The Soul of Discretion, Part 2
When Mike and Matt run into each other in the lodge, you'll have a choice to confront him about what you saw him doing with Emily. Don't get too aggressive.
Whose Side Are You On
Shortly after, an argument will break out between Emily and Jessica. Side with your girlfriend Emily, of course.
Be Her Hero, Part 1
On the way to the guest cabin, Jessica will fall into a mine. Hop down to give her a hand - it's just decent of you.
Something for Later, Part 1
When Sam and Josh go into the basement to start the boiler, you can find a baseball bat near the boiler itself. Make sure you examine this before giving Josh a hand.