The Play team debate which kids book they would turn into a game

Lies of P
(Image credit: NEOWIZ)

In this month's Play Magazine, the team is debating which kids book they would turn into a game, with some pretty bold claims coming from the gang. 

Inspired by the upcoming Lies of P, which is a Bloodborne-esque take on the story of Pinocchio, here are the children's tales which the Play staffers would take and mold into a videogame. We're already getting chills thinking about some of these Grimm adaptations... 

You can pick up the issue of Play Magazine which this first appeared on Magazines Direct or subscribe today to ensure they never miss a copy of Play again!

Rachel Watts, Staff Writer

"GERMAN FAIRYTALES ARE PERFECT FOR HORROR ADAPTATIONS."

Any fairy tale by the Grimm brothers would make an excellent creepy but cutesy horror game, and Hansel And Gretel would be my first choice. I love playing horror games with friends and so my adaptation of the story would be a two-player co-op adventure in the style of Brothers: A Tale Of Two Sons meets Little Nightmares. There would be stealth elements for when the siblings need to escape their stepmother and woodcutter father, puzzle elements for laying down the breadcrumbs, and then, of course, a boss fight against the witch.

Miriam McDonald, Operations Editor

"MR TOAD IS GOING TO KICK SOME FURRY WEASEL BUMS.”

Move over, Noctis and co, because some better bros are going on an RPG road trip. Gentle Mole, water loving, capable Ratty and impetuous, speed-loving Mr Toad are out to traverse a world more familiar than Eorzea but no less characterful. The Wind In The Willows has it all: driving challenges in a stolen car, the dangerous Wild Wood that’s full of evil faces (random battles ahoy!), a stealthy prison break disguised as a washerwoman, horse theft, and even a final battle (with some help from wise old Badger) with the wicked weasels who’ve taken over Toad Hall.

Oscar Taylor-Kent, Editor

CLIMBING THE FARAWAY TREE COULD BE A CHALLENGE IN AND OF ITSELF

Forget Babylon’s Fall. The only fantastically large thing I want to climb is The Faraway Tree from Enid Blyton’s series of books. The giant tree, with houses up its trunk and ever-changing lands at the top, is magical. But something has always struck me as suspicious about Moon-Face, one of the denizens of the land above. This would be a gritty, gruelling climb taking the kids on a perilous procedurally generated ascent that gets more dangerous the closer you get to the top, where the round headed creature awaits for a final, brutal challenge. 

Only once they’ve climbed the tree can they be free of the nightmares that terrorise them. But with Moon-Face vanquished, your character looks into a puddle of rain to find their own head has become spherical. The cycle always continues, and you become the boss for another player

Jessica Kinghorn, Games Editor

STRANGE, CRUEL, AND UNUSUAL – FAIRY TALES AND VIDEOGAMES ARE A PERFECT MATCH.

Fairy tales serve well as malleable narrative wrappings around game mechanics. Many feel the best-known versions of these tales, as collected by the Brothers Grimm, are far too violent to be bedtime stories for modern tiny wees, but perhaps they’d fit right in with another medium. Any folklorist worth their salt will tell you there’s plenty else to draw on besides such Grimm things but just picture it: Red Riding Hood as a stealth game. Snow White And The Seven Dwarves as a dating simulator. Hansel And Gretel as a Hitman-esque puzzle game where you race against each other’s ghost data as you try to shove the witch in the oven – the designs write themselves!

Oscar Taylor-Kent
Games Editor

Games Editor Oscar Taylor-Kent brings his Official PlayStation Magazine and PLAY knowledge to continue to revel in all things capital 'G' games. A noted PS Vita apologist, he's always got his fingers on many buttons, having also written for Edge, PC Gamer, SFX, Official Xbox Magazine, Kotaku, Waypoint, GamesMaster, PCGamesN, and Xbox, to name a few.

When not knee deep in character action games, he loves to get lost in an epic story across RPGs and visual novels. Recent favourites? Elden Ring: Shadow Of The Erdtree, 1000xResist, and Metaphor: ReFantazio! Rarely focused entirely on the new, the call to return to retro is constant, whether that's a quick evening speed through Sonic 3 & Knuckles or yet another Jakathon through Naughty Dog's PS2 masterpieces.

Read more
A screenshot of the announcement trailer for Hello Kitty island Adventure, with all the characters waving
Hello Kitty Island Adventure is the latest example of how cozy games are secretly pretty dark at their core
Concept art shows American McGee's Alice flying through the air.
I want to call this incredible action game with a harrowing story, bloodthirsty combat, and a psychedelic fantasy world my favorite game – but it doesn’t actually exist
A Series of Unfortunate Events PS2 screenshot
I'm replaying my favorite obscure PS2 game and now I miss when movie tie-ins were the norm
Little Nightmares 3 Big In 2025
With two not-so secret weapons up its sleeve, Little Nightmares 3 is shaping up to be the "charming horror" event of 2025
Screenshot of a child looking into a still lake in Miniatures
Finding lost treasures in this mesmerizing indie game unlocks stories of childlike wonder, and I've never experienced anything like it
Screenshots from the Fame & Fable Kickstarter
Fame & Fable is a post-lockdown D&D Dungeon Master's baby, born of "homebrew characters, monsters, and artefacts"
Latest in Horror
I Have No Mouth, and I Must Scream
For 30 years, PC gamers have been keeping this cult classic horror game based on a 58-year-old short story to themselves, but next week it's finally coming to consoles
The Apex Predator in horror game Repo.
After blowing up on Steam, indie horror hit Repo confirms its first major update will include a new map and a 'duck bucket'
Screenshot from R.E.P.O, showing a scary ghoul face popping out of the shadows to spook a tin-man.
Lethal Company creator shouts out another viral co-op hit that already has 28,000 Steam reviews, says it has "the most funny objective for a horror game"
Silent Hill f
Don't ask Pyramid Head's creator what he knows about Silent Hill f: "I didn't work on it"
Silent Hill f
After 2 years of silence, the next mainline Silent Hill game is getting a dedicated stream this week with "the latest news"
The Sinking City 2
After a years-long battle with its publisher, Ukraine-based studio reveals first gameplay footage of survival horror sequel The Sinking City 2, launches Kickstarter, and hits $100,000 goal in hours
Latest in News
Silent Hill 2 Remake
Silent Hill 2 Remake devs spent many hours "watching, reading, discussing" fan theories about the iconic Labyrinth level and wanted to "incorporate as many" of them as possible
Phoenix #12
Jean Grey's "miraculous return" will solve an X-Men mystery that's been lingering for over 30 years
A screenshot of protagonist Lucia from GTA 6
GTA 6 is "definitely gonna be a big economic boost for the games industry" that'll help "bring a lot more people back into the ecosystem," PlayStation indie boss reckons
Clair Obscure Expedition 33
Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 builds on a "heritage of JRPGs" like Final Fantasy 7, 8, 9, and 10, but it's also "inspired by Sekiro" and taking pieces from deckbuilders
Games like The Witcher 3: A cut scene during Act 2 of Baldur's Gate 3.
Baldur's Gate 3's corporate overlord says news on the future of the RPG series is coming "in pretty short order"
Silent Hill 2 Remake
Silent Hill 2 remake dev says Bloober played up the original's iconic toilet scene to punish its protagonist for being a bad husband: "The theme here is disgust"