Join The Community
One of the creepier mysteries in the Red Dead Redemption games surrounds the 'Strange Man', an unnamed gentleman in a top hat who makes recurring appearances. He has an ethereal presence in Red Dead Redemption 2 and its predecessor, haunting John Marston and sparking rumors among NPCs.
Dan Houser, co-founder of Rockstar Games, doesn't have too many answers on what's going on with the character, but he does provide more context as to their creation. "We felt we needed more story so we, quite late in development, started putting in almost like this RPG-type content where you'd go and meet someone, and they'd be like short stories," he remembers on the Lex Fridman Podcast.
"We tried to make them these short stories with a sting in the tail, and he came out as just this weird character," Houser continues. "And then we built a bit into the story where he would unlock as you were making your way through, and be a commentary on what you were doing."
The Strange Man, as Houser sees it, was meant to be a "manifestation of your shadow, your karma, the devil," and something "any artist is scared of: a creative who's kind of sold his soul to the devil." Both of those things are frightening in their own way, giving the black-suited man an even more ghostly aura.
These vignettes came about after Rockstar realized without the cars, machine guns, cities, and most of the people wandering about, Red Dead Redemption was just about "a dude riding a horse in the desert," which was "quite boring." The world needed more stimulation, and what better than an elusive phantom? Players figured there was something not quite right about the figure after the end of the first RDR, where John Marston shoots at him but the bullets appear to do nothing.
"He knows what you're up to, but what's never made clear is, does he know this about everybody?" Houser adds. "Is he following you, or is he able, because of the pact he's made with evil forces, able to do this for everybody? I don't think we ever clarify that."
It's still unclarified now, but it's fascinating to hear Houser's take as one of the main developers. We'll have to see how the man reappears in Red Dead Redemption 3, whenever that arrives.
