At first, NeverDead seems like a standard, straight-up
action game. You know the type. Walk into a room, kill a bunch of monsters, the
door opens up, repeat. Every so often, there’s a mini-boss. At the end of the
level, there’s a big boss. Pretty basic stuff. You attack with dual guns, or a sword.
You block. You dodge. And sometimes you get hit.
And that is the
moment when everything goes wrong for NeverDead… when the one concept that
makes the game unique and original breaks it instead. Protagonist demon hunter Bryce
Boltzmann has been cursed with immortality, you see, and with that comes the “ability”
to drop limbs like so many leaves off a tree. It’s certainly an interesting
gimmick. That is, it would be, if it didn’t completely ruin the game.
Think about it like this: Action games are all about quick
reactions and precision. You need to be able to dodge when you need to dodge,
block when you need to block. And without limbs, it’s tough to do that. It’s
cool to have a visual representation of your failures, but when it only leads
to further failures, that’s a problem. Punishing players for mistiming a dodge
by chopping off their legs, thus making it impossible to dodge more isn’t interesting
design. It’s unfair. It certainly doesn’t help that limbs go flying off Bryce at
the slightest bump, which makes most of the game a mad scramble to get your
The worst part, though, is when Bryce’s head gets knocked off,
which happens at least a few times in every fight. Left as a slow-rolling cranium,
he has to reattach to his body before he can keep fighting. As he rolls along, small
enemies will attempt to suck him up, leading to a quicktime event that, upon
failure, means death for Bryce. It’s one of the most frustrating design
decisions we’ve experienced in a while.
This wouldn’t be such a big deal if the general combat
design wasn’t so flawed as well. Bryce’s default weapons of choice are dual
handguns. Unfortunately for his easily detached arms, aiming is sluggish and
imprecise. By the time he manages to get the aiming reticule around to an
enemy, there’s a strong chance that another will have snuck up behind him and bitten
something off. Of course, that means he’ll miss the first one, leading to a
frustrating cycle of aiming, getting whacked, searching for missing limbs, and repeating.
Thankfully, swordplay is a little more effective. Featuring
a nice auto-targeting mechanic, aiming isn’t really a problem. Plus, the sword
does a heck of a lot more damage than the guns, making the often tedious combat
sections go by slightly quicker. You can also take out large groups of enemies
by using the sword on the destructible environments, though crushing them with
falling sections of buildings isn’t as satisfying as it should be, as it seem
to happen at random. There’s very little rhyme or reason to what is
destructible, so actually killing anything with debris is tough to do on