Shadow Hearts: From The New World review

  • A wacky story filled with crazy characters
  • The Judgment Ring makes battles entertaining
  • Lot of rewarding little bonuses
  • A little too much pointless wandering
  • The gameplay hasn't evolved much
  • Its weirdness may turn off some

The Shadow Hearts series is an enigma in role playing games. You have one of the deepest combat mechanics in the genre, mixed with some seriously wacky storylines. After jumping the publishing ship from Midway to newcomer XSEED Games, one may worry that the delicate balance the series treads would be in jeopardy. Not so, and Shadow Hearts: From The New World is another truly great and genuinely interesting RPG.

We get introduced to a new cast of characters here, making it more spin-off than sequel. The setting is America, circa 1929, and young Johnny Garland ditches his hefty inheritance to make it as a New York detective. He's a typical orphaned, amnesiac main character, but the rest of the game's story and characters couldn't be further from the norm. Imagine Al Capone cavorting with a talking cat, or two gay merchants flamboyantly peddling their wares in a Native American village in the Grand Canyon. If you have any kind of a sense of humor, you'll find the tale engaging and a welcome departure from the typical.

The Judgment Ring is still the basis for all gameplay. For the uninitiated, it's a ring with a spinning cursor and areas where you need to click a button for successful execution of moves - almost reminiscent of a golf game. Few updates have occurred with it, but damned if it isn't still a clever way to play. Use it for attacks, spells, and even for shopping discounts. Customize the size or type to suit your skill level. Best of all, it forces you to pay attention during skirmishes - something too few RPGs require.

Magic is handled through a convoluted Stellar Chart that never really feels that intuitive. At least it's not too annoying, and it gives you some choices for who holds what spell. Combos are also back, and now you can make one character do double move duty in one turn. Used well, it allows for even more damage during battles.

Perhaps the most exciting thing about the battles, though, is sexy Native American character Shania, and her ability to morph into a variety of demonic forms. Always the cornerstone of the Shadow Hearts series - ex-lead Yuri did it too - this supernatural power returns with full gusto in the sequel. This leads to both brutal combat power and something lovely, if slightly twisted, to look at.

Another quality putting Shadow Hearts in a class of its own is how many little bonus things there are to occupy your time. Play the lottery, track your battle steps with a pedometer, trade snapshots of monsters, and catch supernatural creatures in a magical jar. Each character has a strange collection mechanic that lasts throughout the game; you can choose to ignore them, but the game is better for including them.

From The New World hasn't upgraded the series' graphics all that much. The game looks a little rough at times, but it's still overall pleasing to the eye. The CG cutscenes are especially nice, and of course character design is top notch. Environments are attractive but linear - though the fact that goodies are scattered around makes up for that fact.

The music is quirky and fits the early 20th Century vibe. Voiceovers only show up in cutscenes, but are well done. The wittiness of the writing makes up for the silence of the many random characters you'll meet, and you'll get a kick out of all the odd names - like "Out for a Stroll Edmond" or "Nina, Intoxicated With Herself."

Shadow Hearts: From The New World takes several risks - chief among them being the new publisher and the brand new story and characters. Amazingly, though, it works. It works really well. Shadow Hearts has a really odd world but at least it holds your interest. The Judgment Ring is old hat by now but it's still compelling. If the thought of playing as a goofy rip-off of Ninja Gaiden star Ryu Hyabusa named Frank, who always refers to himself in the third person, doesn't have you running for the hills, then by all means pick up Shadow Hearts: From The New World. You definitely won't find yourself bored.

More Info

Release date: Mar 07 2006 - PS2 (US)
May 25 2007 - PS2 (UK)
Available Platforms: PS2
Genre: Role Playing
Published by: XSEED Games
Developed by: Aruze, Nautilus
ESRB Rating:
Teen: Crude Humor, Language, Suggestive Themes, Use of Alcohol, Use of Tobacco, Violence
PEGI Rating:


Join the Discussion
Add a comment (HTML tags are not allowed.)
Characters remaining: 5000