Best of Cannes 2009: Up first reaction!

A 3D animation movie opening the world’s premiere film festival? A thousand chin-stroking journalists donning oversized spectacles before they get down to the serious business of the new Haneke? Now that’s a tough audience…

Pixar, as ever, rose to the challenge, winning tears, laughs and a sizeable round of applause with their tale of a grouchy OAP who attaches thousands of balloons to his house and floats off to South America for the adventure of a lifetime.

Carl and his wife Ellie had always dreamt of adventuring in Venezuela, and so it is that Carl now hits upon his gorgeously surreal scheme to float up, up and away. What he didn’t bargain for was the over-eager cub scout standing on his porch, up there in the clouds.

Which of course means the second half of Up speeds everything up, unleashing a flurry of verbal gags and a host of chases involving a giant bird, a pack of talking dogs (thanks to special collars that translate their growls and snarls – is John Lasseter and co. taking the Mickey out Disney’s heritage of talking animals?) and a nasty hunter.

As with WALL.E, there’s a feeling here that Pixar haven’t yet got the courage of their convictions; that the animators want to reinvent mainstream animation, to make it emotional and thematically adult, but are wary of jettisoning the frenetic set-pieces in case the kids get bored.

Which isn’t to say the second half of Up isn’t good – it’s consistently funny and continues to pulse with emotion whenever it pauses to take a breath – but it’s not AS good, the life-or-death action containing no real sense of peril.

Gorgeously crafted, the set-pieces nonetheless feel a little… cartoon-y. Which would be a stupid thing to say if it were not for the fact that the first half of Up feels anything but.

But as ever when criticising Pixar, all grouches seem a little churlish – these guys remain so far in front of the competition it’s embarrassing. One thing’s for sure: Cannes 2009 is up and flying.

The Total Film team are made up of the finest minds in all of film journalism. They are: Editor Jane Crowther, Deputy Editor Matt Maytum, Reviews Ed Matthew Leyland, News Editor Jordan Farley, and Online Editor Emily Murray. Expect exclusive news, reviews, features, and more from the team behind the smarter movie magazine.