's not too close to the project

Con: He's not too close to the project

Could Snyder's distance from the subject matter actually be detrimental to The Man of Steel ?

Singer's unfairly-maligned Superman Returns didn't exactly relaunch the franchise in the way that Warner Bros were hoping it would, but Singer's all-out affection for the character made for a movie that spoke to your inner nostalgia, bringing a sweet reminder of the days when you marvelled in wide-eyed wonder at the vastness of the cinema screen.

Maybe a character like Superman, who uses his godlike superpowers for good deeds, needs the old-school movie magic approach. It'll be interesting to learn exactly what the team have in store when more details of the new approach filter through.

Page 6 of 16
Page 6 of 16
Pro: He is a versatile filmmaker

Pro: He is a versatile filmmaker

Zack Snyder has risen to a number of challenges in the space of a relatively short (so far) career.

With Dawn of the Dead , he turned a beloved property into one of the only well-received horror remakes of the decade. He tackled the 'greatest comic ever' and has gone on to conjure up an action-fantasy of his own creation in Sucker Punch .

Between those two recent projects, Snyder has somehow found time to direct family-friendly owl animation Legend of the Guardians: The Owls of Ga'Hoole .

Seemingly unpeturbed by changes in tone, Superman shouldn't give Snyder any reason to lose sleep. Besides, if he can combine the gritty world of Watchmen , the stunning action sequences of Sucker Punch , and the wholesome adventuring of Guardians , he could really be on to something.

Page 7 of 16
Page 7 of 16
Con: Is Superman enough of a challenge?

Con: Is Superman enough of a challenge?

Snyder clearly likes a bit of variety in his projects.

Over the last six years he has ticked off: horror remake; revisionist swords and sandals epic; alternate reality (not-so-super)hero tale; fantastical barnyard-bird adventure; and reality-bending, kick-ass actioner. Is Superman going to be the change of pace he needs? Will the task of putting the iconic character into 'a modern context' be enough to get the creative juices going?

There's a risk of directorial boredom if Snyder is going to be asked to produce a thinly-veiled Watchmen redo. Hopefully Nolan's got something far more tantalising lined up.

Page 8 of 16
Page 8 of 16
Pro: He has a knack for casting

Pro: He has a knack for casting

One of Watchmen 's indubitable successes was in its casting.

Patrick Wilson, Jeffrey Dean Morgan and Jackie Earle Haley were perfect as Nite Owl, The Comedian and Rorschach respectively, and Malin Ackerman and Matthew Goode defied the 'too young' cries to turn in unexpectedly decent approximations of their comic book counterparts.

Dawn of the Dead attracted indie brainbox Sarah Polley, and Snyder tapped a pre-fame Michael Fassbender for 300 . Legends of the Guardians has a sparklingly starry voice-cast.

The casting for The Man of Steel will be the biggest rumour magnet of the next few months. With Jon Hamm appearing in Sucker Punch , expect him to be the butt of a great deal of speculation. Will Snyder get one of his badass Sucker Punch lovelies back as a non-wimpy Lois Lane? It's almost a shame that Fassbender is playing the young Magneto in X-Men: First Class as he'd have made an awesome Zod.

Page 9 of 16
Page 9 of 16
Con: Can he do character?

Con: Can he do character?

While he's a proven quantity when it comes to cool, can Snyder deliver when it comes to character?

Dawn struggled under the weight of too many characters; 300 confused manliness with shouting. Watchmen contained some top performances, and indeed, some 'cool' characters, but none of them were sympathetic. Perhaps a positive sign is that the most convincing character was blue Übermensch Dr Manhattan. Perhaps Snyder will find some humanity in DC's other all-powerful super being?

Sucker Punch
and Legends of the Guardians will also act as interesting experiments to see if Snyder has made any developments at all in terms of character investment.

Critics are bound to have their "THIS! IS! KRYPTON!" gags lined up so Snyder best be careful.

Page 10 of 16
Page 10 of 16
Pro: He has a great relationship with Warner Bros

Pro: He has a great relationship with Warner Bros

Zack Snyder's close working relationship with Warner Bros means that he'll be able to get cracking on Superman the moment Sucker Punch is in the can.

He's obviously been trusted in the past, as they allowed him to deliver a defiantly 'adult' cut of Watchmen , the 'hard R' that any successful adap of the property needed to be.

In fact, golden boys Snyder and Nolan could very well have Warner Bros eating out of the palm of their hands.

Page 11 of 16
Page 11 of 16
Con: Watchmen didn't hit as big as expected

Con: Watchmen didn't hit as big as expected

Watchmen opened to reasonable critical praise, and Snyder's faithful translation of Alan Moore's comic seemed to have the fanboy worked up into a frenzy.

Then the box office numbers came in. It wasn't a disaster, taking $55m in the first weekend, and reaching $185m worldwide by the end of its run. But those weren't the numbers that the suits needed, especially considering the budget was supposedly substantially far north of $100m.

Compare that with Superman Returns 'disappointing' worldwide figures of $391m. Warner Bros need this reboot to be a mega-hit, are they going to be willing to take any risks with the material? Will Snyder's creative clout still have weight? Let's see how Guardians and Sucker Punch perform…

Page 12 of 16
Page 12 of 16
Pro: Superman needs simplifying

Pro: Superman needs simplifying

Superman is not an inherently dark character, everything fibre of his being screams golden age.

With Snyder's keen visual sense and eye for style, perhaps we will finally see Supes distilled down to what he does best: flying, fighting enormous adversaries, and generally helping to avert large-scale disaster. Snyder certainly knows how to please the Saturday night multiplex crowds.

The Superman origin story has been done well several times. What we need know is an out-and-out adventure, showcasing what Superman can do. If anyone can take the icon and turn in a movie that's downright fun, surely it's Snyder.

Page 13 of 16
Page 13 of 16
Con: Superman needs to be classical

Con: Superman needs to be classical

Many people take umbrage with the fact that Superman is practically indestructible. He's faster than a speeding bullet, he can lift aeroplanes with ease, and he does it all with a self-satisfied grin. But that's what he does. That's how he has endured over the years.

Batman was always the cool one; Nolan simply knew how to tap his potential in a real world scenario. Does Superman need a Spielberg or an Eastwood to do his classical sensibilities justice?

With Snyder there's the distinct risk of everything being too, well, cool … Here's hoping John Williams' brass and percussion isn't usurped by some unholy nu-metal.

Page 14 of 16
Page 14 of 16
Pro: Nolan has faith

Pro: Nolan has faith

When all else fails, remember this: Christopher Nolan is the 'godfather' of this project. So good, they had to give him a title much cooler than 'exec producer'.

He has delivered the two greatest superhero movies of the last decade (and, you could pretty well argue, ever). He takes his time. He knocks out amazing cinematic treats in-between. If this modern master trusts Snyder to helm his fresh take on Superman, who are we to argue.

Snyder's going to be sticking to a template laid down by the Batman team, who'll hopefully be looking over his shoulder to put him in line should he start to drift off course.

Page 15 of 16
Page 15 of 16
Con: Was he the best of the bunch?

Con: Was he the best of the bunch?

If only we hadn't seen Nolan's shortlist.

Sure, Snyder's no less than solid, and he has the credentials to easily rank him 'a safe pair of hands'. And let's be thankful that Tony Scott is nowhere near Kal-El.

But imagine what Aronofsky could have done with The Man of Steel ? He's a director who churns out challenging and visually-stunning movies again and again, and he'd surely be game after formerly coming so close to helming a Batmovie.

Or Duncan Jones? The Moon man did wonderful things with a tiny budget, he clearly has respect for old-school traditions, and he could be amazing given a bigger field to play on (and it'd be great to see 'the godfather' supporting the little guy).

Or even Matt Reeves? Cloverfield proved he could root epic sci-fi firmly in reality, and with Let Me In he sensitively handled the characters from a revered source material.

When you daydream about these possibilities, Snyder's appointment loses a bit of its lustre...

Page 16 of 16
Page 16 of 16
Matt Maytum
Matt Maytum
Social Links Navigation
Editor, Total Film

I'm the Editor at Total Film magazine, overseeing the running of the mag, and generally obsessing over all things Nolan, Kubrick and Pixar. Over the past decade I've worked in various roles for TF online and in print, including at GamesRadar+, and you can often hear me nattering on the Inside Total Film podcast. Bucket-list-ticking career highlights have included reporting from the set of Tenet and Avengers: Infinity War, as well as covering Comic-Con, TIFF and the Sundance Film Festival.

See more Movies Features
Read more
David Corenswet as Superman
After arguing over who would win in a fight, DC fans are debating which movie is better: Superman or Man of Steel?
David Corenswet as Superman
Superman’s surprise message from Krypton twist changes everything we know about Kal-El’s origins in the DCU
Nicholas Hoult as Lex Luthor and David Corenswet as Superman
James Gunn's Superman looks to one of the best Superman comics for inspiration, and is better for embracing its weirdness
David Corenswet as Superman inside the Fortress of Solitude in James Gunn's Superman.
Superman review: "A triumphant reinvention and a promising start for the DCU"
David Corenswet as Superman in first look at James Gunn's new movie
James Gunn says that controversial Superman lore change was because he allowed himself "to make changes where changes might work" and be "interesting for the DCU"
Hideo Kojima speaking at Sydney Film Festival about Death Stranding 2
Hideo Kojima finally weighs in on James Gunn's Superman, a "heartwarming 'human' film": "It was neither dark nor stylish, cool or even 'super'"
Latest in Action Movies
Robert Pattinson in The Batman
Clayface set photos tease a connection to The Batman, and fans are hoping that Matt Reeves' Elseworlds movies will merge with the DCU
Olga Kurylenko as Taskmaster in Marvel's Thunderbolts*
A new behind-the-scenes Thunderbolts photo is making fans even more disappointed with one character death: "She showed her face for like two seconds for absolutely no reason"
Ant-Man and the Wasp Quantumania
Avengers: Doomsday directors tease it's even bigger than Endgame as Paul Rudd hints at more practical, "jaw dropping" sets in the MCU crossover
Joseph Quinn as Johnny Storm in The Fantastic Four_ First Steps
The Fantastic Four: First Steps has finally crossed a major box office milestone over 1 month after release, but only just
Viola Davis as Amanda Waller in Black Adam
James Gunn provides update on Amanda Waller series
Thor: Love and Thunder
Chris Hemsworth says Thor 5 happening depends on one important detail
Latest in Features
Borderlands 4 screenshot shows someone holding a weapon forward towards the camera.
"We tend to commit to the bit": Gearbox boss Randy Pitchford talks Borderlands 4, the evolution of looter-shooters, and $80 game discourse
Valor Mortis
Ghostrunner devs abandon parkour for Valor Mortis, a first-person soulslike that might explain why the rest of the genre follows Dark Souls' lead
A mech firing a machine gun in the desert in Menace
Menace is an XCOM-Warhammer hybrid that makes turn-based strategy feel like an immersive sim, and for the first time in my life I'm playing a game that seems made for me
Metal Gear Solid 5 showing Snake and Ocelot looking to the horizon in front of more soldiers
10 years later, Metal Gear Solid 5 remains a masterpiece that was never going to live up to its own hype
Dogtooth
The new Yorgos Lanthimos movie is getting rave first reactions out of Venice Film Festival, but I think it's worth revisiting his breakout feature Dogtooth before Bugonia hits theaters this fall
Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2 Legacy of the Forge DLC showing Henry and two allies standing looking down
I built a home and ran a business in Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2's next DLC, and the added role-playing guarantees I'll spend another 70 hours in my current game of the year
  1. Kaser clad in black and Victor in white clash swords in Lost Soul Aside
    1
    Lost Soul Aside review: "We (don't) have Final Fantasy Versus 13 at home"
  2. 2
    Hell is Us review: "The lack of waypoints and explicit objectives is a double-edged magical sword that pulls me deep into its harsh world"
  3. 3
    Shuten Order review: "The Danganronpa creator's new multi-genre mystery feels like a forgotten DS cult classic I would have been obsessed with"
  4. 4
    The Rogue Prince of Persia review: "I roguelike but don't roguelove this freerunner – there's just not enough to stand out"
  5. 5
    Shinobi: Art of Vengeance review: "So close to being to a pitch-perfect revival of a classic series, but just can't quite line up the killing blow"
  1. Jacob Elordi as the monster in Guillermo del Toro's Frankenstein
    1
    Frankenstein review: "A classy, if somewhat safe, adaptation"
  2. 2
    Weapons review: "A twisted fairytale that bests Barbarian"
  3. 3
    The Fantastic Four: First Steps review: "An occasionally thrilling heroic adventure that sits safely within a B-tier MCU range"
  4. 4
    Superman review: "A triumphant reinvention and a promising start for the DCU"
  5. 5
    Jurassic World Rebirth Review: "An unscary sequel that needed a little more time in amber"
  1. John Cena as Peacemaker holds a gun to the head of a different John Cena as Peacemaker in Peacemaker season 2.
    1
    Peacemaker season 2 review: "Darker and sadder than the first year, but there's still a lot of fun to be had with the 11th Street Kids."
  2. 2
    Wednesday season 2 part 1 review: "Complex and exciting but weighed down by too many subplots"
  3. 3
    Alien: Earth review: "Arguably the franchise's strongest outing since James Cameron's Aliens"
  4. 4
    King of the Hill season 14 review: "Hank Hill himself has evolved into a much more open and accepting person"
  5. 5
    Eyes of Wakanda review: "A creative premise shortchanged by the runtime and Marvel bloat"

GamesRadar+ is part of Future US Inc, an international media group and leading digital publisher. Visit our corporate site.

  • About Us
  • Contact Future's experts
  • Terms and conditions
  • Privacy policy
  • Cookies policy
  • Advertise with us
  • Review guidelines
  • Write for us
  • Accessibility Statement
  • Careers

© Future US, Inc. Full 7th Floor, 130 West 42nd Street, New York, NY 10036.

Please login or signup to comment

Please wait...