PS3 to make used games illegal? Thankfully, no

Not content to get all of the controversy regarding PlayStation 3 out in the open during E3 06 - see ourstoryregarding the sky-high price; the motion-sensitive, non-rumbling controller; and the differences between the two PS3 models - Sonyapparently saved some for later.

Our UK companion siterecently posted anarticleoutlining a claim that certain UK retailers have been informed that they will be unable to sell used PlayStation 3 games.

Sony does indeed have thepatented ability tocreate PS3 games that must be registered the first time they're inserted into your PS3, andcould then only play on that specific PS3. This would obviously bothseverely hindergame piracyand also torpedo used game sales.

However, this rumor is apparently just that: a rumor. Despite contacting several industry insiders, neither GamesRadar US or its other companion site,, could seem to verify the UK retailer's story. NextGen's take on the scene can be foundhere, complete with quotes fromvarious of industry insiders sounding bewildered and incredulous.

Sony's US office could neitherallay nor confirm our fears. Kimberly Otzman, senior manager of corporate communications, offered, "We can't comment on rumors or speculation. We plan on announcing the [launch] lineup as we get closer to the launch in November. We haven't made any announcement on used game sales."

For our part, GamesRadar US contacted over a dozen industry insiders, and none have yetheard of such a plan. Many ceded that a system which locked a disc to a console (and which Sony has a patent on, incidentally) could be a useful tool to combat piracy, and that many publishers and developers would welcome the extinction of used game sales, which they view as little more than legalized piracy.

However, those same insiders also agreed that such a plan would enrage both retailers - many of which rely heavily on the sales of used games forincome- and game-buying consumers themselves.

Finally, Jennie Kong, UK PR Manager at SCEEtold the UK newspaper The Guardianthat "this is false speculation and that PlayStation 3 software will not be copy protected to a single machine but will be playable on any PlayStation 3 console."

So that's that. Sony, as it turns out,isn't doing everything they possibly can to send consumers running to 360, Wii, PC and basically any console other than a PS3.

May 24, 2006

Eric Bratcher
I was the founding Executive Editor/Editor in Chief here at GR, charged with making sure we published great stories every day without burning down the building or getting sued. Which isn't nearly as easy as you might imagine. I don't work for GR any longer, but I still come here - why wouldn't I? It's awesome. I'm a fairly average person who has nursed an above average love of video games since I first played Pong just over 30 years ago. I entered the games journalism world as a freelancer and have since been on staff at the magazines Next Generation and PSM before coming over to GamesRadar. Outside of gaming, I also love music (especially classic metal and hard rock), my lovely wife, my pet pig Bacon, Japanese monster movies, and my dented, now dearly departed '89 Ranger pickup truck. I pray sincerely. I cheer for the Bears, Bulls, and White Sox. And behind Tyler Nagata, I am probably the GR staffer least likely to get arrested... again.