Skip to main content
Join The Community
- Join our community
Commenting
Join the discussion
Exclusive Articles Coming Soon
Member-only articles
Weekly Newsletters
Weekly gaming & entertainment news
Member Badges
Earn badges as you go
Exclusive Competitions
Members-only prize draws
Curated Deals Coming Soon
Tech and gaming deals worth grabbing
GET COMMUNITY ACCESS QUICK
For the quickest way to join, simply enter your email below and get access. We will send a confirmation and sign you up to our newsletter to keep you updated on all your gaming news.
By submitting your information you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy and are aged 16 or over.
FIND OUT ABOUT OUR MAGAZINE
Want to subscribe to the magazine? Click the button below to find out more information.
Find out more
GET Community ACCESS QUICK

Join the GamesRadar community for quick access. Enter your email below and we'll send confirmation, and sign you up to our newsletter.

By submitting your information, you confirm you are aged 16 or over, have read our Privacy Policy and agree to the Terms & Conditions. Geographical rules apply.

Welcome to GamesRADAR+ Community !
Hi ,

Your membership journey starts here.

Keep exploring and earning more as a member.

MY ACCOUNT

Earn your first badge
Read 1 article to unlock your first badge.
Keep earning badges
Explore ways to get more involved as a member.
Latest Games News

Latest Games News

Breaking gaming news and updates

Read Now
Latest Games Reviews

Latest Games Reviews

Expert verdicts on the newest releases

Read Now

See what you’ve unlocked.

Explore your membership benefits.

Explore
Member Exclusives

Stay Ahead with GamesRadar+

Get the biggest gaming news, reviews, and releases straight to your inbox.

Explore

Sign Out
GamesRadar+
US EditionUS CA EditionCanada UK EditionUK AU EditionAustralia
Sign in
  • View Profile
  • Sign out
  • Games
    • Game Insights
      • Games News
      • Games Features
      • Games Reviews
      • Games Guides
      • Big in 2026
      • Big Preview
      • Future Games Show
      • Golden Joystick Awards
    • Genres
      • Action Games
      • RPGs
      • Action RPGs
      • Adventure Games
      • Third Person Shooters
      • FPS Games
    • Platforms
      • PS5
      • Xbox Series X
      • PC
      • Nintendo Switch
      • Nintendo Switch 2
      • Tabletop Gaming
    • Franchises
      • Grand Theft Auto
      • Pokemon
      • Assassin's Creed
      • Monster Hunter
      • Fortnite
      • Cyberpunk
      • Red Dead
      • The Elder Scrolls
      • The Sims
  • Entertainment
    • TV Shows
      • TV News
      • TV Reviews
      • Anime Shows
      • Sci-Fi Shows
      • Superhero Shows
      • Animated Shows
      • Marvel TV Shows
      • Star Wars TV Shows
      • DC TV Shows
    • Movies
      • Movie News
      • Movie Reviews
      • Big Screen Spotlight
      • Superhero Movies
      • Action Movies
      • Anime Movies
      • Sci-Fi Movies
      • Horror Movies
      • Marvel Movies
      • DC Movies
    • Streaming
      • Apple TV Plus
      • Disney Plus
      • Netflix
      • HBO
      • Amazon Prime Video
      • Hulu
    • Comics
      • Marvel Comics
      • DC Comics
  • Hardware
    • Insights
      • Hardware News
      • Hardware Reviews
      • Hardware Features
      • Buying Guides
    • Computing
      • Desktop PCs
      • Laptops
      • Handhelds
    • Peripherals
      • Headsets & Headphones
      • TVs & Monitors
      • Gaming Mice
      • Gaming Keyboards
      • Gaming Chairs
      • Speakers & Audio
    • Accessories & Tech
      • Gaming Controllers
      • Tech
      • SSDs & Hard Drives
      • VR
      • Accessories
      • Retro
  • Deals
    • Toys & Collectibles
    • Lego
    • Dungeons and Dragons
    • Merch
  • Video
    • Videos
    • GR+ Replay - Submit Your Clips
    • G+RLS Podcast
  • Edge
  • Newsletters
    • Quizzes
    • About Us
    • How to pitch to us
    • How we score
    • Newsarama
    • Retro Gamer
  • Home
  • Games
    • View Games
      • Games News
      • Games Features
      • Games Reviews
      • Games Guides
      • Big in 2026
      • Big Preview
      • Future Games Show
      • Golden Joystick Awards
      • Action Games
      • RPGs
      • Action RPGs
      • Adventure Games
      • Third Person Shooters
      • FPS Games
    • Platforms
      • View Platforms
      • PS5
      • Xbox Series X
      • PC
      • Nintendo Switch
      • Nintendo Switch 2
      • Tabletop Gaming
      • Grand Theft Auto
      • Pokemon
      • Assassin's Creed
      • Monster Hunter
      • Fortnite
      • Cyberpunk
      • Red Dead
      • The Elder Scrolls
      • The Sims
  • Entertainment
    • View Entertainment
    • TV Shows
      • View TV Shows
      • TV News
      • TV Reviews
      • Anime Shows
      • Sci-Fi Shows
      • Superhero Shows
      • Animated Shows
      • Marvel TV Shows
      • Star Wars TV Shows
      • DC TV Shows
    • Movies
      • View Movies
      • Movie News
      • Movie Reviews
      • Big Screen Spotlight
      • Superhero Movies
      • Action Movies
      • Anime Movies
      • Sci-Fi Movies
      • Horror Movies
      • Marvel Movies
      • DC Movies
    • Streaming
      • View Streaming
      • Apple TV Plus
      • Disney Plus
      • Netflix
      • HBO
      • Amazon Prime Video
      • Hulu
    • Comics
      • View Comics
      • Marvel Comics
      • DC Comics
  • Hardware
    • View Hardware
      • Hardware News
      • Hardware Reviews
      • Hardware Features
      • Buying Guides
      • Desktop PCs
      • Laptops
      • Handhelds
    • Peripherals
      • View Peripherals
      • Headsets & Headphones
      • TVs & Monitors
      • Gaming Mice
      • Gaming Keyboards
      • Gaming Chairs
      • Speakers & Audio
      • Gaming Controllers
      • Tech
      • SSDs & Hard Drives
      • VR
      • Accessories
      • Retro
  • Deals
    • Toys & Collectibles
    • Lego
    • Dungeons and Dragons
    • Merch
  • Video
    • View Video
    • Videos
    • GR+ Replay - Submit Your Clips
    • G+RLS Podcast
  • Edge
  • Newsletters
    • Quizzes
    • About Us
    • How to pitch to us
    • How we score
    • Newsarama
    • Retro Gamer
Trending
  • EDGE GTAVI exclusive
  • Join our monthly RPG Club
  • Golden Joystick Awards 2026
  • Deal of the Day
  • Countdown to GTA 6
  • RPG Hub
  • G+RLS Podcast
  • Submit your clips. Win prizes
Sign up to the GamesRadar+ Newsletter

Weekly digests, tales from the communities you love, and more


By submitting your information you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy and are aged 16 or over.

You are now subscribed

Your newsletter sign-up was successful


Want to add more newsletters?

GamesRadar+

Every Friday

GamesRadar+

Your weekly update on everything you could ever want to know about the games you already love, games we know you're going to love in the near future, and tales from the communities that surround them.

GTA 6 O'clock

Every Thursday

GTA 6 O'clock

Our special GTA 6 newsletter, with breaking news, insider info, and rumor analysis from the award-winning GTA 6 O'clock experts.

Knowledge

Every Friday

Knowledge

From the creators of Edge: A weekly videogame industry newsletter with analysis from expert writers, guidance from professionals, and insight into what's on the horizon.

The Setup

Every Thursday

The Setup

Hardware nerds unite, sign up to our free tech newsletter for a weekly digest of the hottest new tech, the latest gadgets on the test bench, and much more.

Switch 2 Spotlight

Every Wednesday

Switch 2 Spotlight

Sign up to our new Switch 2 newsletter, where we bring you the latest talking points on Nintendo's new console each week, bring you up to date on the news, and recommend what games to play.

The Watchlist

Every Saturday

The Watchlist

Subscribe for a weekly digest of the movie and TV news that matters, direct to your inbox. From first-look trailers, interviews, reviews and explainers, we've got you covered.

SFX

Once a month

SFX

Get sneak previews, exclusive competitions and details of special events each month!


Join the club

Get full access to premium articles, exclusive features and a growing list of member rewards.


An account already exists for this email address, please log in.
  1. Games
  2. RPGs

The One Ring and Lord of the Rings Roleplaying are the RPGs Tolkien fans have always wanted

Features
By Matt Thrower
Published 20 July 2023

Opinion | These games capture Middle-earth better than any other

When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here’s how it works.

The One Ring Starter Set rulebooks, dice, cards, and map laid out on a wooden table
(Image credit: Benjamin Abbott)
  • Facebook
  • X
  • Pinterest
  • Flipboard
  • Email
Share this article
Join the conversation
Follow us
Add us as a preferred source on Google
Subscribe to our newsletter

Toward the back of the original Dungeon Master’s Guide for Advanced Dungeons & Dragons, there was a list of inspirational reading. Some of the suggested authors, like Robert E. Howard, Jack Vance and Edgar Rice Burroughs, were very obvious influences on the game. Others, such as H. P. Lovecraft and Roger Zelazny, were less clear but could be seen in some niche concepts. In between, there was a name that was both: wholly, inescapably iconic if you enjoyed modern fantasy, yet whose work seemed curiously distant from one of the best tabletop RPGs. That author was J.R.R. Tolkien.

At first, this might seem like a peculiar claim: how can a game full of magic rings not have a strong relationship with the book that popularised the idea of magic rings? How can a system that features a copyright-skirting people known as “halflings” and rewards them for being “thieves” not have pilfered the concept outright from Bilbo Baggins, the hobbit burglar? Yet when you delve into the relationships, the problems become clear. Rings in Tolkien’s work were artefacts of unimaginable power, limited in number or closely held, not minor trinkets left forgotten in treasure chests for adventurers to find. Bilbo was brave and stealthy, but his heroics were a far cry from backstabbing monster hordes for experience points.

Missing the point

An open Dungeon Master's Guide

Despite owing a lot to Tolkien's work, D&D never quite seemed to understand it (Image credit: Wizards of the Coast)

This, then, was the problem. In trying to make the game as exciting to play and as open-ended to imagine as possible, Dungeons and Dragons books forgot all the things that make Tolkien’s work special. In the books, combat was rare and a choice of last resort, whereas role-playing games developed from wargames. Character development was based on genuine growth and learning, not the empty accumulation of power. Most problematic of all was magic, a concept that Tolkien left intentionally rare and enigmatic in a setting he otherwise filled out in fastidious, obsessive detail was, in the game, given out freely to any character that wanted to be an apprentice wizard.

Latest Videos FromGamesRadar+
Watch full video here:

Magic in Tolkien relates in some strange way to the amorphous concepts of “power” and “wisdom”. Gandalf is both of these things, we are told, yet often he seems like a feeble and, occasionally, foolish old man. His magic, such as it is, rarely appears via any overt display but rather can be seen in his extraordinary fireworks, the coloured smoke rings he blows, and his apparent telepathic abilities. Yet this seemingly harmless eccentric single-handedly fights and beats the Balrog, a fire demon from the ancient days before Middle-earth was populated, which is hinted as a being of hideous power. Yet the Balrog itself shows no clear signs of that strength, only that “a power and terror seemed to be in it and go before it”. That is magic in Tolkien’s world, not firing magic missiles or summoning mirror images, and it’s all the more fascinating for staying mysterious.

At a stroke, Tolkien fans suddenly had the game they always wanted

Dungeons & Dragons had good reasons for eschewing the literary magic that Tolkien created in its own trailblazing quest to popularise the role-playing game. What’s perhaps more of a surprise is that the first game to gain an official licence from Tolkien’s estate, Middle-earth Role-Playing, or MERP for short, repeated many of the same mistakes. Although combat was much more dangerous, it was still the default solution to many encounters. Players could take the role of high elves, with associated stat bonuses that were ripe for abuse by power gamers. Magical treasure remained to be found under rocks, and wizards were still ten a penny and functioned under strictly delineated rules and descriptions for magic and spells.

You may like
  • A Nazgul leads an army of orcs across a stone bridge against cloudy, green-yellow skies One Ring RPG designers promise "many adventures ahead" after Lord of the Rings campaign approaches $3 million in pledges
  • A pair of cloaked adventurers in a rowboat look upon the giant Argonath statues on the River Anduin Meet the Lord of the Rings RPG that smashed its crowdfunding goal by 32 times in less than a day
  • A young man in a cape with a shield looks back at a humanoid penguin and cat, alongside a young woman, as they stand on a lush green field with a castle in the background This RPG may be the closest we’ll get to a D&D-style Legend of Zelda game, and it’s magnificent

So fundamental had the template set by Dungeons & Dragons become that the same publisher did the same thing a decade later with The Lord of the Rings Adventure Game. This was supposed to be a stripped-down system for beginners that could be used as a stepping-stone for MERP, and thus would seem like a fantastic opportunity to get back to Tolkien’s basics. But magic was problematic yet again, with characters of every type permitted access to simple “spells” if they didn’t spend all their skill points during character creation. And it was still very much an adventure game in the classic mould of exploration and combat.

The cover artwork from Middle-earth Role Playing

The original Middle-earth Role Playing game repeated many of the same mistakes made by D&D (Image credit: ICE)

What came next was even worse. The Lord of the Rings Roleplaying game came from a newer, smaller publisher with a background in collectible card games rather than role-playing. With a licence to produce such a game based on Peter Jackson’s film adaptations of Tolkien’s books, they decided to expand it into producing a role-playing game. The result was a disaster, not only having all the same mechanical weaknesses in terms of the setting as its forebears, but being poorly written, confusing, and unbalanced to boot. The less said about it, the better.

Sign up to the GamesRadar+ Newsletter

Weekly digests, tales from the communities you love, and more

By submitting your information you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy and are aged 16 or over.

And that’s how things stayed until 2011, when Cubicle 7 got hold of the licence and produced The One Ring. The core mechanics of that game were kept when Free League took over the licence and published a second edition in 2022. And at a stroke, Tolkien fans suddenly had the game they always wanted.

Return of the king

The One Ring Core Rulebook and dice on a wooden table, against a dark background

The One Ring captures the essence of Tolkien's world perfectly (Image credit: Future)

Right from the opening pages, it was clear that this game was packed with fan service, but in that particularly delightful and welcoming way that doesn’t make it obvious that it is fan service. Readers were greeted with the class and culture options that we all take for granted in a role-playing game, but veterans would have noticed right away that balance-affecting options like high elves were absent, as was any class that smacked of magic. Instead, there were various flavours of warriors and rogues, explorers and scholars, and some choices that combined multiple flavours into one package. 

On top of that, the system was packed with thoughtful additions that showed the designers had really thought about what made venturing into Tolkien’s world so appealing. Parties now had a patron figure, one of the wise folk of Middle-Earth, to bring them together and guide them, just as Gandalf does with Bilbo and the Dwarves in The Hobbit. Fellowship within that company was also represented both as a role-playing aid and a source of potential mechanical advantages. Succumbing to temptation or wickedness, or even just witnessing terrifying creatures, led to adventurers acquiring problematic shadow points, just as the shadow remains on Frodo many long years after his adventures. As mentioned in our The One Ring Starter Set review, it can "give the sense that you're part of a lost story from Middle-earth creator J.R.R. Tolkien himself."

You may like
  • A Nazgul leads an army of orcs across a stone bridge against cloudy, green-yellow skies One Ring RPG designers promise "many adventures ahead" after Lord of the Rings campaign approaches $3 million in pledges
  • A pair of cloaked adventurers in a rowboat look upon the giant Argonath statues on the River Anduin Meet the Lord of the Rings RPG that smashed its crowdfunding goal by 32 times in less than a day
  • A young man in a cape with a shield looks back at a humanoid penguin and cat, alongside a young woman, as they stand on a lush green field with a castle in the background This RPG may be the closest we’ll get to a D&D-style Legend of Zelda game, and it’s magnificent

Showcases how easy it would have been for D&D to have stayed truer to one of its listed inspirations all along

Even when you zoom out, that attention to detail is still there. Fighting in the game is dangerous, but not impossibly so, and there’s a wide palette of skills for players to draw on in seeking non-violent solutions. Journeying is given a section all to itself, with an event-based system that keeps things vivid and exciting without resorting to the tiresome hex-crawls and repetitive random encounters that plage the game’s peers. Between them, these systems help groups to recreate the narrative pleasures of Tolkien’s work as the players undertake arduous travels into the unknown, facing multiple dangers only some of which can be seen off with sword and flame.

One thing that MERP did get right was the tone and content of its various supplements that delved into different regions of Middle-earth, laying them out in mechanical and narrative detail into places where players could explore and adventure. So far, the various iterations of The One Ring have focused on the northern lands, where The Hobbit is set. While that gives players less to work with, those places are detailed with the same love and care shown to Tolkien’s wider world in the rest of the system.

Character sheets, dice, and the Adventure Book from The One Ring Starter Set

There's a wealth of richly detailed locations to explore in The One Ring (Image credit: Future)

What’s particularly striking is that both publishers also created versions of this system which utilised the same core mechanics as Dungeons & Dragons. That game is as far, or maybe even further, from Middle-earth as it ever was, choosing instead to throw as many fantasy subgenres as it can into the same delicious yet surprising stew. Yet by bringing the concepts described above into the fold, Lord of the Rings Roleplaying, as the result is known, showcases how easy it would have been for D&D to have stayed truer to one of its listed inspirations all along. 

So whether you’re a Tolkien fan who wants to dip their toe into role-playing, or a veteran gamer seeking something new, either version of this latest foray into Middle-earth are worth your while. There is no telling where you might be swept off to.


For more tabletop recommendations, be sure to check out the best board games and these board games for adults.

Today's best The_One_Ring_Starter_Set deals
View Similar Amazon US
Amazon
No price information
Check Amazon
We check over 250 million products every day for the best prices
Matt Thrower
Matt Thrower
Social Links Navigation
Freelance Writer

Matt is a freelance writer specialising in board games and tabletop. With over a decade of reviews under his belt, he has racked up credits including IGN, Dicebreaker, T3, and The Guardian.

Read more
A Nazgul leads an army of orcs across a stone bridge against cloudy, green-yellow skies
Tabletop Gaming One Ring RPG designers promise "many adventures ahead" after Lord of the Rings campaign approaches $3 million in pledges
 
 
A pair of cloaked adventurers in a rowboat look upon the giant Argonath statues on the River Anduin
Tabletop Gaming Meet the Lord of the Rings RPG that smashed its crowdfunding goal by 32 times in less than a day
 
 
A young man in a cape with a shield looks back at a humanoid penguin and cat, alongside a young woman, as they stand on a lush green field with a castle in the background
Tabletop Gaming This RPG may be the closest we’ll get to a D&D-style Legend of Zelda game, and it’s magnificent
 
 
The One Ring Starter Set rulebooks, dice, cards, and map laid out on a wooden table
Tabletop Gaming $2 million Lord of the Rings RPG crowdfunding campaign is so popular it's had to make new stretch goals
 
 
Lord of the Rings: War in the North
Action RPGs "I argued vociferously not to release this up against Skyrim," says dev on LotR RPG's re-release
 
 
D&D World of Warcraft book on a wooden surface
Tabletop Gaming D&D World of Warcraft is like MMO loot with some hits and misses, but overall it lives up to the promise
 
 
Latest in RPGs
Geralt with a bloody lip lies on the ground
The Witcher CD Projekt Red worked with an AI company on Geralt's Polish voice in The Witcher 3 Songs of the Past
 
 
Ralof sitting in a prisoner wagon chatting to the Dragonborn during the opening of Skyrim.
The Elder Scrolls Bethesda celebrates Skyrim’s 15th anniversary with new artwork from a "legendary artist"
 
 
A close up of Geralt in The Witcher 3 Remastered.
The Witcher The Witcher 3 already had the most Golden Joysticks and it just won another
 
 
A black dragon roaring with a manor house behind it and lighting in the sky during Skyrim.
The Elder Scrolls Bethesda says sorry, no Sentinel news for Skyrim's anniversary – and none "for some time"
 
 
A man in a suit in The Outer Worlds 2's Side Effects Guaranteed DLC
RPGs Amid Bethesda takeover and Fallout pivot, Obsidian's finally making good on The Outer Worlds 2 DLC
 
 
Todd Howard
The Elder Scrolls Skyrim lead doubted Todd Howard’s constellation-based skill system, and then the RPG came out
 
 
Latest in Features
Sephiroth stands against a purple background in Final Fantasy 7 Revelation, with orange GamesRadar+
Final Fantasy My Final Fantasy 7 Remake trilogy's entire story so far will get you FF7 Revelation-ready
 
 
Tyroe Muhafidin at The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power season 3 premiere
Lord of the Rings TV Shows The Rings of Power's Theo star teases there may be more to his father reveal, and reacts to episode 4's big death
 
 
Marnûkh in The Rings of Power season 3
Lord of the Rings TV Shows The Rings of Power season 3's new heroic Orc character offers a fresh perspective on Middle-earth
 
 
A young man in a cape with a shield looks back at a humanoid penguin and cat, alongside a young woman, as they stand on a lush green field with a castle in the background
Tabletop Gaming This RPG may be the closest we’ll get to a D&D-style Legend of Zelda game, and it’s magnificent
 
 
Red XIII looks determined in Final Fantasy 7 Revelation, with the GR+ orange Big Preview frame
Final Fantasy "The snowboarding minigame is just essential," says FF7 Revelation director "There really was no other option for us!"
 
 
A screenshot of the GTA 6 Extended Look. Jason looks out a car window while sitting next to Lucia.
Grand Theft Auto I want an uglier GTA 6 that runs at 60 FPS – 30 FPS on console is more reason to wait for PC
 
 
LATEST ARTICLES
  1. Avengers: Doomsday hits theaters on December 18
    1
    Anthony Mackie jokes that he didn't get to fight Robert Downey Jr. in Avengers: Doomsday because "it wasn't him" in the Doctor Doom costume: "Robert don't fight!"
  2. 2
    CD Projekt Red worked with an AI company on Geralt's Polish voice in The Witcher 3: Songs of the Past – with the original actor's approval after health concerns
  3. 3
    The Witcher 3 already had the most Golden Joysticks and it just won another, extending its lead over RPG rivals Baldur's Gate 3 and Clair Obscur: Expedition 33
  4. 4
    Why wasn't GTA 6 at the Golden Joystick Awards?
  5. 5
    Resident Evil Requiem ties with Meccha Chameleon as the biggest winner at the Golden Joystick Awards

GamesRadar+ is part of Future US Inc, an international media group and leading digital publisher. Visit our corporate site.

Add as a preferred source on Google Add as a preferred source on Google
  • About us
  • Contact Future's experts
  • Terms and conditions
  • Privacy policy
  • Cookies policy
  • Advertise with us
  • Review guidelines
  • Write for us
  • Accessibility statement
  • Careers

© Future US, Inc. Full 7th Floor, 130 West 42nd Street, New York, NY 10036.

Please login or signup to comment

Please wait...