Games that should be more controversial than GTA

Murder a baby seal and no one bats an eyelid. But do in a hooker and everyone's up in arms

Words: on July 26, 2010

GTA gets a pretty bad rap in the mainstream press. If you listen to them it’s responsible for the downfall of society, Han Solo shooting second and Skittles the shitting tiger corrupting children in their sleep.

But there are plenty of games that do controversial shit which pass under the all-seeing gaze of Saur… eh, the media. Blowing up an entire town with an A-bomb. Doing something decidedly saucy with a woman’s chest. Baby seal genocide! The games below all avoided courting controversy for these acts simply because their profile isn’t as high as the series that lets you kneecap hookers.


Fallout 3

Why it should be more controversial: It lets you blow up an entire town with a goddamn nuclear bomb.



Yes, that’s right. This isn’t offing the occasional Lithuanian mobster, pimp or good old fashioned street walker. No, we’re talking about painfully vaporising dozens of innocent civilians with an atomic explosion… for money.


Above: Won't somebody think of the Jedis?!

Why it isn’t: Because while little Timmy can perhaps grow up to be an automobile thief, it’s unlikely he’s ever going to pop down to the local convenience store and pick himself up a weapon of mass destruction with his soda pop. That said, Japanese copies of the game understandably had The Power of Atom mission removed.


3D Dot Heroes

Why it should be more controversial than GTA: Your pixely protagonist can get a sex massage.



Quick, hide the young ‘uns. Someone needs to ban this sick filth right the hell now. Really, what’s this world coming to when a man can’t slay a few blocky monsters without being offered a happy ending massage? If you don’t get the above poofpoof scene it’s a reference to a bit from Dragon Quest VIII where a raunchy woman massages your character’s face with her big, round… eh, Slimes.  

Only the thing is, there’s a definite lack of blue blobs to do the massaging this time. So when she dims the lights, we can only assume she’s giving the hero a thorough rubbing with her blocky, angular shirt turnips. Oh, and poofpoof totally means sex.  

Why it’s not: It’s all a bit of fun, innit? Now if the next game in the 3D Dot Heroes series takes this direction that would be a different story…


Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater

Why it should be more controversial than GTA: It contains six, count ‘em, six minutes of brutal torture.



Holy shit. We’re used to seeing characters getting shot and having seven shades of bum juice kicked out of them, but Snake Eater’s torture sequence is something else. It’s the fact that many of the horrendous acts that befall Snake lie so close to reality. The plastic bag over the head to onset claustrophobia, the Deer Hunter-style Russian Roulette sequence, the dude who can fire bolts of lightning out of his finge… alright, scratch that last one. The rest of the scene, however, we can actually imagine happening in real life (admittedly pretty illegal) interrogations.

Why it’s not: Because Metal Gear can do something GTA never can. Namely, hide its violence behind a semi comforting blanket of fantasy. Where GTA is (somewhat) grounded in reality, making its shootings, knifings and hooker homicides too close to what’s actually going on in the world for many critics’ tastes, the Gear can balance its violence with baddies who shoot bees out of their ass, camp one-liners and effeminate men in g-strings.

Actually, screw what we just said. Seeing Raikov’s lightning bolt-branded banana hammock is worse than watching a hundred eye-gouging torture scenes.


Above: Nothing at all. Nothing at all. NOTHING AT ALL...

Related

Games:


Grand Theft Auto IV (Xbox 360)

View Videos and Screenshots Hide Videos and Screenshots

Latest Videos

Latest Screenshots

Platforms:

Xbox 360, PS3, PS2, PC, 3DS

51 Comments
Order Comments: Newest First | Oldest First
  • Voltaire

    Voltaire  - 1 year, 2 months ago  - Report

    I may as well mention that no one seems to mind the fact that you have to kill adult pandas in Overlord 2
  • 2cute2Bcruel

    2cute2Bcruel  - 1 year, 4 months ago  - Report

    I can think of TONS more games that are more offensive and should be MORE controversial than GTA. But the reason that they aren't is that they aren't popular enough.
  • wiitard07

    wiitard07  - 1 year, 6 months ago  - Report

    Come on people there is a pissed of Japanese fellow at the beginning of the article pointing at what seems to say SPOILERS BELOW! stop blaming GR for your stupidity
  • brickman409

    brickman409  - 1 year, 6 months ago  - Report

    what about mario 64 you could drop a baby penguin of a cliff on that snow level
  • Syncmaster

    Syncmaster  - 1 year, 6 months ago  - Report

    guys whats wrong with you?? the second paragraph BEFORE de huge spoiler alert had the almighty heavy rain spoiler. it ruined the game for me, but thanks, the sentence was REMOVED so.. there are no more spoilers there genius. ppl read the first couple of comments and just go bashing...
  • seanpolley

    seanpolley  - 1 year, 6 months ago  - Report

    wow. thanks for ruining heavy rain. a spoiler alert wouldve been nice.
  • icbacomingupwithapropername

    icbacomingupwithapropername  - 1 year, 6 months ago  - Report

    Damn was t expecting fable 2 on here but I guess the dog killin and girl killig is kinda controversiall never realy thought about it befor.

    Re-capcha:them pedigrees. Actualy I think the dog was a mongrel not a pedigree but nvm
  • AstroTartJones

    AstroTartJones  - 1 year, 6 months ago  - Report

    Remember. Its just a game, settle down. If its Ok in movies its ok in video games.
  • Vitoruss1

    Vitoruss1  - 1 year, 6 months ago  - Report

    For someone who really doesn't like MGS, I must admit, that torture scene was pretty awesome. Minus the tackiness that is ever-present during all of the games.
  • stizzybeatbonk

    stizzybeatbonk  - 1 year, 6 months ago  - Report

    I would like to see a girl in a two-piece Slime-themed swimsuit. Chances of that happening are slim to none, but hey, a man can fantasize.
  • philipshaw

    philipshaw  - 1 year, 6 months ago  - Report

    Kojima does like a good toture scence,there is one in MGS1, MGS3 and MGS:PW
  • Zeb364

    Zeb364  - 1 year, 6 months ago  - Report

    To everyone complaining about the end of Heavy Rain being spoiled: look to the top of the article, see the giant picture that says "Spoilers Ahead" with the giant red arrows pointing down at the rest of the article? That's your warning that the article ahead contains spoilers.

    @KnightDehumidifier: I agree, it should've been in here. Especially since every game contains a sex scene and the media always seems to get a giant hard on over sex in video games. I was shocked as hell when Fox News didn't bust a nut about God of War 3's lesbian sex scene.
  • CurryIsGood

    CurryIsGood  - 1 year, 6 months ago  - Report

    well in fallout 3 the children have guns and often swear at you
  • ballplayer27

    ballplayer27  - 1 year, 6 months ago  - Report

    There is no way someone missed the spoiler alert. Are we sure they didn't add it? It's an article wide picture of a dude pissed off because his game got spoiled. It's also the same pissed off Asian dude they use for major spoiler articles...
  • GangsterJew92

    GangsterJew92  - 1 year, 6 months ago  - Report

    Seriously, does GR need to blare a siren continually saying spoiler alert so that you know even though the picture saying "Spoiler Alert" is practically the size of an entire paragraph.

    Idiots aside, great article guys.
  • curly_jefferson

    curly_jefferson  - 1 year, 6 months ago  - Report

    I love how you can tell a Dave Meikleham article from the first image
    the internet needs more of that personality.

    Maybe next time you can do an article on how to recognise blatantly obvious spoiler warnings
  • Personamanxx

    Personamanxx  - 1 year, 6 months ago  - Report

    Seal meat is delicious. I love being a Newfoundlander.

    But seriously? Yeah some of these games really should cause some ripples from watch dogs more than they do.
  • sleepy92ismypsn

    sleepy92ismypsn  - 1 year, 6 months ago  - Report

    How can you have had Heavy Rain Spoiled? The only game I didn't want to be spoiled for me was MGS3 so as soon as I saw the title I looked away and went on to the next page.
  • sleepy92ismypsn

    sleepy92ismypsn  - 1 year, 6 months ago  - Report

    Don't want to spoil anything good so I didn't read. I've already played Heavy Rain but not fallout 3. Can someone please tell me which games get spoiled? I can understand them not mentioning which games get spoiled in that article about video game characters dying but not this article. fuck it I'll try not to read anything but the game titles.
  • metalgatesolid

    metalgatesolid  - 1 year, 6 months ago  - Report

    Great Heavy Rain RUINED!!!! Should have a huge marker over that one saying this is the spoiler to end all spoilers!!
Most Commented
Connect with GamesRadar