Why you can trust GamesRadar+ Our experts review games, movies and tech over countless hours, so you can choose the best for you. Find out more about our reviews policy.

All the world’s a stage, some bloke once wrote. And the men and women in Joe Wright’s stylised take on Leo Tolstoy’s 19th-Century tome are merely players thanks to the Hanna director’s decision to base its melodramatic action within the confines of a theatre.

Given the characters’ obsession with appearance, role-playing and social rank, there is sufficient logic to this approach to make it more than ostentatious affectation. But it still results in a ponderously artificial, self-regarding work that often feels like Moulin Rouge! without the karaoke.

OK, so an enormous amount of thought has gone into transforming Sarah Greenwood’s decaying playhouse set into a railway station, an ice rink and various other locations.

Article continues below

Yet rather than involve us in the story Wright’s grandiose concept keeps it at arm’s length, forever highlighting the smoke, mirrors and meticulous stage management that have been pressed into service to make his big idea a reality.

Every now and then, the walls separate to show a world beyond that Domhnall Gleeson’s lovelorn landowner Levin retreats to after his marriage proposal is rejected by the flighty Kitty (Alicia Vikander).

But no sooner have we adapted to this more conventional treatment, than Wright reverts to his experimental one, an aggravating switcheroo that’s not so much showmanship as simple showing off.

It doesn’t help that Knightley’s performance plays like a reprise of her Duchess turn - albeit a less involving one - or that the peach-fuzzed Taylor-Johnson is as credible a beau as his beloved steed Frou-Frou.

Neil Smith is a freelance film critic and writer who contributes regularly to Heat, SFX and Screen International. He's a long-time member of the London Film Critics’ Circle and was a contributing editor at Total Film for many years.