Skip to main content

Xbox controller drift lawsuit will also be settled out of court

xbox series x controller series s

Update - April 19: The long-running class action lawsuit alleging rampant drifting issues with Xbox controllers will be settled out of court, much like the Nintendo Switch Joy-Con lawsuit from 2020. 

As The Loadout reports, legal partner Benjamin Johns of US law firm CSK&D confirmed that the case has entered arbitration, a move that usually marks the "end of the road" for lawsuits like these since it all but guarantees they'll never reach a public court. Nevertheless, the firm claims that it received a "sufficient volume" of faulty controllers to highlight the alleged controller design flaw, and it will still seek damages for its many plaintiffs. 

Microsoft pushed for arbitration earlier this year on the grounds that the Microsoft Services Agreement, which all of these plaintiffs would have needed to accept to use things like Xbox Live, blocks such lawsuits from going to court. With the Joy-Con precedent in its favor, the company's now gotten its wish. 

Original story - January 4: 

Microsoft says that the class action lawsuit over the Xbox controller drift should be taken out of the courtroom. A new motion, filed by Microsoft (via VGC), claims that the suit's plaintiffs all agreed to the company's Services Agreement, which states that disputes should be settled by arbitration and an impartial adjudicator, rather than a jury.

The lawsuit was originally filed in April 2019, and alleges that drifting issues caused by wear on the controllers is the result of a design flaw that Microsoft was aware of, but did not inform customers of. In October, seven plaintiffs were added in an amendment to the original suit which also demanded the issue be settled in front of a jury.

Microsoft, however, argues that this shouldn't be the way the suit is resolved, as every plaintiff listed in the case "repeatedly agreed not to bring a lawsuit like this in court," when they "assented to the Microsoft Services Agreement" by using the controller as well as other Microsoft services, such as Xbox Live.

While perhaps not as prolific a problem as the Nintendo Switch's notorious Joy-Con drift, the lawsuit claims that Xbox controller drift has been an issue since 2014, one which Microsoft has failed to disclose to customers and "routinely" refused to fix. 

Nintendo has faced its fair share of class-action suits over issues with its controllers, but last year, a judge allowed one of those lawsuits to be settled by arbitration, which could set an important precedent in Microsoft's favour. There's no word on when the suit may be settled, but it won't be until after the arbitration debate has been settled one way or another.

Still looking for a new console? Check out our Xbox Series X review.

Ali Jones

I'm GamesRadar's deputy news editor, working with Ben T across our gaming news articles. I started my journalistic career while getting my degree in English Literature at the University of Warwick, where I also worked as Games Editor on the student newspaper, The Boar. Since then, I've run the news sections at PCGamesN and Kotaku UK, and also regularly contributed to PC Gamer. As you might be able to tell, PC is my platform of choice, so you can regularly find me playing League of Legends or Steam's latest indie hit.