Skip to main content
GamesRadar+ GamesRadar+ GamesRadar+ The Games, Movies, TV & Comics You Love
Sign in
  • View Profile
  • Sign out
flag of UK
UK
flag of US
US
flag of Canada
Canada
flag of Australia
Australia
  • Games
  • TV
  • Movies
  • Hardware
  • Video
  • News
  • Reviews
  • Guides
  • Deals
  • More
    • PS5
    • Xbox Series X
    • Nintendo Switch
    • Nintendo Switch 2
    • PC
    • Platforms
    • Tabletop Gaming
    • Comics
    • Toys & Collectibles
    • SFX
    • Newsarama
    • Retro Gamer
    • Newsletters
    • About us
    • Features
Total Film
Gaming Magazines
Gaming Magazines
Why subscribe?
  • Subscribe from just £3
  • Takes you closer to the games, movies and TV you love
  • Try a single issue or save on a subscription
  • Issues delivered straight to your door or device
From$12
View
Trending
  • Summer Game Fest
  • New games for 2025
  • Upcoming Switch 2 games
  • Switch 2 stock

Recommended reading

Clair Obscur: Expedition 33
JRPGs "There's nothing about JRPGs that requires them to be made in Japan," says ex Dragon Age writer, speaking nothing but facts – and Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 just proves it again
Count Louis in Metaphor: ReFantazio in an anime cutscene with a dead Human behind him
JRPGs Metaphor: ReFantazio smashed Atlus' expectations on PC - another reminder that PC gamers really want more JRPGs and Japanese games
Final Fantasy 7 Rebirth PS5 screenshot
JRPGs Amid Clair Obscur: Expedition 33's turn-based hype, Square Enix asks JRPG fans "what's the best combat system" in its catalog and shares "some games with brilliant battles"
Meeting the yeti-like puppet creature Monoco in Clair Obscur: Expedition 33
RPGs Ex Dragon Age writer says Baldur's Gate 3 and Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 prove publishers wrong on how successful RPGs can be "when the game is good," and "what's possible when a game is given time to cook"
Clair Obscure Expedition 33
RPGs It's "difficult to convince many people" that "your turn-based RPG will sell," Baldur's Gate 3 dev laments as Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 sells 1 million copies in 3 days
Baldur's Gate 3 screenshot showing Lae'zel, a Githyanki woman with olive green skin and tied-back red hair, smirking
RPGs The 25 best RPGs you can (and should) play right now
Strohl, Gallica, the protagonist, and Hulkenberg in a Metaphor: ReFantazio anime cutscene screenshot.
JRPGs "One wrong move and everything's lost": Metaphor: ReFantazio battle lead explains why turn-based JRPGs rule and why they absolutely have to be hard

Western RPGs vs Japanese RPGs - Great Debate

Features
By Hollander Cooper published 20 September 2012

Which role-playing genre will reign supreme?

When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here’s how it works.

The battle of the genre within the genre

The battle of the genre within the genre

For the past few years weve noticed a decline in the quantity of Japanese role-playing games and a rise in the number (and quality) of western RPGs. Some argue that this is a good thing, and that the West has finally begun to triumph over the East when it comes to the RPG, while others believe that JRPGs are still the superior sub-genre.

Today, Hollander Cooper (1-1-0) takes the side of WRPGs, while Henry Gilbert (0-1-0) argues for the East. Which RPG is the best kind of RPG? Its time for the great debate.

Page 1 of 10
Page 1 of 10
Henry says: Japanese developers care about making characters look unique

Henry says: Japanese developers care about making characters look unique

Henry: You can complain about repeated tropes all you want, but the developers care about making every single character look good. You wont see any stock armor or interchangeable space suits on JRPG characters. Each is a special snowflake, each made to stand out from the everyday people that fill the world. Even those that mock the pointy hair and zippers of some JRPG heroes have to admit that theyre memorable.

Cooper: Unique doesnt always equal good. Sure, androgynous protagonist wearing a belt and sporting spiky hair A might look different from androgynous protagonist wearing a belt and sporting spiky hair B, but being different isnt always all that special. Also, I dont even know if I agree that theyre all that unique--most sport the same outfits, hairstyles, and personalities. Whats so unique about that?

Page 2 of 10
Page 2 of 10
Cooper says: WRPGs have less tired cliches

Cooper says: WRPGs have less tired cliches

Cooper: Nice belts, bro. Nice crystals, buddy. Nice spiky hair, dude. JRPGs aren't all the same, but... well, they're pretty close. A ragtag group of teenagers picking up swords, staves, and bows to fight a boring evil presence might have felt original in 1995, but in 2012 it's just a crutch. Meanwhile, BioWare and Bethesda are creating massive worlds (or universes) and finding interesting things to shove in them besides floating crystals.

Henry: Western RPGs may paint compelling characters in the corners, but the leads are almost always of the vanilla chosen one variety. Or the protagonist is drawn in incredibly broad strokes to give players the idea that theyre really defining their characteristics, which is consistently not the case. And dont underestimate the interesting characters that populate franchises like Persona and Lunar.

Page 3 of 10
Page 3 of 10
Henry says: JRPGs have a better sense of drama

Henry says: JRPGs have a better sense of drama

Henry: The overly open nature of Western-style RPGs like Elder Scrolls end up lacking in payoff and feel increasingly random in their plot structure. The plots in JRPGs, like Chrono Trigger and Persona 4, are built around major moments that still work within the inviting structure of role-playing. And boss battles have satisfying, cinematic conclusions instead of ending with the empty thud of one last, wild sword swing.

Cooper: Melodrama is more like it. Theres nothing legitimately dramatic about teenagers whining about the fate of the world for 265 hours. By the time you actually get to the bosses youve helped, every townsperson find love and discover friendship, and those cinematic conclusions usually come after youve completed a nonstop barrage of trivial quests seemingly built from the ground-up to remove any real sense of drama or urgency from the story.

Page 4 of 10
Page 4 of 10
Cooper says: JRPG plots are often confusing, muddled messes

Cooper says: JRPG plots are often confusing, muddled messes

Cooper: In order to understand the plots of games like Final Fantasy XIII and Kingdom Hearts, you need to essentially pause the game every hour to read codex entries telling you who the Lacie or Nobodies or Organization XI is. It's overly complicated, and not all that interesting, even when you take the time to study their plots. Western RPGs don't fall victim to this folly, and usually include stories that make sense, or at least stories that make more sense than most JRPG plots.

Henry: Its true that some recent series seemed more interested in confusing players than telling a story, but it should be noted that most JRPGs are famous for telling complete stories in each game. Each new Final Fantasy and Dragon Quest told stories with a beginning, middle, and end that introduced whole new worlds that were hardly ever revisited. They didnt end in a lousy cliffhanger to make room for the next entry in a planned trilogy.

Page 5 of 10
Page 5 of 10
Henry says: Theres much better quality control

Henry says: Theres much better quality control

Henry: This is low-hanging fruit, and the only consistent culprit is genre leader Bethesda, but seriously, western RPGs seem too lazy or indifferent to not ship without massive, game breaking bugs. Bugs that might get fixed in a patch and will likely never be addressed, since the devs are busy working on the next broken game. Youll never see that in a Dragon Quest or Shin Megami Tensei game, since the developers pride themselves in their games actually being playable.

Cooper: Sure, if you compare every JRPG to Skyrim, youre going to notice more bugs, but thats the extreme situation. Most Western RPGs ship relatively bug-free, and though you wont see JRPGs like Dragon Quest or SMT shipping with huge bugs, plenty of JRPGs have issues when they are released.

Page 6 of 10
Page 6 of 10
Cooper says: WRPGs include more interesting combat

Cooper says: WRPGs include more interesting combat

Cooper: JRPGs have spent the last ten years scrambling to find a way to merge classic turn-based battles with action-based combat, and, by and large, they've failed. Games like Final Fantasy XIII and Xenoblade Chronicles end up feeling like dumbed-down massively-multiplayer online RPGs once blades are drawn. Meanwhile, Mass Effect has some of the best shooting in the genre, and Kingdoms of Amalur plays like God of War, while still maintaining its RPG roots.

Henry: First off, whats wrong with having a little extra time to think out your next move during turn-based combat? Second, Mass Effect was hanging on to the RPG genre by a thread in ME3, and Kingdoms of Amalur was only really an RPG in its trappings. They succeed in changing RPGs by leaving the genre altogether. With RPG elements in every game these days, its nice to still see an RPG fight actually work like an RPG.

Page 7 of 10
Page 7 of 10
Henry says: JRPGs have unforgettable soundtracks

Henry says: JRPGs have unforgettable soundtracks

Henry: While Ill give Mass Effect credit for its distinct music, so many other western RPGs settle for epic scores that all sound like theyre merely ripping off the Lord of the Rings films. Meanwhile, JRPGs have been famous for decades for pioneering musically, and still do. Theyre much more committed to diverse soundscapes that give a different flavor to each new world and situation. Just look up the music of Nobou Uematsu, Yasunori Matsuda, and Yuzo Koshiro if you dont believe me.

Cooper: JRPG music used to be good, but in the last few years the quality has dropped significantly, leading to less memorable soundtracks. Now, many just substitute in cheesey J-Pop or obnoxious techno. No thanks.

Page 8 of 10
Page 8 of 10
Cooper says: Choice-driven narratives are superior

Cooper says: Choice-driven narratives are superior

Cooper: Say what you will about Mass Effect 3's ending, but that series has revolutionized the idea of player choice in a video game. Being able to shape not just your story, but an entire universe makes the events feel more important. It's a groundbreaking achievement in storytelling, and it's becoming more and more common, creating replayability beyond grinding to get XxUltimaxX versions of every weapon.

Henry: As with other parts of this list, Mass Effect is the exception that proves the rule. Most of the different endings youll see after completing Western RPGs basically amount to your character wearing a different hat as one of three possible endings plays on the screen. While some JRPGs do offer multiple endings, its more important to the creators to end strong instead of hoping the players found a compelling conclusion on their own.

Page 9 of 10
Page 9 of 10
Dun dun dun dun, dun dun dun dun dun!

Dun dun dun dun, dun dun dun dun dun!

So, who do you side with? Henry and team turn-based battles, or Cooper on the side of choice-driven narratives? Answer the poll and comment below to let us know who you think won this Great Debate.

Who do you think won the debate?

And if you want more Great Debates, check out free-to-play games vs. pay-to-play games and Mario vs. Sonic.

Great Debate pits two editors in a head-to-head battle to debate some of gamings hottest topics. Have a subject you want them to discuss? Let us know in the comments and well wrangle some editors to talk it over.

Page 10 of 10
Page 10 of 10
Hollander Cooper
Hollander Cooper
Social Links Navigation

Hollander Cooper was the Lead Features Editor of GamesRadar+ between 2011 and 2014. After that lengthy stint managing GR's editorial calendar he moved behind the curtain and into the video game industry itself, working as social media manager for EA and as a communications lead at Riot Games. Hollander is currently stationed at Apple as an organic social lead for the App Store and Apple Arcade. 

Read more
Clair Obscur: Expedition 33
"There's nothing about JRPGs that requires them to be made in Japan," says ex Dragon Age writer, speaking nothing but facts – and Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 just proves it again
Count Louis in Metaphor: ReFantazio in an anime cutscene with a dead Human behind him
Metaphor: ReFantazio smashed Atlus' expectations on PC - another reminder that PC gamers really want more JRPGs and Japanese games
Final Fantasy 7 Rebirth PS5 screenshot
Amid Clair Obscur: Expedition 33's turn-based hype, Square Enix asks JRPG fans "what's the best combat system" in its catalog and shares "some games with brilliant battles"
Meeting the yeti-like puppet creature Monoco in Clair Obscur: Expedition 33
Ex Dragon Age writer says Baldur's Gate 3 and Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 prove publishers wrong on how successful RPGs can be "when the game is good," and "what's possible when a game is given time to cook"
Clair Obscure Expedition 33
It's "difficult to convince many people" that "your turn-based RPG will sell," Baldur's Gate 3 dev laments as Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 sells 1 million copies in 3 days
Baldur's Gate 3 screenshot showing Lae'zel, a Githyanki woman with olive green skin and tied-back red hair, smirking
The 25 best RPGs you can (and should) play right now
Latest in
Fantastic Four Bookazine #1
You'll soon be able to buy Fantastic Four comics off a newsstand, just the way our ancestors once did
Death Stranding 2 PS5 screenshot
Hideo Kojima was "so bummed" Death Stranding 2 Easter eggs were "revealed on social media right away," but "I'm retweeting all these things so the blame is on me"
Sean Gunn as Maxwell Lord in Peacemaker season 2 trailer
Maxwell Lord - The comic history of the villain who mind-controlled Superman and almost destroyed the Justice League
Elden Ring
Elden Ring's new content and Nintendo Switch 2 release could be coming soon – the Tarnished Edition was just rated by the ESRB
Holding the Nintendo Switch 2
Amazon's missing out on that sweet Switch 2 money because Nintendo's mad about "unauthorized sales," new report suggests
lea seydoux as fragile smoking a cigarette
Hideo Kojima says "I'm happy with the scores, thank you" as Death Stranding 2 settles at 90 on Metacritic, overcoming his fears that it might be too likable
Latest in Features
Sean Gunn as Maxwell Lord in Peacemaker season 2 trailer
Maxwell Lord - The comic history of the villain who mind-controlled Superman and almost destroyed the Justice League
Hades 2 announcement trailer
70 hours later and with a full launch imminent, I already miss Hades 2 being in Early Access
Toothless, Miles Morales' Mask, Battle Droid with STAP, and Nike Dunk sets divided from each other by white lines, with a 'GamesRadar+ New Lego' badge in the middle
New Lego sets for July 2025, including the perfect gift I think fans will go nuts for
Jan sadly presses a hand on a screen that says 'deceased' in The Alters
The Alters has changed the way I play games for the better, and after 18 years I can finally finish Mass Effect
Sam balances across a ladder high up in the mountains in Death Stranding 2
Death Stranding 2 is my favorite online game this year, even though you never directly see any other players
Lee Jung-jae as Gi-hun in Squid Game season 3
The Squid Game season 3 finale is a crushing but ultimately hopeful conclusion – and I wouldn't have it any other way
  1. Sam fires at the ghost mech squid boss in Death Stranding 2: On the Beach
    1
    Death Stranding 2: On the Beach review: "This tarpunk delivery epic is more Metal Gear Solid than ever, for better and worse"
  2. 2
    Rematch review: "As with Rocket League, the just-one-more-game pull is magnetic"
  3. 3
    Tron: Catalyst review: "Disc slinging is a thrill in this gorgeous rendition of the series, but I'm let down by a time-loop story that falls flat"
  4. 4
    FBC: Firebreak review: "A disappointingly bland multiplayer FPS that's missing far too much of what made Control special"
  5. 5
    Dune: Awakening review: "Both extremely compelling and extraordinarily boring, sometimes at the same time – yet still a true Dune love letter"
  1. A T-rex in Jurassic World Rebirth
    1
    Jurassic World Rebirth Review: "An unscary sequel that needed a little more time in amber"
  2. 2
    M3GAN 2.0 review: "A bold sequel with a slightly underwhelming conclusion"
  3. 3
    28 Years Later Review: "Enough terror, splatter and suspense to satisfy”
  4. 4
    Predator: Killer of Killers review: "Great characters, thrilling action, and gorgeous Arcane-esque animation"
  5. 5
    From the World of John Wick: Ballerina review: "Brilliant action, even if the plot gives you a sense of déjà vu"
  1. Lee Jung-jae as Gi-hun in Squid Game season 3
    1
    Squid Game season 3 review: "A staggeringly excellent final season wraps up one of the greatest Netflix shows ever"
  2. 2
    Ironheart review: "A relic of Marvel's content-at-all-costs era"
  3. 3
    Star Trek: Strange New Worlds season 3 review: "The show's most assured run of episodes to date"
  4. 4
    Doctor Who season 2, episode 8 spoiler review: 'The Reality War' is "a mix of the good, the bad, and the truly baffling"
  5. 5
    Doctor Who season 2, episode 7 spoiler review: 'Wish World' is "an exciting and ambitious" start to the season finale, with hints of WandaVision

GamesRadar+ is part of Future US Inc, an international media group and leading digital publisher. Visit our corporate site.

  • About Us
  • Contact Future's experts
  • Terms and conditions
  • Privacy policy
  • Cookies policy
  • Advertise with us
  • Review guidelines
  • Write for us
  • Accessibility Statement
  • Careers

© Future US, Inc. Full 7th Floor, 130 West 42nd Street, New York, NY 10036.

Please login or signup to comment

Please wait...