Pokemon HeartGold/SoulSilver review

  • The Pokewalker
  • Integrated stylus controls
  • Nearly all 493 Pokemon in a single game
  • Core game is identical to the original
  • No tools for advanced training/breeding
  • Pokethlon offers few rewards

Just as every few years brings us a new Harry Potter movie, or another awful Dane Cook album, it's once again time for a new Pokemon game. HeartGold and SoulSilver are the latest in a long line of Pokemon remakes and updates, and as such offer the exact same improvements everyone has come to expect: more Pokemon, more side quests/mini-games, and better graphics.

Above: Turns out 10 years is a long time in video games! 

Not surprisingly, the battle system remains identical to the one introduced nearly 15 years ago in Red/Blue. Fire still beats grass, water still beats fire and of course, psychic still beats poison. Players trek from city to city, beating gym leaders, winning badges and catching and raising more Pokemon on their quest to defeat the Elite Four and become the Pokemon Champion. And as always, you'll casually trounce an evil Team Rocket or Team Rocket-esque crime syndicate on your way to the top as well. The major difference between HeartGold and SoulSilver is standard for the series, too: each version contains a few Pokemon the other does not. Although with global Wi-Fi trading, it's no longer necessary to force yourself to buy the other version or, depending on your age, muster up a bunch of fake tears to get your parents to cough up the cash.

HeartGold and SoulSilver are remakes of 2000’s Gold and Silver, which essentially means Nintendo has revamped a Game Boy Color game for the DS. That's a 10 year difference though so the similarities between the two are outweighed by the differences. HG&SS drags its source material games into the present day with a total graphical overhaul, a modernized Pokedex, full DS Stylus functionality and brand-new minigames and side quests.

The new stuff

The graphical updates from the original Gold/Silver are huge, and observant players will appreciate the new houses and architecture of the Johto region as well as the little things like the illustrated images that pop up when entering a cave or dungeon. All the graphical touches of Diamond Pearl and Platinum are here, and HG&SS definitely trumps its predecessors. While HG&SS is at its core, a remake, the only things that really remain the same are the world layout and plot points. For most people it’s been a decade since they’ve played Gold and Silver, and the magic of an eroding memory will make the bulk of HG&SS seems like a brand new experience.

Above: Totodile ponders his existence while enjoying the autumn leaves 

The best addition however, is the ability to have your Pokemon trail behind you, free of his/her Poke Ball. The sprites for your trailing Pokemon are simple, but each is totally unique- they even retain their colors if they’re a rare shiny variant. While it's a little detail, it definitely makes you more aware of your Pokemon and makes your character look a little less lonely wandering around Johto.

As Pokemon has aged, it's developed more and more features that have rendered its past iterations obsolete. Wi-Fi supplanted the link cable, defeated trainers began calling you to let you know when they were ready for a rematch, and now the stylus is slowly smoothing out the clunky Pokemon box and menu interface. Despite there being three versions of Pokemon on the DS, none of them ever utilized the stylus in any meaningful way; frankly it felt tacked on and underdeveloped. Fortunately HG&SS sports the best integration of the stylus yet, enabling you to navigate menus and Pokemon boxes more easily than before. In spite of this, the game’s menu still features the individual Withdraw/Deposit Pokemon options, which is redundant given that the Move Pokemon option is all you’ll ever want or need. You can even use the stylus to completely replace the face buttons, if you want. Given the repetitive nature of the gameplay, it’s nice to be able to swap between the two control options to keep your hand from getting tired.

Nintendo has also added additional challenges and competitions, including a tile-sliding puzzle in the ruins of Alph and a great "Voltorb Flip" minigame in the Goldenrod City Game Corner. It replaces the slot machines of the original Game Corner, but offers a great hybrid of Sudoku, Picross and Minesweeper that'll keep you busier a lot longer than you might expect. The biggest addition, though, is the Pokethlon.

The Pokelympic games

Above: Not Shown: $8 Poke Brats and $12 Poke Beers
HG&SS's Pokethlon games are like the previous games' Contests, non-combat competitions for your Pokemon to show their stuff and consist of a bunch of stylus-only minigames played by three-Pokemon teams. Also, each Pokemon gets a new set of stats for the Pokethlon, which include Speed, Skill, Strength, Endurance and Jump.

Some of the events work better than others. In the Ring Drop event, your Pokemon attempt to knock each other out of a ring, Sumo style, which is a lot of fun. Meanwhile, the Pennant Capture packs a bunch of scrambling Pokemon into a too-tight arena cluttered with debris while you struggle with overly sensitive controls. Overall, though, the games make a nice distraction from the constant grind of leveling and training. They’re also a particularly great addition for trainers who liked the Contests of previous games, but who would have liked them even more if they had hands-on (or stylus-on) control of their Pokemon. 

Above: Bonus points if you name your Pokemon Turbo, Laser, and Malibu
Ultimately, though, the actual rewards for participating in the events are minor. Points you earn can be traded for prizes, the most expensive of which include stones and items for evolving specific Pokemon. While the stones are generally rare in game, and it’s nice to have a reliable way to acquire them, this won’t appeal much to anyone but the most hardcore players. Your Pokemon also won’t gain any experience from the Pokethlon, meaning there's little practical reason to participate in the games other than personal entertainment. It’s another odd quirk that the game requires you to buy data cards to record your Pokethlon data, including how many matches you've won or how many times a certain Pokemon has jumped.

What Nintendo is doing with HG&SS is daunting, as it's akin to trying to make a 1930s Studebaker competitive in a world full of 2010 Porsches. The good news is, for the most part, they've succeeded. The visual updates and gameplay touches are nice, but the biggest sell for HG&SS is the Pokewalker.

More Info

Release date: Mar 14 2010 - DS (US)
Mar 26 2010 - DS (UK)
Available Platforms: DS
Genre: Role Playing
Published by: Nintendo
Developed by: Game Freak
ESRB Rating:
PEGI Rating:


  • stevenjohnson - July 19, 2010 10:53 a.m.

    lol,ive got all 3 starters and i pwn wit all of them.arby and the cheif on utube is the most funniest video ive seen.look it up on utube
  • Demonflare - March 26, 2010 12:11 a.m.

    I respect the game, I would buy it, yet its the remake of the Johto region, Ive got all of the pokemon except minor legendary pokemon. Im saving money for the generation 5 game. Zoroark is sexy! I love Pokemon!
  • super0sonic - March 21, 2010 7:14 p.m.

    I bought it and i LOVE it. But then i skipped gold and silver so this is all new to me!!
  • starhaw - March 17, 2010 7:55 p.m.

    I have always loved pokemon...but I would just love for Nintendo to just ONCE let them make a pokemon game on the console you know true 3D where you can see the actual pokemon walking in the grass, things like that....I remember in a GR article when they asked the developers of Pokemon why they wouldn't and they said it was because they wanted pokemon to be a traveling experience you know as if you where actually a poke-trainer carrying your pokemon with you where ever you go....well my solution to that is why not make the idk Wii version include a DS version so you can take your Pokemon on the go? ( I know that sounds a little hard with constantly having to transfer saved games and such but they could do it if they really wanted to) Captcha: The Girlhood (wth is that? lol sounds like some book a girl would read... )
  • Metroidhunter32 - March 12, 2010 11:48 p.m.

    Monster Hunter, Other M, and Ikaruga can all go suck it, I'm buying a DS now.
  • hardcore_gamer1990 - March 12, 2010 9:33 p.m.

    I'm going to get an old DS from my local and this game and that shall be my one and only game :) I never got to play gold/silver, so it'll be a new game to me.
  • Pocotron - March 12, 2010 9:31 p.m.

    @McSpermie Its cool man. We're all here to get our Pokemon freak on! Ammiright? (That came out wrong)
  • jackthemenace - March 12, 2010 7:58 p.m.

    I do quite want this game, but forking out £35-£40 is stupid. especially since one girl actually likes me, it'd be stupid to chase her away
  • Sukururu - March 12, 2010 6:11 p.m.

    *drool* All my great childhood memories in a remake....and don't have the console... D=
  • McSpermie - March 12, 2010 7:15 a.m.

    @Pocotron I'll stop here but there are other ways you could have gone about saying what you said, though it wasn't my place to say it was childish because in truth it wasn't, just as you said it was fanboyish which isn't a bad thing at all. Sorry to have offended you :D
  • secretsearcher - March 12, 2010 4:50 a.m.

    Gold/Silver are still my favorites of the generations. So a remake would be fantastic :). But in my opinion, I liked the contests in the Ruby/Sapphire Games. The Diamond/Pearl contests were too gimicky, and now this Pokemon Olympic thing? Wayyyy too cheesy for my tastes.
  • Sanguinarius - March 12, 2010 4:21 a.m.

    The concept of having you prkemon follow you outside of the pokeball really is not that new. I still have my Pokemon Yellow that I won in a raffle and they had a Pikachu that you recieved as your starter follow you around, it even had indicators of its mood. Pokemon yellow came out when Red and Blue did, but it was like a special edtion version with extras such as the pikachu as a starter and a Jesse/James and Meowth (from the show) Team Rocket NPC's that you battle. Overall, I will probably buy this. Silver and Gold were the best that i have ever played of pokemon, mostly because I liked the day/night transition and the special pokemon you could get depending on the time of day. I can't remember but was Pokemon Crystal like Silver and Gold? I remember having it and it had like those dog legendariy pokemon that were like fire/ice/and somthing else. I also remember it having the Unknown (the pokemon shaped like letters that were encryptions) that you could capture. (at least I think they were called Unknown)
  • Rubberducky - March 12, 2010 3:10 a.m.

    I have absolutely no clue what Pokemon is about
  • johnthe5th - March 12, 2010 1:57 a.m.

    I can't wait for this one. The best part for me will be the recurring memories. My favorite Pokemon game was Crystal but I lost it along with Gold and Silver. Just thinking about this brings back a myriad of memories. The bug contest, Ho-oh's tower, Lugia's sea cave, I seem to remember something about an Espeon and Umbreon. I also remember a snow cave with some swinub and delibird. And other things like the Sudowoodo... oh I cant wait! All these subconscious memories will finally come to life!
  • Kytl - March 12, 2010 1:30 a.m.

    don't care much about the faults, this game is just filled with nostalgia. Silver was my first pokemon game and you can guess which one i'll get. besides, G2 was my favorite, G4 makes me cringe whenever i look at it
  • mubobi7593 - March 11, 2010 11:39 p.m.

    Wow, that's genuinely surprising to find out that the Pokewalker isn't just a quick cash-grabbing gimmick... Not that I wouldn't have gotten HG&SS anyway... But does it give EVs while leveling???
  • marioman50 - March 11, 2010 11:22 p.m.

    I have fond memories of the original Silver, and it's been a while since I've tried catching 'em all. I owe it to myself to re-experience the biggest of all Pokemon games in a new generation.
  • keroro47 - March 11, 2010 11:22 p.m.

    wow.. i remember when i got yellow... then gold and silver..... this brings back memories
  • Conman93 - March 11, 2010 11:07 p.m.

    Looking forward to getting it and battling my rival/friend ( by coincedence, his name is gary !)
  • Romination - March 11, 2010 10:02 p.m.

    Gold and Silver are my favourite of these games though. That's why I need to get this. But I have 2 Final Fantasy games and Disgaea for my DS already... that need to be beaten...

Showing 1-20 of 48 comments

Join the Discussion
Add a comment (HTML tags are not allowed.)
Characters remaining: 5000