The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword review

So, it is tied with Twilight Princess?

This game is incredible. It has achieved the feat that so many releases have missed: the magic of playing a game for a game's sake. It has that magical, whimsical touch that makes the hardcore scene look like a million miles away.

Having actually played the game, I couldn't agree more with this review. 9/10 is the perfect score, and the reviewer hit pretty much all the good/bad points of the game, including that the fact there is no breathing room somehow takes out some of the magic that OoT and TP had. Gotta say though, I'm really surprised Wind Waker is your favorite zelda. I really didn't care for that game at all, and it didn't even compare with OoT, TP, or this game even. The water world thing got very old, and I absolutely HATED the cartoony, childish, lame graphics. I really can't figure out why people liked that game so much...

IMO its art style graphic. Though Celshaded Graphic is timeless will never grow old. I know Ocarina of Time is amazing da best but u can see its aging quite a bit by today's standard but Wind waker will never age its like Disney's good old cartoons like Mickey mouse, Lion King etc... I still see disney cartoons and never felt they are dated. I am sure after 10 more years Wind Waker still look awesome. Maybe Miyamoto made this game with idea like that in mind

wonder what brett thinks

Very happy you decided to do a spoiler free review even if Zelda isn't the most story oriented game out there. I'm really looking forward to this but kind of worried I might not play it for awhile when I get it because of how amazing Skyrim is. Thanks again for being the only review I felt safe reading Ms. Gudmundson.

I agree that Wind Waker is the best 3D Zelda to date, with Link to the Past being a close second. I never liked Ocarina of Time, it never grabbed me the way it did most people apparently. I honestly had more fun with the DS titles than that game. Majora's Mask is pretty cool though, I guess. The comment section on the review is no better, in fact, worse than the Halo Reach review. People are being extremely and unreasonably butthurt over a nine. I mean seriously, it's a nine people. Everyone is treating it like it got a six or a five. Just goes to show that fanboys are still fanboys no matter what series it is, Halo or Zelda.

Same people write comments like 100 times lol

I feel like GR has completely lost it's integrity. I guess I'm not overly irrate at them giving say, Skyrim a 10, I figured and I'm sure it's a great game (I still haven't really played Oblivion very much and I'm not overly in love with it or anything. I think it's over-rated in general and I like more focused gaming). However, giving this game a 9 and saying it's not as good as WW is weird, but I suppose that's opinion. I'm still peaved about the Uncharted 3 review, it's complete bogus, I think Uncharted 3 was even better than 2, screw what everyone else says. But MW3 getting a 9 just felt like an obligation, I knew it was going to be either a safe score like a 9 and I was even worried they would give it a 10 because they are such tools on here sometimes. I'm gonna rent Arkham City and see if the fuss is justified, I still don't see how anyone but a Batman fanboy could have thought Arkham Assylum was a GOTY game, but to each his or her own. I'm just going to trust Game Informer for my reviews before I pick up a game from here on out. GR has some fun and cool articles and is still a great place to get cheats/help but as for reviews, screw em I think I can get a better opinion from even IGN or my own personal views from renting and for sure Game Informer, even though they can be weird sometimes too but not nearly as controversialy idiotic as GR has shown to be in the past year or two. Sorry GR, keep writing the great articles but you are no longer a good reviewing site. I'll play Skyward Sword and I'm willing to bet, from what I've heard at least it's going to be the best Zelda since OoT

The problem is that "srs gaming review websites" don't have any integrity left. Don't give good scores and next time you won't get an early copy so every other place will be ahead of you.

I'm not sure why either of you two decided to read this if you don't trust or respect the people at this site, and bringing up Game Informer just seems like you want everything to get high ass scores as their scale is skewed higher (7 is average on their scale, I believe it is 5 here) I suppose if that is what you are looking for you have the solution to your problem.

Ahhh, November 20th can't come fast enough D: I can't wait to play!

Not better than Twilight Princess or Wind Waker? hmmm.

Great review; I'll have to pick this up when I have money again. And if I could weigh in on the argument about the score... In the review Carolyn mentions some things that seem to lower the score for her, but aren't mentioned in the "You'll hate" section. Most of them are summed up in the comparison to Twilight Princess, such as the safer story and Fi paling in comparison to Midna. These things aren't listed in "You'll hate" because they're not things to hate, but they could conceivably lower a score, especially when you add in the complaints about the motion controls. And what Skyrim got is completely irrelevant to this review. All in all, when I read the review, it felt like it was going to get a 9. And a 9/10 is awesome.

Although Windwaker is my personal favorite in the series, that's a very much more personal thing because I loved the ocean aesthetic and the epic story details. I however completely understand the reasons that some people don't care for it as much. If you get tired of seeing the sea and island scenery, you get tired of sailing. If you hate searching for treasure that the actual location of disappears when you get close, you might not care for it as much. To me, it was awesome because it was like a post-apocalyptic Zelda game in the sense that Hyrule was now an unlivable and even hidden kingdom lost under the sea. I believe that Skyward Sword has too many pros not to be a 10. Based on what I've seen it already is in my book, and the newly restructured worlds that aren't all long dungeons sounds like a welcome change of pace. Most importantly, this game deserves to be up there with the other big games like Skyrim and (far above) MW3.

Wait... Wind Waker the best 3D Zelda game?! No.

9 is a good no great score, but the reasoning behind why it didn't get a ten do no make sense in my opinion. I'm not being a fanboy (because every player who defends a certain game becomes a fanboy amirite? lol) but the only problem the reviewer mentions is often calibrating the controller. The other reasons are literally irrelavent. It seems that the only reason it scored a 9 instead of a 10 was because the writer's favorite game was Wind Waker. While Skyrim was said to have a few bugs in the system and it could be improved and still got a 10. In terms of relavence you would think the problems in Skyrim are more substantial than just simply recalibrating ever so often. Now based on what I've seen I believe both games deserve 10s. Even though we can all have different opinions as a reviewer I think he should give just reasoning as to why the sc

oops hit the wrong button. I meant that being a high profile reviewer, one need to present just reasons for the scores given and must remain unbias

In fact you are right. But you don´t have to worry about that. Think about it, Deus Ex Human Revolution (Great game) was rated with a 10, but Skyward Sword was still between the 5 nominees for Game of the Year. What could that mean? It means that when a game is rated with a 9 it is just an editor´s opinion. A 9 game isn´t worse than a 10 game. It depends on the editor who reviewed it. If all the 10 rated games were obligatory better than 9 games, then Deus Ex: Human Revolution would have been between the 5 nominees, and then Twilight Princess would be better than Wind Waker. Resuming my comment, when a game reaches a 9, it depends on the person who plays if it is perfect or not. A 9 can be a 10, and a 10 can be a 9.

I didn't read too much so I wont know too much about the game, but it seemed very positive. I'm suprised you only gave it a 9. I know 9 is a great score, but nearly everything you said seemed like a 10. I am so stoked that we FINALLY see the relationship between Zelda and Link explored a bit.