First Dungeon Siege III screens look a bit Square Enix-ey, trailer only slightly softens fears

This is the first screenshot of Dungeon Siege III, which is the first Dungeon Siege to come to consoles, the first to be published by Square Enix and not Microsoft, and the first to be developed by Obsidian and not Gas Powered Games. That's a lot of firsts! It's also a lot of ugly, if you ask me.

I'll temper my face palm with information from someone who's actually seen the game. Heidi Kemps took a look for us recently, and wrote of the graphics:

"Perhaps the most striking new feature was the one that showcased the game’s stunning graphics. You’ll be able to survey your surroundings more effectively by using vistas – vantage points in areas that let you see far out into the distance, giving a better glimpse of the areas and goals that lie in wait."

Having not seen the game in motion, like Heidi, all I have as reference is this screenshot, and let me tell you: ICK! I like Obsidian, and I'm willing to put some faith in Square Enix's ability to oversee its first Western RPG, but this mess of skeletal polygons looks awfully JRPG to me, and the advancing hero looks like a character out of KOEI's Dynasty Warriors (right).

For reference, here's a screen from Dungeon Siege II. Aside from looking dated as hell, it probably reminds you of World of Warcraft or Diablo. It's got a Western fantasy feel, and while there's a touch of Eastern influence, it's no Final Fantasy:

That's what Dungeon Siege looks like! Fine, so maybe my reaction is influenced by nostalgia and a general fear of change, but it also has to do with how impressed I was at the visuals of inXile and Bethesda's Unreal-based Hunted: The Demon's Forge, which I'd have expected Dungeon Siege III to look more like.

But wait! We received one more Dungeon Siege III screen today:

I like this one. It's a little Tim Burton, a little Alien, a little... Piranha 3D. But I can't help but be reminded of Square Enix again, if only because of the publisher's love of glowing-eyed enemies. But now I'm just being a nitpicky asshole.

I'm making a lot of assumptions. Screens rarely do a game justice, and I have no concrete indication of how much creative control Square Enix has taken. Plus, the knowledge that Chris Taylor, the creator of Dungeon Siege, is advising the team at Obsidian soothes some of my concerns, though he's likely also very busy working on Chris Taylor’s Kings and Castles. His name's in it and all.

I'm still excited to see what Square Enix and Obsidian do with Dungeon Siege. Just, please, send us some better screenshots. These don't look anything like the great pieces of concept art we saw earlier.

UPDATE: Just in time to potentially invalidate all my bitching, the game's first trailer showed up. It's a pretty uninformative teaser, but it does look nice. Getting... slightly... less... skeptical...

Jul 27, 2010


  • laxsiber - July 28, 2010 9:54 p.m.

    looks interesting but can't say anything before some gameplay footage.
  • JayBeat - July 27, 2010 11:53 p.m.

    Tyler Wilde has the most fun articles, i only bothered reading this because of the author. I'm totally uninterested in Dungeon Siege.
  • JohnnyMaverik - July 27, 2010 8:40 p.m.

    Huh... well, we'll see...
  • zanthox - July 27, 2010 8:38 p.m.

    Hmm... If DS3 could be Obsidian's Jade Empire I would be cool with that. I'd kinda like them to stick to the source though...
  • CH3BURASHKA - July 27, 2010 8:25 p.m.

    I played the first on PC, and plan on doing the same; this console BS is blasphemy, but I guess it's the natural progression towards consolification and overall appeal. They better be planning on getting out ahead of Diablo 3, because it's no contest which one is cock of the walk.

Showing 1-5 of 5 comments

Join the Discussion
Add a comment (HTML tags are not allowed.)
Characters remaining: 5000