Destiny is very much Halo: The MMO - but that's a great thing

The open Beta for Destiny starts... now. You're probably reading this on your fancy second-screen device, while you wait for the game itself to finish downloading on PS4. I was lucky enough to play the Beta for five hours yesterday, and what strikes me most about Destiny is how much like Halo it feels. That's not to say it lacks merit as an original game, or that the Halo-feel is a detriment, but that Destiny feels comfortingly familiar while exposing players to some wonderfully ambitious ideas that Bungie has clearly been brewing for some years.

After all: why should Bungie simply throw away all the lessons it learned while making a series that not only became the flagship title for Xbox, but also defined an entire generation of shooters? Its like saying: “Hey, Polyphony--good work with the Gran Turismo series, but now we'd like you to make a strategy game about pixies and warlocks”. Madness. I imagine many will beat Destiny with the metaphorical stick for 'being too much like Halo', but for me that's no bad thing.

The tutorial itself is a cheeky nod from the developers, as you're greeted right at the start by Ghost--a floating robot that would win first-prize in a Guilty Spark Look-a-Like competition. Voiced by Peter 'Tyrion Lannister' Dinklage, Ghost takes you through the basics like running in a straight line, and shooting bad-guys. Although Destiny features a more traditional Left Trigger = ironsights style of shooting, weapon feel and feedback is very, very Halo. There's a pleasingly relentless pace to each combat scenario, and enemies have those trademark Bungie smarts, where they'll dodge behind cover and coordinate attacks organically. And yes, getting in close for a melee attack is just as satisfying as a Mk2 Pistol to the face.

If I was being pedantic (and I totally am), I'd even say certain enemy types and vehicles are ripped straight out of Combat Evolved. The Stealth Vandals, for example, are semi-cloaked enemies with swords attached to their arms; hugely similar to Halo's Elites. The Sparrow hover bike, which you can spawn at any time, is essentially a posh version of the Ghost. However, while handling is similar the Sparrow feels lighter, nippier, and less clumsy to rotate. There were several beautiful moments during my play time when my whole fireteam forgot about the mission objective, and simply spawned Sparrows to race around the playing area for larks.

It's the playing areas and non-combat hubs where Destiny feels more like an evolution of Halo, rather than a direct relation. While combat maps are still wide-open spaces, there's much more to see and do in Destiny; a greater sense of conflict. Although I didn't see it myself, there are public areas in each map where fireteams (usually three players in a party) will meet each other and attempt to tackle massive, or swarms of, enemies. There's always something to randomly murder but, if you want to just crack on with the mission, that's easy enough to do. Halo feels very directed, very linear. Destiny is a true open-world multiplayer game that simply uses Bungie's broad sci-fi environments to give players more freedom. Plus, it's massive in a way that Halo only manages via clever art direction and visual smoke and mirrors.

And then there's customisation. While Halo pioneered multiplayer customisation, Destiny really takes things to a new level. Before you even start, you're greeted with a wealth of character creation tools. I choose to play as an Exo, Hunter Class, with robotic spiked-hair and a striking, green face-mask, although there are three species and a huge variety of cosmetic-choices to wade through. Thankfully, you don't need to spend hours fiddling with your character's face to prevent them looking like they've gone seven rounds with Mike Tyson. 

Although the action in Destiny takes place in first-person, there are third-person areas and options. If--like me--you choose to break into a funky dance half-way through an intense fire-fight, much to the annoyance of your team mates, the camera switches to third-person. You can then view your custom character strutting his/her stuff while your buddies die. There are four 'emotes' mapped to the d-pad, and when you're in the hub area prepping for missions and chatting to other players, it can often feel like a ComicCon version of PlayStation Home, as players wave, dance, and flock around female avatars just in case they're real women. Which they rarely are. Sorry.

The main hub city itself is classic MMO territory, so nothing like any existing Halo games. Fair enough. It's actually one of the more underwhelming aspects of the Beta, as there isn't a whole lot to do beyond socialising and buying gear, but it may become more of a bustling metropolis in the final game. What I do like is the way it lets you 'decode' weapons that you pick up during combat missions. Enemies will sometimes drop glowing orbs that represent firearms, but until you bring them back to the city and have them decoded, you don't know what stats and effects they'll have. Weapons are varied, but Bungie seems to have kept them well-balanced too. We're not talking Borderlands-levels of guns here, but a decent mixture that allows you (and your team) to adapt according to every scenario. My favourite weapon, so far, is a short-range rifle that charges like a Spartan Laser before unleashing a shot that burns enemies to cinders.

While many of the things in this Beta are brilliant fun, there are problems. Some of the environments will start to feel very samey when you've done the 10th mission in the same part of the world, and boss fights are... inconsistent. While the 'over-powered regular enemy' versions are a great challenge, the 'massive hulking' bosses (like one Fallen Walker I encounter) are pure grind. It takes my fireteam 20 minutes to kill the Fallen Walker, despite the fact that it never really threatens to kill us outright. It's just a matter of finding ammo, and peppering the hulking menace until its health-bar is depleted. If a team mate goes down, revives are quick, and you respawn after 30 seconds anyway. These boss fights have none of the smart pacing or spectacle of the Scarab fights in Halo 2 and 3. Shame, because other foes level naturally, creating a very balanced difficulty to the whole game.

Again, though, there's time to fix problems ahead of September's release. And isn't balancing exactly what Betas are for? The secret to staying successful in games isn't through constant reinvention, it's through learning from your past, and being ambitious with your future. That's exactly what Bungie is doing with Destiny. The Chief may have moved house, but this is still the home of aspiring sci-fi gaming. Don't believe me? Surely the Beta has downloaded on your console by now... better start playing.


  • ceranoe - July 19, 2014 2:25 p.m.

    please can someone tell me what is with this creepy romanticism with halo/masterchief? like seriously when the first halo came out there were plenty of better games. the same faceless protagonist with the same bulky ass weapons with the same alien story. i want 1 good reason other than "destiny is a halo mmo" to be brought to me before ill even consider purchasing another halo game. i bought the first one on xbox and i didnt find anything new in it. it didnt have any new features that didnt already exist and in fact had less than some. i dont understand why people like it so much and if destiny is just a halo-ish mmo game then theres no reason why it should have such a massive following. im the guy that has every console and has not one halo game for any system. i HAD halo one for my pc and i got rid of it after i beat it. i was not impresssed. the way i feel about a halo mmo feels like someone some where is trying to make a poorly written DOOM mmo. please tell me you kiddies arent too young to remember doom? or a quake mmmo.
  • Shigeruken - July 17, 2014 11:10 p.m.

    Destiny certainly seems like a logical evolution of Bungie's Halo formula. I wouldn't be all that surprised if the rumors about Guardians being less linear prove to be true. I'll be dropping $250 NZD (217 USD) on the Ghost edition, so I really hope Destiny ends of being great.
  • _--_ - July 17, 2014 3:33 p.m.

    --i dont like how its a 7th gen game --bungie has been building this game all this time --its basically dropping about a year after 8th gen launch --and its just a 7th gen game --that is also on 8th gen consoles --i know its still early in the generation --but still --whats the 'real' point in 'bringing in' 8th gen --if ALL the games are just 7th gen(ESPECIALLY a game as 'big of a deal' as this one) --true~the game will 'look better' on ps4 --but at its core(mechanics) --this is a 7th gen game
  • TheMariner - July 19, 2014 6:37 a.m.

    I understand where you're coming from, and that's one of the reasons why I love that Assassin's Creed Unity is 8th gen-only. However, one of the problems with making games only for 8th gen is that the install base is still rather low compared to their 7th gen counterparts. The most recent figures I could find put the PS4 at 9 million and the Xbone at 3 million. From a purely business oriented standpoint, it makes sense to include the 7th gen consoles which stand at 80 million for PS3 and 83 million for X360. What really needs to happen is that more companies need to take Ubi's route with AC: Unity and make games only for 8th gen which will force an increase in the install base if people want to play them. It will happen eventually, but we are currently still in the odd limbo period between console generations.
  • _--_ - July 19, 2014 3:12 p.m.

    --ubisoft is getting paid 'more' by xb and PS to make asscreed 8th gen exclusive --then theyll turn-over for the next 3 years --thats pretty standard console manufacturer practice(in times like these) --and asscreed is the poster boy for sellout~ nobodies-land fodder --in other words --asscreed 2014 is a 7th gen game --being released only on 8th gen --because they got paid off to do so --as of 2 weeks ago --XB1 has sold 4.8 million units --wiiU has sold 6.6 --ps4 has sold 8.4 --and --thats sold~not shipped --for the last coupla months --ps4 sells a lil over 100,000 units a week --while wiiu and XB1 sell around 60,000(wiiU was hanging around the 30,000 unit a week mark~but MK8 has SERIOUSLY increased the wiiu's weekly numbers) --3ds dominates the landscape weekly (with a very occasional drop to 2nd place under ps4) --asscreed 2014 is NOT a 'true' 8th gen game --just because a game is exclusive to 8th gen consoles --does not mean that it was developed 'only' for 8th gen consoles --if a game will 'run' on a 360 --there is NOTHING 8th gen about the game --when developers start 'truly' building 8th gen games --after a few years --it wont just be a 'graphical' difference --the very core of the mechanics will start to change(more complicated and bigger~like HEAVILY improved ai and stuff) --its just sad --we'll be playing 7th gen games for the next 3 years atleast --i do think however --that because of CDproject-red's development 'background' --that the witcher3 --will be our first REAL 'glimpse' --into what an 8th gen game 'can be'
  • TylerYatesHere - July 17, 2014 3:33 p.m.

    Still am annoyed that Playstation gets the beta for longer than other platforms. Without XBOX (or PC at the beginning) Bungie might not have taken off too well with Halo. And then we wouldn't have Destiny. But I suppose you could look at it as Playstation have never had the chance to experience the awesomeness of Bungie or Halo so they're getting a bit of a leg up.
  • brian-stephenson - July 19, 2014 9:15 a.m.

    They started strictly on Mac. Microsoft bought Bungie shortly after Steve Jobs showed halo at the Macworld expo and it ended up being a xbox game. Besides they had other hit games before Halo anyway, if anything Halo helped Microsoft sell xboxes. As for the beta who really cares it was a business decision seeing as how they're working with Activision. They also already know the xbox infrastructure for online, the Playstation infrastructure was new to them, hence the longer beta test period for Sony. Bungie also did release a game on the PS2 before Microsoft bought them so Sony people did see the awesomeness of Bungie before Microsoft did.
  • diizzymatt - July 17, 2014 11:08 a.m.

    Nobody is downloading it on Xbox yet....

Showing 1-8 of 8 comments

Join the Discussion
Add a comment (HTML tags are not allowed.)
Characters remaining: 5000