you guys are nuts Arkham City was a much better game than Asylum, true Asylum was a more focused story, []
you guys are nuts Arkham City was a much better game than Asylum, true Asylum was a more focused story, but that was all down to the location, it was narrow and confining and enveloped the player in a wonderfully gloomy atmosphere. Arkham city is a much more spiraling locale, therefore the story doesn't need to be as immediately focused, it allows you to explore the wonderfully detailed world at your leisure and the sheer size of the map and variety of gameplay puts Asylum to shame...
but as for GOTY material, before i played Skyrim i was 100% sure this was it, now its a wash and and its almost impossible for me to choose which is better...