Skip to main content

The Paperboy review

Not an adaptation of the Atari videogame

Lee Daniels’ latest was roundly castigated when it debuted in competition at Cannes last year - critics, no doubt, expected something more sombre after the celebrated Precious .

Yet this trashy noir is not the one-star piece of merde many would have you believe.

Based on Pete Dexter’s novel set in the late ’60s, it follows Miami Times reporter Ward Jansen (Matthew McConaughey) as he returns to his Florida hometown to dig into the dubious conviction of Death Row inmate Hillary Van Wetter (John Cusack).

Aiding Jansen in his investigation is British colleague Yardley (David Oyelowo) and kid brother Jack (Zac Efron).

The ace in Jansen’s pack, though, is blowsy blonde Charlotte (Nicole Kidman). She’s newly engaged to Van Wetter and her prison visits allow the boys access to their subject.

For so long classy and glacial, Kidman here steals the show oozing sex and instability, at once funny and poignant as she pulls up her skirt for Van Wetter’s bulging appraisal or urinates on Jack when he’s stung by a jellyfish.

Yes, The Paperboy is that nutty/smutty, tottering along an art-trash tightrope as it juggles techniques, tones and themes (murder, desire, race).

Not all of it works: Macy Gray, playing a housemaid, delivers an imbecilic voiceover, and the sticky lethargy of it all brings wheeze to the sleaze.

But the critics deriding Daniels’ choppy cuts, garish palette, camp flourishes and grainy 16mm missed the point.

The Paperboy is a throwback to the exploitation cinema of its period. As such, it’s grungy, tasteless and hard to take your eyes off.

More info

Available platformsMovie