The Eternal Daughter review: "Double Tilda Swinton in a slender tale of grief"

Tilda Swinton in The Eternal Daughter
(Image: © A24)

GamesRadar+ Verdict

Joanna Hogg on ponderous, observational form – like the hotel at the heart of this tale, it won’t be everyone’s cup of tea.

Why you can trust GamesRadar+ Our experts review games, movies and tech over countless hours, so you can choose the best for you. Find out more about our reviews policy.

Joanna Hogg continues her autobiographical-film journey with her take on '40s psychological mystery (think Rebecca, with more hot water bottles). The Eternal Daughter is a tale of grief that’s slight but provides double Tilda Swinton. 

Following on from The Souvenir Part II, the film sees the now-elderly Rosalind (Swinton) being whisked away to a manor-house hotel for some R & R by her “fusspot” filmmaker daughter (and Hogg avatar) Julie (Swinton, taking on the role played by real-life daughter Honor Swinton Byrne in the Souvenir movies). 

The hotel is one any staycationing Brit might recognise: a fusty pile run by one unhelpful receptionist (Carly-Sophia Davies, nailing passive-aggressiveness) where everything creaks in the night and there’s only four unimaginative choices at dinner. As fog curls around the grounds and windows shimmer with possible spectres, Julie attempts to write a screenplay about her mother, trying to tease information out of a stiff-upper-lip woman who clearly hides fissures of emotional pain.

That explorative screenplay is the one we’re watching play out in front of us, which may feel self-indulgently meta from the off for some viewers. But get past the conceit and Hogg’s trademark celebration of the mundanity of human interaction is a tiny treasure to behold – much like the pillbox Rosalind keeps her “little helper” tablets in. 

The precision of Hogg’s script and Swinton’s cadence captures recognisable conversations between parents and their children, as mother and daughter discuss the merits of soup over beetroot salad, where to find a kettle and whether to go to lunch with a cousin. On the surface such exchanges are banal, yet loaded with meaning and intention. Then, as the family dog (Swinton’s own pet, Louis) gets antsy, mysterious crashes are heard in the night and the soundtrack signals disquiet, The Eternal Daughter leans into the ghost-story genre, ultimately yielding a haunting quality of a different kind. 

Over the few nights the women stay in the hotel little actually happens, aside from nocturnal forays for hot water or a mildly anxious search for a dog. But the mother/daughter relationship shifts to deliver a payoff that plays like Hogg’s version of an Inside Number 9 episode. Add to that an exploration of the role of exploitation in creating art from lived experience and this (will’o-the-)wisp of a film is a beauty depending on the eye of the beholder; frustratingly slender yet with moments of profundity. 

More info

Available platformsMovie
Editor-in-Chief, Total Film

Jane Crowther is a contributing editor to Total Film magazine, having formerly been the longtime Editor, as well as serving as the Editor-in-Chief of the Film Group here at Future Plc, which covers Total Film, SFX, and numerous TV and women's interest brands. Jane is also the vice-chair of The Critics' Circle and a BAFTA member. You'll find Jane on GamesRadar+ exploring the biggest movies in the world and living up to her reputation as one of the most authoritative voices on film in the industry.