Deus Ex and Mass Effect devs argue over 'Aug Lives Matter'

TODO alt text

Quick catch up if you've missed it: a recent piece of Deus Ex Mankind Divided concept art uses the phrase 'Aug Lives Matter', obviously referencing the 'Black Lives Matter' movement. And understandably that's upset people. 

Let's just skip right past the 'all lives' argument, because not 'all' lives face discrimination and threats based on appearance. That's the point of the statement. So, obviously, people have some quite strong opinions of a game co-opting such a sensitive phrase.

Deus Ex has already used things like 'Mechanical Apartheid' to help colour its portrayal of a normal/augmented split in humanity. That alone raised a few eyebrows, but less of a fuss due its more historical context. This involves something that is an issue now. 

The conflict's spilled out onto Twitter where Andre Vu, Deus Ex Mankind Divided's global executive brand director and Manveer Heir, Mass Effect: Andromeda gameplay designer, have discussed the situation at length:

You can see the full exchange here. I agree with Manveer. Whenever the phrase may have entered the game's production and in whatever context, there's no escaping it's taking from a current and highly sensitive movement that's affecting people everyday. 

If there's a workable justification in-game, as Andre seems to suggest, then let the game explain it - don't pull out a single frame with no context. All games, films and fiction absorb real world stuff but there's a difference between using it to tell a story or enhance a narrative, and just 'using' it. 

Seen something newsworthy? Tell us!

Topics

OPM
oxm
We recommend