The Top 7… Saddest video games that will make you cry
For years, developers have tried to make games that would touch gamers on an emotional level. Some emotions, like fear, are fairly easy to elicit – as games like Resident Evil and Amnesia have proven time and time again. But fear is easy. The real success in terms of emotional investment is sadness, and making a game that will "make the player cry" has been something developers have attempted for years.
Usually, their efforts bomb horribly, coming off as insincere, but every so often there are great successes. We've assembled the games that have caused up to tear up, sniffle, or outright break down and sob. So grab a box of tissues and get ready to let it all out.
And be warned, there are some spoilers here, obviously, though we've marked them so that you won't mistakenly stumble onto a character death and start crying.
7. Silent Hill: Shattered Memories
There's a good chance you didn't play Silent Hill: Shattered Memories. It
was, after all, released primarily on the Wii just too late in the
generation for a third-party title to really make waves. If you skipped it,
then you missed out on the best Silent Hill in years. And you also missed out
on crying a whole bunch. Because the game will make you cry a whole bunch.
Above: A trailer for the game that most likely won't make you cry
What makes Shattered Memories different from other sad games is that it actually isn't all that sad right away. Actually, you may not even realize what's so sad about it until you get to the end of the game, and even that isn't all that depressing. It's not until you
beat the game, and then start thinking back over the events that took place,
that you'll start piecing things together and laughing about how hard you're
crying.
And if you play it again? Grab the tissues, you’re in for an absolute
bawl-fest.
6. Final Fantasy VII
Death isn't really all that frightening in a video game, especially an RPG.
Heck, characters die in nearly every battle, and they're just brought back to life
with a cheap item. Whatever. It doesn't matter. Just shove a Phoenix Down into
their rotting mouth and they’ll be back on their feet within seconds.
Or, at least, that’s what we thought. This ignorance was used against us in
Final Fantasy VII, the game that put death back on the table in RPGs.
Above: Beware spoilers in the video above (and text below)
In a twist that would be called one of the most shocking in video game history, Aerith, Cloud's love interest and one of the more important party
members in the story, was stabbed by Sephiroth. And then she died. And then she
didn't come back.
We couldn’t believe our eyes. She would come back, right? This happened in
Chrono Trigger and then he came back, so surely she couldn’t be… dead? Yeah.
But she was. And we were heartbroken.
5. Gears of War 2
Marcus Fenix isn't really all that interesting of a main character. His partner, Dominic Santiago, on the other hand, has a much deeper persona. He's complicated, with motives beyond "kill all thems there locusts and maybe find out about my daddy." See, Dom is looking for his wife, Maria, who went missing once the imulsion hit the fan during Emergence Day. For the entire first game (and part of the second), Dom searches for information about her, getting glints of hope from time to time as he flashes her picture to other survivors.
And then... well... um... he finds her?
Above: The above video contains spoilers for Gears of War 2 – be warned
Say that Gears of War is for meatheads. Say that it's a dumb game with terrible writing. Say whatever you want – it doesn't matter. Epic nailed the segment where Dom finds Maria, and we were bawling like we just got dumped the night before Spring Formal. Dom's voice actor, Carlos Ferro, actually stepped into the mo-cap suit for the first time in this scene, adding to the emotion, and making this one of the saddest game moments we've ever experienced. And it was in Gears of War 2, so we were totally blindsided.
4. Lost Odyssey
Thousand-year-old
Kaim suffers from amnesia. It’s easy to see his lack of memories as a curse –
those are a lot of forgotten memories – but after playing just a few hours of
Lost Odyssey we’re pretty sure that Kaim’s better off not remembering his past.
As the game goes on, he’ll occasionally be reminded of events in his life, which play out on-screen as short stories consisting simply of text and sound effects.
They’re utterly
devastating. There are dozens of
these forgotten memories, and we eventually had to stop reading them. Some tell
tales of lost love, some of forgotten friends. Others are just downright
depressing, expertly crafted by fantastic writers whose only goal was to make
us miserable. Seriously, take a look at one of these things:
And even if you
avoid these catastrophically dismal memories, the story itself is just as
rough. At one point you help children gather flowers for their sick mother, and
then when you bring them to her she dies and you stand there awkwardly as the
children cry. That’s actually a thing that happens.
3. Shadow of the Colossus
Character motivation is usually pretty cut-and-dry. You're killing the bad guys who are trying to take over the world, or you're trying to get revenge, or you're trying to save someone. In Shadow of the Colossus things aren't so clear. Plot details are dripped slowly throughout the course of the game, but you eventually learn out that your character, named in the credits as Wander, has traveled to the forbidden land to resurrect a girl named Mono with the help of Dormin, a powerful, evil-ish god. So far so good, right?
But before the creepily-voiced Dormin is willing to bring Mono back, he needs Wander to travel around the massive, desolate landscape and slay 16 colossi. That's it. There are no strange puzzles, no other enemies, just a man and his horse wandering the world to kill giants.
Above: This trailer isn't that sad, but the rest of the game totally is
After a little while, killing these colossi... it starts to get to you, man. They're literally just chilling, minding their own business, and then some punk kid climbs up their back and stabs them in the head until they die. They aren't rampaging around cities or killing people. They're sleeping. Eventually you'll find a colossus – and it's different for every person – who pushes you over the brink and makes you start doubting what you're doing. It's just going to happen. And you're going to get sad.
We're not even going to deal with the ending stuff right now, because screw that. It's essentially like the first 15 minutes of Pixar's UP, except you're in control and it's sadder because there were giants involved.
Sad giants.
2. Mother 3
Nintendo never gave a reason for Mother 3's lack of a worldwide release, but we think we know why it was never officially translated to English: it was too goddamn sad. We imagine that Nintendo just had to scrap the translation after a few months of work because the translators couldn't see the game text past their tears. That's the most practical excuse.
Mother 3's story is tragic, but what makes it hit even harder is how randomly the depressing bits show up. Mother 3, like
Earthbound before it, is absolutely hilarious. The characters are funny, the dialog is wonderfully written, and the world is as whimsical as any RPG's. It totally catches you off guard when the
tone shifts completely from silly dances and fart jokes to real-world issues like the death of a family member.
Above: ULTIMATE SADNESS! (not really)
It follows a small, wholesome town torn asunder by a series of unfortunate events. The inhabitants don't even know how to handle things right away, with the game's narration eventually breaking the fourth wall just to ponder aloud if the townspeople had ever experienced sadness before. If the concept of a tight-knit village being exposed to the abstract concept of "sadness" for the first time doesn't have you blabbering like a teenage girl watching A Walk to Remember, the ending will. We're not going to spoil it for you, but believe us when we say that the last few minutes of the game will kick your heart in the ass really, really hard.
1. To The Moon
To the Moon is so sad that you'll be dehydrated once it's over. That's how much you'll have cried. It takes place in the not-too-distant future, where trained specialists have the ability to enter into the memory of people in order to change things. While you might think this sort of power would be use to Incept people, it's actually primarily used to grant the wishes of people on their death bed. Always wanted to go to France but never actually went through with it? Wish you told that crush that you love her? Doctors can dive into your memories and convince your younger self to do just that, leaving you to die without any regrets.
We'll skip over the morally grey areas of this practice and skip right to the plot: you play as doctors going into the memories of Johnny, a dying man who has wanted to go to the moon since his wife passed away. Trouble is, he has no idea why he wants to go there, so before you're able to convince his memories to do it, you need to track down the source.
What follows is a dive into the memories of an old man, dropping down a few years every so often and reliving his life in reverse. It covers with typical issues one would deal with during a long life, ranging from monetary problems to relationship issues.
Above: Oh god we just watched this video and now we're tearing up
And it's the saddest thing ever. Playing in reverse means you first see him grieving for his dead wife, and then him seeing her on her death bed, and then her finding out she's dying, and then... it just gets worse and worse. By the time she's healthy your mind is already full of sadness at her death, and the knowledge that you can't do anything to change it. To make things even more emotionally devastating, traveling back through his memories reveals that the game actually takes place in the future, and that he was born in the 1980s, which means he's in his 20s now, building a stronger connection.
All of the depressing, crippling sorrow comes to a head at the ending, which made us more emotional than we were during any movie, television show, or book we can remember. It's an amazing experience, and one that'll have you dry heaving tears for months.
What did we miss?
Yeah, we know, you disagree with us. We're wrong about one of the entries, or we forgot something, or we're stupid for not including your favorite game of all time. It's fine, we get it.
Don't just sit there shouting at the screen, though - comment below and let us know what you think of this Top 7.
I think another poster or two may have mentioned this game already, but I had to add to the discussion and say...
The Walking Dead
Episode 1..."Oooh a zombie-themed point and click adventure..cool!"
Episode 2..."Woah this is a bit dark"
Episode 3..."This is probably the best game I've played this year!"
Episode 4..."Oh god no!!!"
Episode 5...
Well, lets just say by the end of Episode 5 there were tears rolling down my face, and when the song kicks in at end (Alele Diane "Take Us Back") I was sobbing like a baby...
One of the most emotional games I've ever played...
Definantly
I was laying in bed ubtil 10 cryin just thinking about
Why? Why did she do it? Why didnt he cut his arm off before it got to his body
And why did it? Omg saddest thin ever
Max Payne 2 absolutely needs to be on this list. You'll hear the protagonist utter "Like all of my problems, this one started with the death of a woman" within the first few minutes. That should give you an idea of how beautiful and tragic the entire game is, right up to its heart-breaking conclusion. Also, check out "Late Goodbye" by Poets of the Fall, an excellent song recorded for (and implemented in) the game.
I played through To The Moon. My God, that is the most emotional, sad and beautiful story I've ever encountered. Not just in gaming, in anything! I cried and cried at the bittersweet end.
It wasn't really even a game. There was essentially no actual gameplay other than clicking on objects and occasionally solving very simple puzzles. You can't fail or die, you just explore each of the character's memories and then move back to an earlier memory.
Despite lacking any real gameplay, its story was simply astounding. I wish there was a movie or something. Using Chrono-Trigger-esque graphics, the game shows beautiful but simple imagery, the music plays well to the story line, and you'll cry like a baby at the end.
I think it was FFIV, searching for General Leo (?) only to find he was dead and never coming back - unless you played the Japanese version. Very sad moment to me...
Didn't a character die in Final Fantasy II also? I thought someone was sick and died off there...
One of the characters died in Legend of Dragoon, but was replaced by a similar - still it was a sad moment.
When the killed Lulu in Suikoden III - they killed a little kid! That character had a great personality and they just killed him! THAT was the saddest to me!
SPOILER ALERT:
Actually Aerith DID come back - at the end she came back as a spirit and showered the world with some sort of healing light. They plainly showed her (spirit) face and her action of spreading a shower of golden drops of light all over the world.
I'm going to echo what a lot of people said about Nier. Nier definitely deserves a place in this list towards the top.
I can't forget the first time I meet an NPC named Fayra she's undeniably cute evening running around helping you making cute eeps as she runs. My first thought was "aww she's cute" followed by a sad sinking feeling knowing that something horrible was going to happen to her.
Because thats what this game does. It never ends happy. All the sidequests only lead up to sad moments, the amazing music in the background is depressingly somber.
The game makes your character out to be noble beyond corruption, the then ofcourse after you played the game once and are on NG+ you find out that most the monsters you killed were only really defending themselves against your unrelenting bloodlust. Good job, Hero.
What picture is that first picture from??? I think the first character is Aerith from final fantasy but the second character I have no Idea and it's driving me crazy!!!!
Spoilers for Shadow of the Colossus;
I know he said he wouldn't go into ending details for SotC, but I'm sooo glad that it was in this list. I almost gave up after Agro "died." I mean, the other games made me really sad, but Agro...I just sat there and silently cried. And, yeah, around Phalanx, I began wondering why I had to kill the Colossi, and what they were doing before I came along. God, I hate Dormin.
I haven't played SH:Shattered Memories, but I guess it is a remake/"reimagining" of the original Silent Hill, which contains one of the saddest moments that I can think of in a video game: you are stuck in this desolate place with very few others, and after you become attached to the most sympathetic of them, Lisa Garland, she deteriorates into one of the monsters. I remember feeling so alone and abandoned when it happened.
SPOILER for Metal Gear Solid
The whole Metal Gear Solid saga had emotional moments for me, from Grey Fox's brave death, to finding out the truth about why big boss turned traitor...but nothing tied everything in like Metal Gear Solid 4. So many incredible moments, key characters death, Raiden's moment in the Shadow Moses Chapter...Snake collapsing when he reaches the final room in Outer Heaven, Naomi's speech. The biggest for me was the feeling of nostalgia when you first go back to Shadow Moses, hearing the ghostly echo's of the scenes that occurred in the rooms. Just seeing how much has changed in that place, makes you reflect on how your life has changed in the same period of time. I read in an article thats exactly what Hideo Kojima was trying to connect us to and it worked perfectly, its why the man is a genius in his field.
Other emotional gaming moments would have been the ending for Heavy Rain, Nathan Mar's story in particular...and also the brief section with the two brothers which i wont go into detail because its a spoiler and its really something that you should experience with an open mind.
I def agree with the Gears 2 article. I've recently finished the 3rd one and Dom's story once again delivers and until now thought it was actually sadder. But just watching that video clip had me welling up, Epic really exceeded themselves when its came to writing that scene
mass effect 3 had a few tear jerking moments. When I was speaking to Javik on earth and he said that he will kill himself after the reaper threat was gone brought a tear to my eye. Also when I saved the Rachni queen and grunt almost died made me start sobbing. It looked like he was gonna die right there!
As far as the Aerith death scene goes, for me it depended. It definitely was sad, but opposed to having like Vincent and Red in your team, you just give a look and walk on, put both Tifa and Yuffie in your party at this part in the game. You'll feel the sad coming on.
g1rldraco7 - January 18, 2013 8:21 a.m.