Google+

UFC Undisputed 3 review

AT A GLANCE
  • Pride mode is spectacular
  • The new submission system
  • General fixes make it the best UFC game yet
  • Pride should be better integrated
  • Load times are rough
  • Career mode's new presentation

There's something about MMA games that makes them easier to wrap our heads around than games like Street Fighter. Don't get us wrong, we love shooting fireballs and doing triple-flips as much as the next journalists, but it's just more relatable to watch about two fighters punch and kick until one falls down and doesn't get back up. It's because of that – and because of our love for MMA – that we're drawn to UFC Undisputed, which has done a fantastic job over the years of converting the fast-paced UFC action into videogame form. After THQ tried to force the game into a yearly release with mediocre results in 2010 we were excited to get our hands on this new version, which was given a little more time to bake before release.

UFC Undisputed 2010 had a lot of small problems and one big problem. The small problems reared their head in every element of the game. Flash knockouts were too frequent, fights rarely made it out of the first round, the ground game was overly complicated, the career mode had a bunch of statistical problems, there wasn't any proper support for truly competitive play, there were... well, yeah, we'll just say there were lots of little issues. With the extra time between games, developer Yuke's was able to address almost every issue, making for a much smoother experience.

Above: Jon Bones Jones has terrifying elbows

Fights last longer than they did before, and when they do end, they're usually not with a fighter collapsing and the other fighter standing still. Fighters are allowed to continue attacking their incapacitated comrades after they fall, which better replicates the "finish the fight" mentality of the actual sport. There's also a simplified control setting for grappling and ground play that makes it much easier to jump in without learning about different stick rotations. There's still a benefit to learning the full controls, as they offer more freedom, but it's nice to be able to play without watching a complex tutorial. Competitive play is supported better thanks to the ability to turn on a mode that equalizes stats and removes some of the randomness from the game, and there's even a "realistic" setting for exhaustion, which makes the matches play more like real UFC fights.

It really feels like Yuke's went down the list and checked off every major concern from fans of the series. It's impressive, and really shows when you start to fight and begin noticing all of the little changes. It's just cleaner, more robust, and all-around better. 

Above: The models are nearly perfect recreations of the athletes

The career mode has also been overhauled, too, though we're sort of conflicted as to whether or not we're happy about the changes. Some are undoubtedly for the better – training is easier and more enjoyable, with new mini-games replacing the old training modes, and the actual system of improving stats, leveling up skills, and learning new abilities is much, much better. The most unpopular aspect of 2010's was likely the stat degradation system, which aimed for an authentic, realistic feel by having attributes fade over time unless they were constantly trained. It's gone now. Cut completely in favor of a more enjoyable, streamlined career where stats go up, without ever falling back down.

But there's a trade-off: the last game's cinematic moments, showing our created fighter's rise through the ranks with occasional cutscenes and post-fight interview dialog options, have been stripped out entirely. Instead, there are interviews with fighters during key moments of our career, with actual UFC athletes talking about their first wins, losses, title shots, and such as we reach those benchmarks. We like the videos, but it leads to a conflicted experience. Are we fighting in a UFC career where we're being immersed into the sport, or are we being inundated with the brand instead? We miss CGI Dana White inviting us to join the UFC, and we missed being able to create a personality with our fighter.

Above: Flipping tires gives stats, which doesn't make sense, but at least it's fun

These were elements we were desperately hoping would be expanded in the sequel, not removed entirely. Still, it's an improved experience, technically, and adds to the long list of general improvements made to the game.

The largest problem with Undisputed 2010, however, was the submission system. Submissions were completed and defended by spinning the right analog stick. The maneuver, called "the shine" by the developers, required no technical knowledge, and simply wasn't very fun. We'd be fighting a fun fight, using all we've learned about the game to do battle with our opponent, and then all of a sudden we were spinning the right stick like we'd stumbled into a game of Mario Party. It was an absolute blister-causing mess. The new system is still a bit unwieldy at first, but it's undoubtedly much better. Now, starting a submission throws an octagon on the screen, with the initiating player being given an icon that goes on the outside of the octagon, and the defending players being given a bar on the inside. In order to submit a fighter, the bar on the outside needs to cover the bar on the inside for long enough to fill a meter up, and the fighters can chase their opponent's bars around the shape flat octagon.

Above: See the submission system in action

The size of the bars is dependent on a number of factors, such as the fighter's stamina, their submission skills, and the amount of damage they've taken to the body part being submitted. It's less frustrating and random than spinning the analog stick, and the fact that the bar size is dependent on the fight makes it feel like a more integrated part of the game, even if the actual art and design itself is somewhat obtrusive, feeling removed from the rest of the game.

In terms of actual content, the largest, most notable addition is the inclusion of the Pride Fighting Championships. Pride was the largest MMA league in the world for several years, running out of Japan and featuring a different rule-set from the UFC. But while the rules were important, Pride was about the spectacle. It was the the spirit of the samurai, brought to life with bright lights, big stars, and a much, much different vibe from the serious tone of UFC. This year's UFC game doesn't just add the Pride mode's rules, it adds the spectacle, and lets every one of UFC Undisputed 3's 150 fighters do battle in the ring with the full Pride presentation. 

Above: Check out the Review Club livestream we did with OXM's Dave Rudden

This means everyone has introductions from the Pride announcers, entrances into the ring, and personalized commentary from Pride's announcers, Bas Rutten and Stephen Quadros. It's an absolute treat, especially for Pride fans, to see fighters tap gloves in the Pride ring that might otherwise never have been able to fight in the classic setting.

But even more interesting is what it actually adds in terms of gameplay. Pride was much more brutal than UFC. The rounds were longer (the first lasts ten minutes, and there are less regulations in terms of what is and isn't a legal strike. Kicks and knees to the head of a downed opponent are banned in UFC, but completely welcome in Pride, meaning that missing a take-down is much more detrimental when there's a chance your opponent might kick you in the head. These changes make the game riskier, and totally change the way we played the game. While we didn't prefer it to regular UFC rules, we found that we were constantly going back for more, just for a change of pace. It's an absolute blast, and kept us coming back time and time again.

Above: That's the definitive "he's going to feel that in the morning" kick

Pride also shows up occasionally in the career mode as a special invitational event, but, sadly, that's where it ends. We really would have liked the option to start our career in Pride to really make it feel like it's a part of the experience, but it's reserved for "special" occasions.There's the inclusion of Pride's Grand Prix events, which were long gauntlets where fighters would sometimes have to fight three or four fighters in a single night, but buried in the "Tournament" menu, which technically makes sense, but isn't very practical. We really would have preferred the Grand Prix show up as Pride's version of the "Title Defense" mode, where players need to fight increasing difficult fighters, as it's an absolute hassle to set up as a tournament, so we ended up barely ever doing it.

In fact, that's our problem with Pride in UFC Undisputed 3, on the whole – it's obvious how much heart went into it, and we wish that Yuke's treated it like something more than a rule set swap. It should have been an integrated part of the game instead of a mode in and of itself. Maybe they're saying it for a sequel, maybe they're saving it for DLC, but whatever the reason we're sad to see Pride kept away when it should have been folded into the overall experience.

Above: Watching Tito Ortiz get punched in the face is our favorite thing

Backing away from the yearly model was a good choice for THQ and Yuke's. With the extra time, the developers were able to truly polish the game, bring forth a game that, while flawed, doesn't have any glaring issues. It's more accessible without losing any of the complexity, it's deeper without being isolating, and it's bursting with content, even if we wish the content was implemented better. The neutered (though technically better) career mode is somewhat of a disappointment, but it's something that we're looking forward to seeing expanded in the sequel – as long as that sequel is more than a year away. Take your time, guys, we'll be playing this one for a while.

More Info

Available Platforms: Xbox 360, PS3
Genre: Fighting
Franchise: UFC
ESRB Rating:
Rating Pending
PEGI Rating:
Rating Pending

Topics

UFC

13 comments

  • MerylsHers12 - March 15, 2014 2:58 p.m.

    If someone is looking for UFC UNDISPUTED 3 for the PC, it is already available :) PlayGameHacker remade this game and gave the manager so that the retrieve for free :) Link to the Manager: http://playgamehacker.com/ufc-undisputed-3-pc-version/ Link to the video of the action Manager: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LsUyfJX88X0
  • wizardc - March 3, 2012 1:46 a.m.

    This game is the best for right now for 2012. The gameplay is a little tough but you will get use to it. The graphics are awesome. Better features than last year. You can do so much with your career fighter. This game is the best. I recommend everybody to get this game.
  • KingOfCarts24/7 - February 15, 2012 1:38 a.m.

    Time to be the uptight reader a-hole that: Knows exactly what I'm talking about 24/7... Will be a grammar POPO and point out minor flaws that really don't matter, but you guys being the writers should know better, so all I'm doing is helping, not just trying to feed my ego... Knows all of the stats of every fighter EVER, and if 1 pt is off I will point that out... Will be upset if 100% of sport content studies is not correct.... Ya, we're all lookin at you buddy(notice how looking is spelled wrong, gonna fix that? ^_^)
  • KingOfCarts24/7 - February 15, 2012 1:40 a.m.

    Darniiiiiiit, I was too busy being the a-hole that I didn't even talk about the game, AAAAHHHHHHHH, NOW IM AN A-HOLEEEEEE Looking forward to picking this up on payday, huge fan of 2010, lookin forward to this one also
  • ChaseByKO - February 11, 2012 7:44 p.m.

    Outside of TJ De Santis' impending review for Sherdog, your Undisputed 3 review is the only other one I intend to read. EA MMA implemented a prettier version of what Undisputed 3 tried to do. Unquestionably, the new sub system is better, but, man, does it look and feel clunky. I look forward to experiencing the training mini-games. On another note, flipping tires is actually pretty tough. A portion of one of my workouts involves tire flips. Fun stuff. For the next game, I hope they improve the ground game to be more fluid, and, ya know, a better representation of actual ground work. Yuke's nailed the standing striking part, tho, even if it is a bit too robotic.
  • glue28 - February 10, 2012 9:44 p.m.

    By the way, nobody likes grammar police
  • glue28 - February 10, 2012 9:41 p.m.

    Jones is a more well-rounded fighter than Anderson, that's why. You'll see an illustration of that if Anderson grows some balls and steps up to LHW to face the champ. Anderson has the striking advantage on paper, but outside of that, Jones is better in every aspect. Anderson's ground game is weak, while Jones has world class wrestling and devastating ground and pound to go along with his very good striking. Anderson has a nasty clinch game, but Jones has one as well. Have you ever actually seen either fighter in the octagon? If so, you shouldn't have to ask why Jones' stats are better overall.He's better in every aspect outside of striking and (arguably) the clinch game. Step your knowledge up...
  • Pwnz0r3d - February 11, 2012 8:25 a.m.

    While I agree with the fact that Bones overall is a more balanced fighter than Silva, I have to disagree with you on the Spider's ground game. I do agree that its sub-par, but remember that he is an expert at AVOIDING takedowns, with an 80% deflection rate. Jones' superior ground game will be moot if they ever go head to head, as will Silva's (Jones has never been taken to the ground after all). It will be a pure stand-up fight, and even the clinch game will be at a minimum because BOTH fighters are good at it. Bone's ridiculous reach could be negated by Silva's kicks or just his agility. But we'll never know until he goes LHW.
  • InFeRnOg - February 10, 2012 10:27 a.m.

    Errors: "Kicks and knees to the head are banned in UFC, but completely welcome in Pride" Kicks and knees to the head of a DOWNED opponent are illegal in UFC, but not in Pride. It is JON Jones. Not John. Other than that, I wish more was written about the AI from a UFC 2009 and 2010 veteran. I played both on the highest difficulty setting and had a blast with it, but the UFC 3 demo's AI seemed less fun to play against.
  • GR HollanderCooper - February 10, 2012 10:52 a.m.

    Fixed those, thanks! And the AI isn't much different, but the ability to play on competition mode with equalized stats definitely makes it more of a challenge.
  • InFeRnOg - February 10, 2012 10:56 a.m.

    Thanks for the swift fixes and for a bit of insight on the AI. One other minor thing related to the game: How is Jon Jones' overall stat higher than Anderson Silva's? Weird.
  • GR HollanderCooper - February 10, 2012 11:47 a.m.

    I have no idea, but he's SO GOOD. Also check back at 1PM PT - we're doing a "Review Club (livestream with reviewers)" and answering questions!
  • wampastompa - February 10, 2012 10 a.m.

    So excited for this. I played the hell out of the first one, but 2010 definitely didn't grab me the same way. Pride mode alone is going to suck a ton of hours out of my day.

Showing 1-13 of 13 comments

Join the Discussion
Add a comment (HTML tags are not allowed.)
Characters remaining: 5000

OR…

Connect with Facebook

Log in using Facebook to share comments, games, status update and other activity easily with your Facebook feed.