FriendlyFire and DozerKing's posts are spot on. There were so many ground-breaking and innovative games in 2008 that it makes Charlie's article seem embarassingly under-thought.
Which makes me wonder why he even wrote it...
My guess, he wanted to enrage the fanboys. Which, judging by the amount of Halo vs Gears and Dead Space vs Bioshock posts there are, he succeed.
Im not usualy one for trash talking but here it goes. THe only reason why idiots think cod4 is better then codwaw is because they suck at it. Simple as that. It takes a lot more precise shooting to kill somebody that has juggernaut on while using a ww2 weapon. The only thing they should fix about it is the horrible spwning in gametypes like headquarters and war. If any thinks different come and play me. GT=CHIAVARONE