God of War II (PS2)
We still hold the first God of War in impossibly high regard. It's a classic. And while its sequel is every bit as impressive and compelling as its predecessor, it had two things going against it. Firstly, it didn't offer very much new in terms of the core experience and, secondly, it was on PS2 when all the attention was focused on next-gen. Gone already.
Above: A tour-de-force. But released for a superceded console and so passed up by many