Need for Speed SHIFT review

  • Handling is more realistic than GRID
  • Always something to unlock and awards to strive for
  • Being congratulated on being a precision driver
  • Drifting is more about precision than fun
  • Manual gears are awful
  • Not as much vehicle variety as GRID

No doubt about it, drafting in British developers Slightly Mad Studios has revitalised the series and turned it into a serious contender. Of course, it helps that Need for Speed SHIFT has clearly used last year’s king of the road, Codemaster’s brilliant GRID, as its benchmark.

Gone are the police. So too are the illegal street racing undertones, obsessions with extensive visual modifications (although bodykits, vinyls and paintjobs can still be tweaked) as well as any lame attempt at a storyline or bit-part glamour models squawking mission objectives at you through product-placement mobile phones.

Instead, we’ve been treated to a pretty damn excellent driving simulator that ticks all the right boxes: a wealth of cars bred for motorsport rather than pimping through LA; visceral engine noises; punishing vehicle damage; and handling that really starts to come alive the less you rely on driver assists. We’d happily admit it’s far more realistic than GRID but without the staid and intimidating nature of Race Pro or straight-laced functionality of Forza Motorsport 2.

Any issues we had with the handling at preview stage have been ironed out and what remains gives masses of feedback without feeling unapproachably hardcore. We still have a couple of issues, though – placing manual gear shifts on the shoulder buttons is a terrible idea (no controls customisation options either). And the drift mode requires such precision it’s more an exercise in how gently you can feather the accelerator, rather than the fun, smoke-pluming lunacy of GRID.

Unlike GRID’s scattershot career mode (throwing you from a Demolition Derby to a Formula 3 single-seater and so forth), SHIFT offers much more predictable progression. Working your way up through four tiers of races, from a VW Golf or tired old 1970’s Skyline up to a Bugatti Veyron, McLaren F1 or Pagani Zonda is typically Need for Speed.

In fact, even with the new direction and serious motorsport intentions, it’s very clear that SHIFT is a Need for Speed product. Although, being co-developed by EA Black Box (who’ve worked on NFS games for the last decade), this shouldn’t come as a surprise. While EA has entrusted driving duties to Slightly Mad, Black Box have concentrated on placing their unmistakable stamp on SHIFT too.

Beyond the aforementioned modification sections and the glitzy presentation, this comes in the form of your driver profile. With the devil of Aggression and angel of Precision sat on either shoulder (the two key areas in which your driving skills are judged by), you’ll be rewarded according to how you behave behind the wheel. With skill badges covering every aspect of racing (Drafting, Overtaking, Drifting, Podium finishes, etc) and specific Invitational events unlocked depending on your style, they act as pleasingly constant pats on the back. Plus, they can be used as a good indicator of an online opponent’s skill. For the brief while before everyone has gold everything, that is…

The best thing is that, even after you strip away the bells and whistles of in-race objective star collecting, award badge hording, swooshy menu screens and expensively licensed soundtracks, you’ve still got a great-looking, fine-handling racer that can hold its head high against some extremely strong competition. SHIFT may not have snatched the yardstick from Turn 10, Polyphony Digital or Codemasters, the damage model might not be the best in the genre, and nor is it the absolute, final word in realistic driving. But it has reignited our affection for Need for Speed – and that alone is a real achievement.

Sep 15, 2009

More Info

Release date: Sep 15 2009 - Xbox 360, PSP, PC, PS3 (US)
Sep 18 2009 - Xbox 360, PSP, PC, PS3 (UK)
Available Platforms: Xbox 360, PSP, PC, PS3
Genre: Racing
Published by: Electronic Arts
Developed by: Slightly Mad Studios
Franchise: Need for Speed
ESRB Rating:
Everyone: Mild Violence
PEGI Rating:


  • Cogglesz - October 9, 2009 5:17 a.m.

    shift is awesome, alot of people will probably have a hard time getting into the handling but once you've mastered it, it feels really realistic, i've had it since its release date and the only two problems i can find with it is the outter camera being too far away and there not being enough cars compared to todays racing sims, saying that i'm a fan of interior camera's so if your also a fan of that i recommend this game to you
  • e1337prodigy - September 26, 2009 10:01 a.m.

    I hate this game, the handling is not more realistic than GRID. I just touch the analogue controller and the car starts drifting. It feels slow and the AI is rubbish. I'm getting Forza 3 - a real driving game. In the meantime I play Dirt 2 and GRID.
  • Frostyman - September 21, 2009 11:11 p.m.

    And I have it, and so far, I love it. Except for the drift things...But thats just me, I suck at drifting.
  • Frostyman - September 18, 2009 8:10 p.m.

    Going to get soon as I get some money. Then ODST... But first this.
  • TheIronMaiden - September 16, 2009 5:33 a.m.

    I was on the rocks about this game, either this one or dirt 2, but I think I've finally settled, SHIFT it is!
  • wwfmankind - September 17, 2009 12:30 p.m.

    I'm still having some issues with the way the cars feel and handle... I can't explain it, but it just doesn't feel right. Dirt 2 feels a lot better to me.
  • purpleshirt - September 16, 2009 12:10 a.m.

    Hmmm, saw an ad for it and it looked fucking hot, but I'm not really a fan of driving games, and I still need to save for odst, mw2 and ac2, so I think I'll pass.

Showing 1-7 of 7 comments

Join the Discussion
Add a comment (HTML tags are not allowed.)
Characters remaining: 5000