Quantcast

BioShock 2


Fan Art versus Official Art

A showdown between fan-made creations and their official counterparts

Words: Tyler Nagata, GamesRadar US

A lot of official game art comes through our inboxes every day. Produced by game developers and distributed by their public relations teams to the media, eye-catching official game art is the stuff that magazine covers are made of and are often posted on sites like this. They help build hype for highly anticipated titles that are in the early stages of development before the dissection of screenshots and additional details in previews that inevitably follow a game’s announcement begin rolling in. Because so much is riding on the public’s initial reaction to them, this sort of official art tends to look great.
 
But more often than not, it’s fan art that we like best. There’s something about excellent fan-made tributes that satisfies in ways that officially sanctioned game art can’t – and no, we’re not talking about hentai doujinshi. We’re talking about the best of the best, the high quality stuff we’ve collected here today.
 

 
Of course, not all fan art is impressive. In fact, a lot of it is downright awful. The internet is full of misshapen Marios holding hands with grotesque Peaches. But to say that all fan art is made by amateurs is full of all kinds of wrong. In fact, much of the best fan art is done by professionals whose love for gaming shines through in their independent projects.

Title: Megaman for SoaringKitty
Artist: Sailor_InuyashaMon


Above: Sailor_InuyashaMon made a valiant attempt at recreating Mega Man. But this isn’t the kind of fan art that we’re talking about


Above: Still, it’s not like this official box art was much better
 
 

Title: Conquering your Demons
Artist: Ben Mauro

Great fan art doesn’t just attract the attention of fellow fans. Sometimes, they’re so professional that they catch the eyes of pros in the industry. Case in point: Ben Mauro, a student at the Art Center College of Design in Pasadena, California. Long before BioShock 2 was officially announced, Mauro posted images from a student project that quickly made their rounds through the gaming blogosphere. His unofficial images for a proposed sequel to BioShock looked so good, that some confused it for genuine concept art. 2K Games, the creators of BioShock, even got in touch with Mauro to express how much they liked his work and to thank him. You can visit Mauro’s blog to see more of his BioShock 2 images and keep up on his latest work.
 

Above: Mauro’s unofficial concept art for BioShock 2 got the attention of 2K Games
 

Above: Official concept art for Rapture’s lobby from the original BioShock looks great, but is severely lacking in the “Giant Mecha-whale” department
 

Gordon Freeman is to PC gamers as Mario is to Nintendo fans. But as much as we love Valve’s official art of the Half-Life series’ protagonist, it’s Anry Nemo’s portrayal of the stoic scientist we like best.

Title: Gordon Freeman
Artist: Anry Nemo


Above: You don’t want to mess with Anry Nemo’s version of Gordon Freeman. He’s got a crowbar and isn’t afraid to use it for the good of science


Above: In this official image, Gordon seems to be more about brooding than bashing things to a bloody pulp


 
67 Comments
Order Comments: Newest First | Oldest First
EpicPale  - 5 months 29 days ago 
That Mario painting is beautiful, I would definitely play that :)
Cyberninja  - 5 months 29 days ago 
i love this art i think one of these will be my gamesrader wallpaper


first
thereaper52  - 5 months 29 days ago 
i like unofficial fan art better. ithink that thew bishock 2 fan art was very impressive and looked more official than the official art. although i would have added haloid in with the final fantasy short.
GamesRadarTylerNagata  - 5 months 29 days ago 
If you do, be sure to follow the links to the authors' sites. You'll often find higher res versions of the pics we've posted here.
Dualcarrot  - 5 months 29 days ago 
- Comment removed by Community
Reported
albinomonkey90  - 5 months 29 days ago 
Both of you guys know you're not first right?
Kehno  - 5 months 29 days ago 
That Monty Oum guy is amazing.
I mean, a battle on flying pieces of column inside a tornado?
Really?
Starplatinum  - 5 months 29 days ago 
YAY! Tyler Post! Prior to this article my knowledge of unoffical fanart was limited to hentai doujinshi. Thank you for the enlightenment!
JohnTheFisherman  - 5 months 29 days ago 
man,those death fantasy battles were killer
Hobojedi  - 5 months 29 days ago 
I don't know about everyone else, but I like the official and fan art versions of Gordon Freeman equally.

Oh, and
Recaptcha: Fontaine unborn
Romination  - 5 months 29 days ago 
I don't even really care about Final Fantasy and that first one Oum video is amazing. It's got so many things that too many movies take themselves too seriously to do...
Unoriginal  - 5 months 29 days ago 
Thoose Dead Fantasy vids, wow...just wow.
I'm still recovering from that.
Just...wow.

I hope Square hires that Monty Oum guy.
Corsair89  - 5 months 29 days ago 
Dead Fantasy has probably the greatest fight scenes I've ever seen. They blow everything else completely out of the water. Now imagine them with the production values of Final Fantasy VII Advent Children Complete!
GIJoe01  - 5 months 29 days ago 
Fan art Faith FACE + official art BODY = PERFECT
The_Zanger  - 5 months 29 days ago 
fanart is the best. I was trying to convince my art teacher that we should make some.
Xtapolapopotamus  - 5 months 29 days ago 
Good article, and that Mario image is just amazing. If Nintendo made a game like that... Or hell, any of the companies that he's made art for.. It would be beyond words.
Ravenbom  - 5 months 29 days ago 
Good article T-Nag.
I like your appearance on TalkRadar as well, don't be stranger to the podcast.
DeadGirls  - 5 months 29 days ago 
That Faith fan art is stupid. I consider it progression of the art from when game devs don't cater to horny, lonely, anime fans for a few extra sales.
Red  - 5 months 29 days ago 
I liked the fan's version of Faith's face better because the makeup looks stupid to me. Boobs are great and all, but I can't see myself playing another game with jiggling boob physics.

Could you imagine those things flopping up in her face in first person while she was running? On second thought...
jtslugmaster10  - 5 months 29 days ago 
i think im mixed about faith i think he could have left the bony checks and lost the nipple but thats just me...

secondly sex sells but how far do we have to go... i think it has gone far enough and the fan based art wasnt even that appealing for the reason i stated above so just adding some additional features doesnt always make the female char look better ... in fact she could have probably not even needed the increase in breast size or just less of an enhancment and she would have been even better looking
Related Games
BioShock 2
Xbox 360
Just Cause 2 - New Grapple Trailer N4G
360 News from N4G
Nov 11, 2009
Bayonetta: Climax Edition Goes For The Money Shot N4G
360 News from N4G
Nov 11, 2009
New GTA limited edition Xbox 360 bundle revealed N4G
360 News from N4G
Nov 11, 2009
Monopoly Now on Xbox 360 Games on Demand  N4G
360 News from N4G
Nov 11, 2009
Alan Wake, Mass Effect 2 and more this Thursday N4G
360 News from N4G
Nov 11, 2009