5. The Wolf Among Us (PS3, Xbox 360, PC, Mac)
The Wolf Among Us is a game in which you play as Bigby Wolf (AKA, The Big Bad Wolf), living in New York City protecting a community of displaced fairy tale characters. Yeah, weird, right? Telltale's next game is based on the popular Fables series of comics (just like, you know, The Walking Dead was), and looks to continue the same story-driven adventure gameplay that won the studio oh so many Game of the Year awards last year.
Don't expect it to try to repeat its success beat for beat, though--Bigby is a far more physical character, and the gameplay adapts accordingly. Sure, you'll still walk around and investigate stuff, but you'll also occasionally need to huff, and puff, and beat the crap out of people that don't know their place. It's super stylish and super fun.