Can You Ever Forgive Me? review: "Melissa McCarthy is a dowdy and determined revelation"

GamesRadar+ Verdict

The powerful, vanity-free performances are the real thing in this bittersweet biopic.

Why you can trust GamesRadar+ Our experts review games, movies and tech over countless hours, so you can choose the best for you. Find out more about our reviews policy.

Swapping her trademark pratfalls for literary crime and daytime drinking, Melissa McCarthy is a dowdy and determined revelation in this engaging true-life tale of author Lee Israel’s audacious ’90s scam. Don’t mistake director Marielle Heller’s rich, melancholy character study, however, for a Life of the Party-style middle-aged makeover movie.

McCarthy’s caustic Lee, a penniless celebrity biographer with a toxic personality, can’t catch a job or a break until selling a showbiz thank-you reveals that there’s big money in famous people’s letters. Soon she’s a one-woman forgery factory, creating hundreds of fake missives from Noël Coward et al on old typewriters and oven-aged letterheads. Enlisting broke grifter Jack Hock (a barnstorming Richard E. Grant) as her fence morphs the movie into a funny-sad buddy caper, complete with archive heists and blackmailer booksellers. 

Jeff Whitty and indie queen Nicole Holofcener’s tack-sharp script is nicely nuanced about gay mid-life loneliness and last chances, with Heller wrapping a smoke-stained ’90s New York of dingy bars, bookstores, and chilly streets around the pair. The real delight, though, is in McCarthy and Grant’s bitingly rude and funny fraudsters, two cynical losers finding refuge in one another. Grant injects a mix of charmer and rotter into Jack’s hustling, but it’s McCarthy’s prickly, vulnerable and bravely egotistical Lee who seals the film’s deal.

For more hotly anticipated films, check out our list of the most exciting upcoming movies in store for 2019 - and while you're at it, why not take a look at the best movies of 2018 that you might have missed?

  • Release date: Out now (US)/February 1, 2019 (UK)
  • Certificate: R (US)/15 (UK)
  • Running time: 106 mins

More info

Available platformsMovie
Freelance Writer

Kate is a freelance film journalist and critic. Her bylines have appeared online and in print for GamesRadar, Total Film, the BFI, Sight & Sounds, and