5. LeChuck’s Secret of Monkey Island
Before LeChuck was an evil, voodoo-powered zombie-ghost pirate captain, he was a… regular… evil… pirate… captain. But he had a heart. He loved the governor’s daughter, Elaine (a plot line that comes up in Telltale's Tales of Monkey Island series), and attempted to impress her by sailing to Monkey Island to uncover its secret. Instead of uncovering the secret, however, he died, and became the immortal foe we all know and hate. We want to see this story from beginning to end, and learn the full tale of the pirate LeChuck.
LeChuck is simply an awesome villain, and we have a feeling his descent into true villain-dom could make for an awesome game. Gameplay-wise, it should be a fairly typical point-and-click adventure, showing his life and death to give the already interesting character more depth. Plus, even if we end up disliking the young LeChuck, we have a feeling that’ll just grow our appreciation of the undead, green, monstrous LeChuck we already know and love.