You’ve probably heard us complain about the pains of sequelitus (yes, Call of Duty, we’re looking at you), but there’s something special about a spin-off that stars our favorite underdogs. Whether it’s Yoshi, Clank, Raiden, Daxter, Wario, Vincent Valentine - or even Tingle - there are plenty of fantastic spin-offs that prove not everything has to be .
But that’s not to say that the spin-off fields aren’t still ripe for the picking. While we’ve been plucking the crops, we’ve got a few spin-off games of our own to suggest, all based on the sidekicks that make the heroes great. In the feature below you'll find a collection of of guys, gals, robots, and aliens who have all proven to be so capable, interesting, and memorable that they could easily support their own downloadable offshoots and/or massive trilogies. These sidekicks shouldn’t be wasting any more time in the background, and we know just what type of game they should star in. Do we have your attention, corporate overlords?
Zelda (The Legend of Zelda)
Sorry, what is this game series called again? The Legend of who? Hmm, funny that. As big a deal as Zelda is in the Legend of Zelda series, and as skilled a fighter as she's implied to be, a game with her at the helm has yet to materialize. Hyrule Warriors gets close by making her playable and giving her control of her own badass army, but she gets the same amount of attention as everyone else in Team Fanservice, and basically ends up being upstaged by Link. Freakin' Link man. Ultimately, a game where she is the undisputed protagonist and doesn't get kidnapped is the only way to do this leading lady of Nintendo justice. Seriously, no kidnapping!
A Zelda-led title could fit snugly just about anywhere in the Legend of Zelda canon. Heck, she wouldn't even have to be a princess, if you wanted to go the Skyward Sword route. Just focus on her honing her magical abilities, and maybe make her transformation between Zelda and Sheik a gameplay mechanic as she travels through Hyrule on a quest to defeat Ganondorf. And it would be called The Legend of Link, naturally.
Alyx Vance (Half-Life)
Half-Life is defined by the silence of scientist-turned-savior Gordon Freeman, but Half-Life 2 introduced gamers to a character many would come to love much more than the stoic Freeman. Alyx Vance is one of the more multifaceted characters in gaming, at times strong and determined, and at other times scared and unsure of herself. Despite occasionally ending up the damsel in distress for Gordon to save, she’s often Freemans equal, if not better equipped to deal with the alien-infested totalitarian state the world has become.
Were Valve to make a game starring Alyx, it could finally break out of its silent protagonist mold and have her take an active role in the story. The game could be a prequel, telling of Alyx’s many exploits as part of the resistance before Gordon decided to wake up from his convenient slumber, but that seems too safe for Valve. Instead, how about they throw the entire gaming world a curveball and make her the star of Half-Life 3 (haha), killing off Freeman in the first ten minutes? Once players got over the shock, we think they’d ultimately appreciate a hero that can speak for herself.
Falco Lombardi (Star Fox)
Unlike most of the characters on this list, Falco has been trying his best to grab the spotlight since he first appeared. Hardly content to merely support Star Fox leader Fox McCloud, Falco is a hotshot pilot that consistently tries to outdo McCloud at every turn, and even when he slightly mellows with age, Falco's skills still rival Fox’s in the air. Plus, anyone that plays Super Smash Bros. Melee knows Falco is at least Fox’s equal in hand-to-hand combat. It’s time Lombardi got the starring role he so richly deserves.
As the Star Fox titles continue to move away from the arcadey flight that defined the series, Falco has always remained committed to the air, so let’s just keep him there. Let Fox have his tanks and submarines, and let Falco’s spin-off focus entirely on classically-styled flight levels featuring Lombardi leading a whole new team of pilots. Star Fox traditionalists would finally have the game they’ve been clamoring for, and Falco could finally become the leadership position we assume Nintendo has been grooming him for.
It's true that Lydia is just as prone to standing in your way during a fight or getting stuck in a door as any other AI companion who follows at your heels. Still, as perfect as she may be for Fus Ro Dah target practice, it feels like there's something special about her. Maybe it's because she's a beautiful first companion, and you never forget your first. Maybe it's that she's really really good at carrying stuff. Maybe it's because she's an accomplished bodyguard (don't let her standing on your toes in battle fool you) with a mysterious past that you're burning to discover. Maybe it's all those things, and maybe all of that's so interesting that she should get a game all to herself. You know, maybe. By which I mean definitely.
Since Lydia's life before she met the Dragonborn is seldom mentioned, a game centered on her journey to become the best housecarl in all the land is ripe for exploration. How does she work her way up the social ladder to enter the house of Jarl Balgruuf before she's gifted to her thane? How many dungeons did she get hopelessly stuck in before mastering the art? Where did she learn how to cook? I MUST KNOW!
Clay Carmine (Gears of War)
Throughout the original Gears of War trilogy, Clay Carmine proved that, in a world of horrific military casualties, the man with a decent set of armour of king. He managed to keep hold of his head and the majority of his limbs to Locust Swarms, which definitely can’t be said about his brothers.
Carmine’s adoring fans and impressive physical prowess means that he’s the kind of chap that is interesting and skilled enough to survive a game of his own.
Sadly for Carmine, Gears of War 4 told the tale of Marcus Fenix’s son, J.D Fenix and a bunch of his mates, with not a Carmine in sight - well not the one we want anyway. Maybe in Gears of War 5, we could see all the Carmine brothers together with Clay taking the lead. With their luck the guy would probably die dropping a stereo in a bathtub, but it's worth a shot!
Garrus (Mass Effect)
Calling Garrus a sidekick is a teensie bit demeaning, especially as Commander Shepard isn’t much without his or her crew. And what a crew they had. Whether it was Jack’s twisted view of the world, Liara’s dulcet tones, the mystery of Tali’s face or even the way Wrex growled your name, the cast of the original Mass Effect trilogy was just plain awesome.
But for us, whether your Shepard or fem-Shep, it was always Garrus, your constant friend who’s already ready for anything - even sarcastic commentary - that acted as your soulmate. So when it was revealed Mass Effect Andromeda would not be the Tales of Garrus, we have to say we were a little disappointed. After all, he really is the complete sidekick/soulmate package. It’s always been you Garrus, it’s always been you.
Though she turns into a bit of a damsel in Bayonetta 2, Jeanne is every bit her badass bestie's equal, and she takes care of herself just fine for the 500 years before the Bayonetta we know starts kicking around. What exactly was she up to all that time? Undoubtedly something completely insane involving a lot of interpretive dance and explosions, and you know you want to play the living hell out of it.
Since Jeanne would probably handle a lot like Bayonetta (if her unlockable model in both of the games is anything to go by), you can probably expect the same sort of globe-trotting, angel-stomping shenanigans from her. Plus, since the series tends to play it close to the vest with expository details, there are plenty of aspects of the world left to explore. Maybe Jeanne and Bayonetta's witch training, or the war between the Umbran Witches and the Lumen Sages, or the half of millennium of downtime afterward.
HK-47 (Star Wars)
For as interesting as the redemptive tale of Darth Revan was, virtually everyone that played Knights of the Old Republic remembers a certain deadly droid more than anyone else in the groundbreaking RPG. An accomplished droid assassin, HK-47 captured the hearts of gamers everywhere with his dark sense of humor and propensity for suggesting that murdering people with lasers was always the best solution to a problem. Popping up occasionally in sequels and both Star Wars MMOs, nothing seems to be able to stop this droid, so why don’t we just cut to the chase and give him his own game?
Fortunately for HK-47, the market for action games starring assassins is booming right now, so a Hitman/Assassins Creed type game starring HK-47 is like a blank check Disney has yet to cash. The publisher has already covered the darker aspects of the Star Wars universe in games like Force Unleashed, but telling tales of HK-47’s past working for gangsters and other unsavory elements would explore a part of Star Wars mythology rarely seen outside of the occasional novel or comic book. Wouldn't be canon, but does that really matter?
Frog (Chrono Trigger)
The supporting players in Chrono Trigger are so well realized and defined that almost any of them could support their own spin-off. We'd surely enjoy a game starring Magus or Robo, but we see the most star potential in the tragic tale of Frog. A noble, stoic knight thats cursed to be trapped in an amphibian's body, he doesn't let that stop him from being a heroic swordsman.
Though the official ending of Chrono Trigger has Frog return to his human form, we hope that the new side game would keep him in his green form. The setting could stay in his home time of 600 AD with him defending the realm from some new threat now that Magus is taken care of. You could even give him some sidekicks of his own who might just be cool enough to get a sequel in 2028.