Google+

The Top 7… Comic book games that need to be made

Comic-book games have gotten the short end of the stick for too long. Usually, the only characters that grace a videogame release are the ones that have been turned into movies, and nine times our of ten, those games are absolute train wrecks. There's the occasional bright spot, like Spider-Man 2 or Arkham City, but a majority of comic-book games are utter rubbish, and the issue is clear: instead of taking hyper-popular comic books and making them into third-person adventure games, developers need to start matching comics to appropriate game genres, and they need to be willing to go deeper than X-Men and Green Lantern.

But we know that all of the developers out there are far too busy to research this. So we've done some of the legwork for them, and come up with a handful of comic books/series ripe for videogame adaptations (and the best way to go about adapting them).

7. Gotham Central (done like L.A. Noire)

Behind every good superhero, there's a building full of police officers cursing his name. In Batman's case, it's the Gotham Police Department. Gotham Central chronicles the lives of these typical, un-extraordinary cops as they're forced to deal with superhuman villains masquerading around in costumes and blowing up hospitals. It's a somewhat typical procedural cop drama at its core, where the officers need to Law & Order their way around inner-office politics, red tape and crime scenes in order to catch the crook. Except, in their case, the crook is sometimes Mr. Freeze, and the red tape involves the Bat signal.

Gotham Central would make a great game, especially if the developers modeled it around L.A. Noire. The player usually wouldn't come toe-to-toe with supervillians, but they'd certainly see the aftermath: frozen corpses, mutilated bodies, and other distressing situations that most cops don't need to deal with that frequently. Gotham police officers could deal with the occasional shootout during a bank robbery, or interrogation sequences to find their leader's hideout, but they'd be dealing with the Joker's henchmen instead of random nameless enemies, adding a bit more personality to the day-to-day occurrences. 

Ideally, you wouldn't be able to screw up interrogations and miss a chunk of the story, like in L.A. Noire, but the game should still have a really cool fail state. If the case is running too long, and it looks like more people might die due to the police's (or the player's) incompetence, the game could make you call in Batman to wrap things up, embarrassing the entire police department by making months worth of work disappear in an instant.

6. Blacksad (done like Heavy Rain with a tinge of Max Payne)

Blacksad is about as noir as it gets. The series, written by Spanish authors Juan Díaz Canales, is set in late 1950s America, and has the titular hero delving into themes relative to the time, like civil rights, racism, the red scare and other ‘50s themes. Oh, and did we mention that Blacksad is a cat? Because he's totally a cat. In the Blacksad universe, every character is an animal, with the stereotypes of the animals being represented in the characters themselves. Lizards are slithery and sneaky, pigs are fat and greedy, and the president is a bald eagle. Get it?

This unique setting would make for a great game, but the tone of the book isn’t one that would be best served with an L.A. Noire-style adventure. Blacksad doesn’t take part in many interrogations, and even if he did, we’re not too sure we’d be able to accurately read the faces of rhinoceroses. Sure, we’d love to try and watch a polar bear’s face to tell when he’s lying, but we’re just not sure how fun that would actually be for an entire game. Instead,a Heavy Rain-style approach might be best, with players investigating situations and exploring areas, with the occasional quick-time-event-heavy segment to make up the action. It would be worth it just to see the fully-realized world of Blacksad come to life. Seriously, we're tired of walking around New York and L.A. - let's get in a shoot-out with a walrus or something. Just to spice things up.

Even though we'd like to see the gameplay mimic Heavy Rain's, we think the developers should take their style cues from the melancholy, analogy-heavy, graphic-novel-inspired grit of Max Payne, just for good measure. Why not L.A. Noire instead? Because while it had "noire" right there in the title, it didn't hold a noir candle to the noir of Max Payne. Noir.

Topics

Top 7

We Recommend By ZergNet

73 comments

  • RagnaBloodedge - December 7, 2011 2:30 p.m.

    Sin City. Nuff' said.
  • TedDidlio - December 3, 2011 3:21 p.m.

    Good top 7, BUT, I feel there was a big omission made; Garth Ennis' Punisher MAX run. I know they made a decent-at-best Punisher game that Ennis wrote in 2005, but if they based a game off of his 60 issue MAX run, they could make an absolutely amazing game. It could be maybe Gears of War style, but with emphasis on setting huge, gnarly traps or catching big groups of gangsters off guard or something. It could be SO good and gory and adult and fun.
  • IAmARobotWhoTurnsIntoATruckAnd - December 3, 2011 11:30 a.m.

    Oh god, the american comic book nostalgia. Someone please kill me now
  • SerpentineZERO - December 3, 2011 3:28 a.m.

    Great list! I've never heard of Blacksad or Mouse Guard, but they both look very interesting. Also, i really hope that the Suicide Squad game gets created and released.
  • Thequestion 121 - December 2, 2011 9:54 p.m.

    One of the best Top 7 articles I've read in a while! Good job Hollander Cooper!
  • 04whim - December 2, 2011 6:57 p.m.

    "The entire Marvel Universe" YES! "(done like League of Legends)" No, bad Gamesradar... Surely a DCUO thing?
  • Craza - December 1, 2011 4:18 p.m.

    Never heard of Blacksad before, but it looks really awesome. I'll have to check it out.
  • Fred1712 - December 1, 2011 3:17 p.m.

    I'm reading Blacksad because of this article and it is FLAWLESSLY amazing.
  • beezn - November 30, 2011 2:33 a.m.

    you snagged me with Chew, I love you for Darkwing and Blacksad is now on my hold list at the library. Thanks!
  • beezn - November 30, 2011 2:31 a.m.

    die in a fire...
  • YuGiOhisbetterthanMagic - November 29, 2011 6:21 p.m.

    I love Chew!
  • Stahlbrand - November 29, 2011 5:30 p.m.

    I am FULLY ON BOARD for the Blacksad and Mouse Guard pitches. I might like to see Mouse Guard handled like a character action game though, with action-game combat (rather than rpg) and mouse-scale traversal.
  • PhantumFish - November 29, 2011 3:23 p.m.

    Dr. McNinja would be the best game ever.
  • WTeen8 - November 29, 2011 1:48 p.m.

    The darkwing duck and marvel league of legends games sound like they'd be awesome. Also was the last one sarcastic? (The bizarro one) I can't tell
  • Sjoeki - November 29, 2011 11:53 a.m.

    Oh a good Marvel game would be awesome, Rocksteady should get the rights to make a X-men game! So much good memories there, or the Avengers, they rocked!
  • SonicX_89 - November 29, 2011 10:02 a.m.

    Blacksad seems like a pretty cool comic; Chew does as well.
  • comaqi - November 29, 2011 8:13 a.m.

    Dark Wing Duck eh? I wonder who suggested that.....
  • 8bitBaby - November 29, 2011 7:55 a.m.

    hm... why these comics specifically? there are waaaaay too many comics in print and online and globally to try and pull off a top 7 like this. i'm not trying to give you crap dude. i just don't think a lot of these would translate well into good gameplay in the end. a lot of comics just don't translate beyond the stagnant format period. maybe i'm wrong. i don't know...

Showing 1-20 of 73 comments

Join the Discussion
Add a comment (HTML tags are not allowed.)
Characters remaining: 5000

OR…

Connect with Facebook

Log in using Facebook to share comments, games, status update and other activity easily with your Facebook feed.