GamesRadar E3 2011 Awards: Proof that 2D isn't dead

In our minds 2D never died, but try telling that some of the game publishers of the last decade. That’s why we love seeing flat graphics get some love, whether it’s in a full-fledged release or a downloadable. E3 had no shortage of great new 2D titles, but which impressed us most?

The Nominees:

Insanely Twisted Shadow Planet

Insanely Twisted Shadow Planet has already won us over with its charming aesthetics and enigmatic tale of alien infestation, but it really hooked us with the evocative, shadowy design. How can spacey, alien tendrils move so fluidly?Preview (opens in new tab)

BloodRayne Betrayal

Developer WayForward knows a thing or two about modern 2D gaming. Contra 4, A Boy and His Blob and Shantae: Risky’s Revenge are all shining examples of sprites done right, each one offering a grand throwback to 8- and 16-bit sensibilities. But up until now, WayForward has worked in standard definition, and even then within a relatively family-friendly mindset. BloodRayne, on the other hand, is stupendously bloody and flat-out gorgeous to see in HD; we know this number is part of WayForward’s marketing speil, but it’s still worth mentioning that Rayne herself has 4000 frames of animation. Not pre-rendered sprites or 3D models with a cel-shaded sheen, but 4000 frames of animation. Nice. Preview (opens in new tab)

Rayman Origins

One year ago Rayman Origins was first revealed as a charming downloadable, and 365 days later it has grown into a retail game and has only grown lovelier. Michel Ancel seems dedicated to give this 2D game the kind of AAA treatment they got before the PlayStation showed up, creating a world that looks nothing short of a living cartoon.Preview (opens in new tab)

Kirby Mass Attack

While the new Kirby game on Wii looks like a nice return to form, Mass Attack is forging new ground in the world of two dimensional pink puffballs. A mash-up of a side-scroller and RTS, Mass Attack features a team of cute Kirbys out to save the world. It might just be the last good game to hit the DS.

And the winner is%26hellip;

BloodRayne Betrayal

Each of these games is worth applauding. But only one can walk away the winner, and seeing as we’ve already propped a spotlight on Rayman Origins (opens in new tab)we felt now’s the time to officially acknowledge BloodRayne Betrayal. Its impressive animations, sprites, music and absolutely everything else that make it a modern Super NES game are too well done and too captivating to watch for us to settle on any other game in this category. Oh, we’ll play (and likely love) everything on this page, but the idea of a lavishly animated, hyper-bloody slash-em-up really pushes all our buttons. So strange – a month ago we couldn’t have cared less about BloodRayne, and never would have expected her to return. But here we are, genuinely excited about her next game. Maybe some hardcore ‘Rayne fans (you’re out there, right?) have a problem with this old-school direction, but as for GamesRadar, we are so damn down.

Swipe to scroll horizontally
Row 0 - Cell 0
MONDAY:
Most graphics (opens in new tab) | Coolest character reinvention
Best response to fan feedback (opens in new tab)
TUESDAY:
Best trailer (opens in new tab) | Most satisfying gore (opens in new tab) | Guiltiest pleasure (opens in new tab)
Most shameless rip-off (opens in new tab)
WEDNESDAY:
Best new game we know nothing about (opens in new tab)
Worst first impression (opens in new tab) | Best game for masochists (opens in new tab)
THURSDAY:
Most likely to consume our lives (opens in new tab) | Artsiest-fartsiest (opens in new tab)
Most tasteless (opens in new tab)
FRIDAY:
Might not actually suck (opens in new tab) | Proof that 2D isn't dead (opens in new tab) | BEST OF SHOW (opens in new tab)

The Nominees:

Insanely Twisted Shadow Planet

Insanely Twisted Shadow Planet has already won us over with its charming aesthetics and enigmatic tale of alien infestation, but it really hooked us with the evocative, shadowy design. How can spacey, alien tendrils move so fluidly?Preview (opens in new tab)

BloodRayne Betrayal

Developer WayForward knows a thing or two about modern 2D gaming. Contra 4, A Boy and His Blob and Shantae: Risky’s Revenge are all shining examples of sprites done right, each one offering a grand throwback to 8- and 16-bit sensibilities. But up until now, WayForward has worked in standard definition, and even then within a relatively family-friendly mindset. BloodRayne, on the other hand, is stupendously bloody and flat-out gorgeous to see in HD; we know this number is part of WayForward’s marketing speil, but it’s still worth mentioning that Rayne herself has 4000 frames of animation. Not pre-rendered sprites or 3D models with a cel-shaded sheen, but 4000 frames of animation. Nice. Preview (opens in new tab)

Rayman Origins

One year ago Rayman Origins was first revealed as a charming downloadable, and 365 days later it has grown into a retail game and has only grown lovelier. Michel Ancel seems dedicated to give this 2D game the kind of AAA treatment they got before the PlayStation showed up, creating a world that looks nothing short of a living cartoon.Preview (opens in new tab)

Kirby Mass Attack

While the new Kirby game on Wii looks like a nice return to form, Mass Attack is forging new ground in the world of two dimensional pink puffballs. A mash-up of a side-scroller and RTS, Mass Attack features a team of cute Kirbys out to save the world. It might just be the last good game to hit the DS.

BloodRayne Betrayal

Developer WayForward knows a thing or two about modern 2D gaming. Contra 4, A Boy and His Blob and Shantae: Risky’s Revenge are all shining examples of sprites done right, each one offering a grand throwback to 8- and 16-bit sensibilities. But up until now, WayForward has worked in standard definition, and even then within a relatively family-friendly mindset. BloodRayne, on the other hand, is stupendously bloody and flat-out gorgeous to see in HD; we know this number is part of WayForward’s marketing speil, but it’s still worth mentioning that Rayne herself has 4000 frames of animation. Not pre-rendered sprites or 3D models with a cel-shaded sheen, but 4000 frames of animation. Nice. Preview (opens in new tab)

Rayman Origins

One year ago Rayman Origins was first revealed as a charming downloadable, and 365 days later it has grown into a retail game and has only grown lovelier. Michel Ancel seems dedicated to give this 2D game the kind of AAA treatment they got before the PlayStation showed up, creating a world that looks nothing short of a living cartoon.Preview (opens in new tab)

Kirby Mass Attack

While the new Kirby game on Wii looks like a nice return to form, Mass Attack is forging new ground in the world of two dimensional pink puffballs. A mash-up of a side-scroller and RTS, Mass Attack features a team of cute Kirbys out to save the world. It might just be the last good game to hit the DS.

And the winner is%26hellip;

BloodRayne Betrayal

Each of these games is worth applauding. But only one can walk away the winner, and seeing as we’ve already propped a spotlight on Rayman Origins (opens in new tab)we felt now’s the time to officially acknowledge BloodRayne Betrayal. Its impressive animations, sprites, music and absolutely everything else that make it a modern Super NES game are too well done and too captivating to watch for us to settle on any other game in this category. Oh, we’ll play (and likely love) everything on this page, but the idea of a lavishly animated, hyper-bloody slash-em-up really pushes all our buttons. So strange – a month ago we couldn’t have cared less about BloodRayne, and never would have expected her to return. But here we are, genuinely excited about her next game. Maybe some hardcore ‘Rayne fans (you’re out there, right?) have a problem with this old-school direction, but as for GamesRadar, we are so damn down.



MONDAY:
Most graphics (opens in new tab) | Coolest character reinvention
Best response to fan feedback (opens in new tab)
TUESDAY:
Best trailer (opens in new tab) | Most satisfying gore (opens in new tab) | Guiltiest pleasure (opens in new tab)
Most shameless rip-off (opens in new tab)
WEDNESDAY:
Best new game we know nothing about (opens in new tab)
Worst first impression (opens in new tab) | Best game for masochists (opens in new tab)
THURSDAY:
Most likely to consume our lives (opens in new tab) | Artsiest-fartsiest (opens in new tab)
Most tasteless (opens in new tab)
FRIDAY:
Might not actually suck (opens in new tab) | Proof that 2D isn't dead (opens in new tab) | BEST OF SHOW (opens in new tab)

GamesRadar+ was first founded in 1999, and since then has been dedicated to delivering video game-related news, reviews, previews, features, and more. Since late 2014, the website has been the online home of Total Film, SFX, Edge, and PLAY magazines, with comics site Newsarama joining the fold in 2020. Our aim as the global GamesRadar Staff team is to take you closer to the games, movies, TV shows, and comics that you love. We want to upgrade your downtime, and help you make the most of your time, money, and skills. We always aim to entertain, inform, and inspire through our mix of content - which includes news, reviews, features, tips, buying guides, and videos.