Costume Quest 2 review

I am Thomas Jefferson, and I have just signed the Declaration of Destruction. I leap into the air like a Power Ranger in a powdered wig and hurl a scroll at my enemy. My opponent--some kind of oily goblin--pops on his reading spectacles and scans the words, before being blown to quivering pieces. It’s a pleasing centre point between cartoon slapstick and spine-shivering awesomeness. But wait! I am, for the purposes of a dramatic introduction designed to keep you reading, a massive liar. And while I may not actually be Thomas Jefferson, this is exactly the kind of sticky-fingered lunacy that passes for normality in Costume Quest 2.

It’s basically a big, fat empowerment fantasy for every kid that’s ever been purple nurpled, wedgied or spitballed. There’s no meanness or spite here, though: exactly like the first game, it’s a chocolate-dipped monument to dressing up in flimsy costumes and collecting candy, built on surprisingly sturdy RPG foundations.

To begin with, I find myself back in pumpkin-adorned suburbs on Halloween night. It’s here I meet the game’s surprisingly compelling new bad guy, Orel White D.D.S.: crusader against confectionary, friend of fluoride. Being a dentist, he’s an obvious choice for an antagonist, but he’s also the best thing about Costume Quest 2. Orel hates Halloween, but he’s more nuanced a villain than a bubbling punch bowl of Modern Warfare baddies. I don’t want to get too beard-strokey here--this is, after all, a game about sugared-up children pretending to be wizards--but a clever time-hopping mechanic means you get to see Orel as a child, and fully appreciate his motivation. No spoilers, but he’s essentially the Norman Bates of tooth decay. Resolving his story was incentive enough to keep me playing.

Being able to traverse time also means that Costume Quest 2 can present some dramatic shifts in location, all with the same pleasurably creepy feel. The glowing suburbs still give me that tingling feeling of childlike anticipation experienced before a night of trick-or-treating, but there’s now more variety: bubbling swamps give way to a futuristic dystopia of neon billboards, constructed above a caricature of urban decay. Also: floating cars! Visiting different time zones also allows for some Chrono Trigger-style meddling. Opportunities are limited, but there are some nice touches: I planted a candy seed in one timeline, only for it to blossom into a tree in the future. It doesn’t take full advantage of these chances for chronological cleverness--there are only about four sidequests which directly utilise it--but it’s a deft touch that reminds you what’s happening.

There is a ‘but’, though. The different locations lead to my biggest complaint: wherever in time you are, you’re essentially doing the same thing. The entire game is wholly reliant on a familiar trick-or-treating mechanic. Later on it’s masked by different missions--package deliveries, speakeasy drop-offs and the suchlike--but far too often it’s a case of locating a house with a light on, knocking on the door and waiting for a surprise attack.

Admittedly, this is what makes Costume Quest unique, but on the few occasions when the game mixes it up it is immediately more fun. One futuristic mission had me double-crossing monstrous, corrupt businessman, using the hand-shakey power of Jefferson’s diplomacy ability: these are the moments which stand out. The repetition is cleverly referenced in the final section--the details of which I won’t spoil here--but unless you adored the original, the samey mission structure could lead to enjoyment decay.

Repetition aside, there’s plenty to like about Costume Quest 2: not least the illicit buzz to waddling around the bright environments and smashing stuff up with your candy bucket. Like before, there are gentle geographic puzzles everywhere, usually solved by the special powers which come with each costume. They’re rarely difficult, so it’s gently taxing without ever being frustrating. Who knew that honking a clown horn could solve so many problems? Not me. For that reason alone, I’m glad Costume Quest 2 exists.

Unlike clowns, Costume Quest 2 is actually funny. It’s never cat-in-tights hilarious, but no opportunity for in-jokes is ignored. My favourite moments belonged to Candy Corn; a costume which bestows the amazing ability to do bollocks-all. If nothing else, Double Fine needs congratulating for writing so many lines about an inanimate nubbin of confection.

Fighting remains chunky and tactical without trying anything too different. It’s the turn-based RPG scrapping of older games, albeit in a tinfoil costume: if you played South Park: The Stick of Truth, you’ll know roughly what to expect. Each character has a limited number of options, so it’s often a case of prioritising enemy threat and building your special moves over time. Attacks and blocks can be also buffed with some simple, well-timed button presses. It won’t be enough for anyone with an itchy trigger-finger, but it’s bright and satisfying, particularly when you’re rewarded for perfect execution.

Unlocking new costumes also gives you access to new types of character, all based on familiar RPG classes (think healer, debuffer, tank and so on). Not all of the costumes are useful; I frequently found myself going back to the same limited choices and focusing predominantly on damage output. Even then, the fights rarely become too tricky. There’s also an over reliance on combat that means the encounters become unwelcome in the earlier stages of the game.

As the variety of enemies increases, however, so too does your need to fight tactically, so later fights become more perilously close. I feel filthy writing this, but the boss battles are often the best moments in Costume Quest. They’re longer battles which force you to use specials intelligently and learn enemy attack patterns. Unfortunately, there aren’t enough of them, with only four or five of these big, set piece moments. This, combined with the relative ease, meant that by the end of the game there were a huge range of skills at my disposal, but at no point did it feel like I’d been forced into learning or using them all.

It all comes to a satisfying, not-too-saccharine-sweet conclusion, though. It's a lean, linear experience which will take you around six hours to complete (slightly more if you go searching for everything). It’s helped along by a cheerily chilling synth string score and some charming animation: there are characterful touches everywhere, such as your party looking glum and sluggish when they’re injured.

Limited missions and frequent fighting aside, every effort feels like it’s been made to create a wide-eyed love letter to All Hallow’s Eve. Costume Quest 2 is a delightfully tasty adventure that’s more swift hit of sherbet than delicate Belgian chocolate. Just make sure you play it before 31st October.

This game was reviewed on PC.