Quantcast

The Beatles: Rock Band


Is it the greatest music game ever made? Well… that depends on who you ask

Words: Joe Newman, GamesRadar US

Let’s face it: one’s enjoyment of a game in a popular franchise is always partly dependent on one’s familiarity with said franchise. So as much as we’d like to make a universal statement regarding the enjoyment you’ll get out of The Beatles: Rock Band, doing so does the game a disservice. Perhaps more so than in any other game, The Beatles: Rock Band is going to mean radically different things to different people. The way we see it, there are four different types of people who will play this; which are you?

The category you fall into will dictate what you love and what you hate about The Beatles: Rock Band. We’ve given each one of these types its own section, so you can pick which review is the most relevant to you. Sound good? First up is…


The Beatlemaniac


Who you are: You grew up in the Octopus’ Garden. You Let it Be. You dreamed of Lucy in the Sky With Diamonds. For whatever reason, you never got into videogames, but when you saw all those posters for The Beatles: Rock Band, you were intrigued. Maybe you thought they were coming out with a new album or something?

What you should know about The Beatles: Rock Band: We’re going to assume for the sake of this review that you don’t hate videogames – otherwise you wouldn’t be at our fine site. But we will assume you don’t know a whole lot about the Rock Band franchise, which is totally OK. The Beatles: Rock Band is about as user-friendly as one could hope for – you grab an instrument, turn the game on, choose Quickplay (the first option on the menu), and you’re ready to pick any of the game’s 45 songs to play.

If you choose to go through the story, you’ll work your way through the band’s history, starting in Liverpool and ending on the roof of the Apple studios. Beautiful, stylized videos bookmark each chapter, and there’s a huge incentive to keep pushing through, not only because the videos are so cool, but also because, let’s face it, The Beatles’ best stuff came later in their career. The animations of the Beatles playing on the Ed Sullivan show are great and all, but when you hit the studio years and the trippy dreamscapes start opening up, it’s a whole new experience. Aside from the fact that the Beatles’ music is arguably better at this point (compare “Revolution” to “Boys”), the game’s visuals become absolutely astounding as you progress. Prepare to fly on a giant balloon with Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band, take a trip on the Yellow Submarine or become the Walrus. Each song has its own visually distinct music video, and each one is an absolute treat.


Above: Within You Without You/Tomorrow Never Knows is so visually arresting that you may play it over… and over…

When it comes to gameplay, the Beatlemaniac will typically gravitate towards vocals – if you choose to take up the mic, you’ll have the option to either sing the solo part or the harmonies. We recommend picking harmonies – there’s no penalty for jumping off your part to the main line, and from a strategic standpoint, you triple your chances of nailing a line if there are three harmonies to choose from. If you’re a Beatlemaniac, you’re likely not in it to win it – you just want have fun warbling about, singing everyone’s part and doing your best John Lennon impression. We know. Have a good time.


Above: How a Beatlemaniac will treat TB:RB

The unlockable photos and movies are so filled with Beatles love and obscure trivia that the desire to collect them all may become obsessive, yet the only way to unlock all these treasures is to earn five-star ratings on each song. If you’re a Beatlemaniac, you may just find yourself a Rock Band Guru as well by the time you’ve unlocked them all.


“They even got Ringo’s mole right! EEEEEEEEEEEEEE!!!!”

Next page: the Rock Band Guru and the Giddy Fanboy


 
58 Comments
Order Comments: Newest First | Oldest First
StarKiller27  - 2 months 16 days ago 
First!!! And it looks like a sweet game Beatles Fanboy 4 Life!!!
Kenjum  - 2 months 16 days ago 
I like the work of the Beatles. First first.
CanadianHockeyGrinder  - 2 months 16 days ago 
never much of a beatles fan but might give it a try despite its price
Kenjum  - 2 months 16 days ago 
Damn, litterally 1 second off. I wish I didn't have to recover my password.
MrGreen  - 2 months 16 days ago 
this pretty fun
moonwalk_mafia  - 2 months 16 days ago 
Good review, about what I expected to see scorewise. As a fan of The Fab Four, ill be leaving my house in a few hours for the midnight release!
kerfuffled_brizzle792  - 2 months 16 days ago 
Holy crap I didn't think I could get anymore excited about this game. I can't wait till tomorrow!
bocaj  - 2 months 16 days ago 
Great review, and the game looks nice!
Elbo444  - 2 months 16 days ago 
im gettin GH5 instead :P
samownzsnake  - 2 months 16 days ago 
rhythm games for the lose

reCaptcha: blankest Pakistani

no joke
samownzsnake  - 2 months 16 days ago 
@ moonwalk_mafia

the game is already released so you cant just be going to the midnight release idiot lol

reCaptcha: English teabags
jar-head  - 2 months 16 days ago 
Strawberry Fields...
CommanderCrunch  - 2 months 16 days ago 
I actually do have an equal affinity for both The Beatles and Metallica. I'm 17 years old so I don't have any nostalgic feelings for either era. I discovered both bands catalogs on my own and fell in love with both.
Hexar  - 2 months 16 days ago 
I approve of this review.

For the record I'm a mild cave dweller. I've yet to play a rock band game (always been a guitar hero fan myself) and I have never EVER liked the Beatles music.

That being said I have a sister who goes ape shit for their music and loves rock band, so on her dime, and my 360 I believe I'll enter this club fairly soon. Hopefully I won't want to tear my ears off in the end.
brikz111  - 2 months 16 days ago 
Score 1 for the cave dwellers! Score another 1 for the other cave dweller, A s i a!
435  - 2 months 16 days ago 
I wish I could afford the bundle.

I want Paul's bass. Q_Q
lucashintz  - 2 months 15 days ago 
This review was splendid good sir! Hopefully I'll find the money to pay for TB:RB in the coming days.
CountFenring  - 2 months 15 days ago 
I'm thinking of getting this for my dad for Christmas or something. I really hope the price goes down. Good review.

My sister is in a Beatles cover band (she's eight, so they're not that good), but her band's closing song is the "Hello Muddah, Hello Faddah" song by Allan Sherman. Kinda funny.
c03n3nj0  - 2 months 15 days ago 
Yeah, the price tag for this game is making me wait....
LokiRising  - 2 months 15 days ago 
Excellently reviewed, most other sites wouldn't take this perspective. Kudos.
This video player requires Flash 9 Player or later. Please download the latest Flash Player.
The Knowledge
The Beatles: Rock Band
The Beatles: Rock Band

Genre: Other Games/Compilations
Release date: Sep 9, 2009
Published by: MTV Games,EA GAMES
Developed by: Harmonix
Franchise: Rock Band
Multiplayer Modes:
Online
4 player CO-OP
9 AWESOME
Read the review
Latest Articles About This Game
Is it the greatest music game ever made? Well… that depends on who you ask
Xbox 360 Review  -  Sep 8, 2009