The games we hate to love

Ah, PlanetSide, my favorite game of all time, and red-headed stepchild of MMOs and FPSes everywhere. Hmm, perhaps I love it due to my own ginger persuasion? You’d think so, considering the disdain or simple “Planet-what?” most FPS gamers lay on the baddest-ass online shooter in history.

Imagine you’d discovered the most amazing FPS ever, but you couldn’t convince any of your friends to embrace it? PlanetSide is an unwieldy beast: huge computer spec demands, dated graphics, a confusing and unforgiving learning curve and worlds so big it sometimes takes a while to get to the fight. Oh, and it costs 15 bucks a month.

Above: The scene from my room on any given night for the past

I’ve tried to get friends to play with me, but impatience for immediate action and severe reluctance to pay for a shooter ended almost every attempt I made (shout out to Darkemans, the one friend who saw the light). So why have I paid $15 a month for six years (holy God, do the math) to play an FPS? How about a persistent world so huge that a single continent dwarfs just about any FPS map you’ve ever played? How about the ability to have 400 players all fighting on one map? Let that sink in. Four. Hundred. Makes your 32 man Deathmatch reassess the size of its balls.

On cold, lonely nights, I sometimes weep tears of splash damage at the thought of all those FPS gamers out there that never gave my beloved PSide a chance. Oh, it’s not perfect - there is plenty to complain about, and that’s why it’s my favorite game ever, not the best game ever.

Since Sony Online Entertainment practically never advertised the game, the players created their own “ads” such as this one from long-time PSider Radant:

Above: Bask in the awesomeness. Makes you wish you’d played it sooner, yes? Ignore the 2003 graphics

Still not convinced? Here’s what you can do in the game: wield mega shotguns, laser-bazookas and camera-guided missiles; fly fighter jets, invisible transport ships and barn-sized gunships; wear power-armor with jump-jets or shields; drive or gun tanks, buggies, hovercraft and mechs; command platoons of up to 30 troops; become an invisible saboteur/assassin; perform orbital drops, giant EMP blasts and call down satellite lasers that can fry 50 enemies at once; and participate in the biggest, most chaotic, most jaw-dislocatingly awesome battles you will ever see in an FPS.

If you’re ever in game, give me a holler. I go by WorldofForms (Vanu Sovereignty), UndeadDeer (New Conglomerate) and ShimmeringSoul (Terran Republic).

The SmackDown series isn't terrible. On the contrary, THQ’s wrestling franchise rivals EA Sports entries in depth, playability and customization. You are presented with almost too many options in the most recent 2009 entry - you could get lost for hours in any number of modes the game throws at you. So I and everyone I know should absolutely adore the series, correct?

Above: Not dumb 

See, I do... but it’s wrestling, man. I’ve grown up knowing sports entertainment was fake and it’s more than a little embarrassing to openly admit to being a fan. The game is a simulation of a simulation, if you can even call it that. It’s like playing a Cirque du Soleil game. Both share the lack of clothing, the penchant for pyrotechnics and the same homoerotic connotations.

Above: Theatricality! 

And every year I lap it up like it’s my Madden, but without “coach’s challenges” or “salary caps” to worry about. I only get disqualified if I hit a guy with a chair when the ref isn’t looking. I can also throw him through a flaming table or drop him off a ladder. I can make a wrestler in blackface if I wanted (I would never, though) and have him wear a unitard with the American flag on it. Doesn’t that sound awesome? NO! It sounds incredibly ridiculous and I love it for that.

2003. I switch on my PS2 and have a sudden realization; I’ve 100%'d both GTA III and Vice City. San Andreas is just a distant dream in the future. I need a new challenge immediately. Cue... True Crime: Streets of LA to the rescue.

There’s no way the game deserves a place on the top table with Rockstar’s epics, but I had a blast with this. Sure, the vehicles are dreadful to drive, the plot's idiotic and there’s a fight with a dragon as the whole thing unravels at the end. The fisticuffs and shooting mechanics, on the other hand, were a revelation at the time.

True Crime offered more genius touches too. The dojos, for example, improve fighting skills like in San Andreas. A karma meter indicates your good cop/bad cop status, which isn’t unlike the morale decisions in GTA IV. True Crime was a trailblazer, even if by default of release dates.

I even loved the universally panned random crimes that you solve. How can burning through LA on the tale of a known vampire be boring? Granted, the eighth time is a stretch, but it’s still fun. And patting down pedestrians to find narcotics on them provides massive cheap thrills on the side.

For me, True Crime: Streets of LA provided the perfect stop-gap between Vice City and San Andreas. I was just as surprised as you are reading this that it then went on to have a special place in my heart. It’s just a shame that the sequel was the buggiest game I’ve ever played. But at least the original got it right, regardless of what you might be thinking.

Game makers like to think that if you take two good concepts and smash them together, you'll make twice as much money. Reality has proven time and again that when you take two good games and smash them together - say, Grand Theft Auto and Twisted Metal - you more often get crap. And one such piece of crap is Roadkill.

As Mason Strong, a guy driving an El Camino with a machine gun in the back, you roll up in the town of Lava Falls, your first stop in the "massive living world of Hell County." The opening cinema shows a hooker in a corset and high heels (and not much else) spewing vulgarity; that should give you a pretty good idea of what's to come. Just add a ton of bullets and blood and you've got your next 10 hours of gameplay.

Above: You get out on the road, and you kill. Hence, Roadkill. Questions?

Mind you, the game does deliver on its promise: it's a big open environment with GTA-style missions and lots of car combat like Twisted Metal. It also delivers majorly cheesy accents in the voice acting, and a weird selection of music (on selectable radio stations, natch) from third-rate rock bands and hip-hop guys you've never heard of.

Maybe the choices were supposed to be ironic, but dammit, it's fun to run over pedestrians to the strains of "Don't Fear The Reaper" - especially when those pedestrians then cling to your bumper, thanks to rudimentary ragdoll physics. It's a morbid, B-grade slasher film that gets off on its own irreverence, and honestly, it's hard for me not to get sucked in. The developers really committed to the concept of being completely splattery and unabashedly unoriginal.

History has already forgotten Roadkill, despite its best efforts to be super shocking and burn itself into the annals of history. (It got close...  just remove one of the Ns.) If it weren't for the intentionally over-the-top language and violence, the game would not even be a footnote. Ultimately, there were a lot of games that ripped off GTA, from its style to its violence to its structure... and this was one of them.

Mar 26, 2009

Beloved games we hate
You love ‘em? We don’t. GamesRadar editors trash your favorite and most cherished classics

The Top 7... games you either love or hate
If you’re in the middle, you’re in the crossfire

Failed franchises we know how to fix 
They've been broken for years. Here's how to set them right


  • YourOldPalD - December 29, 2009 8:20 a.m.

    It's funny how sometimes something so shithouse to many people (aka. Kung Pow) turns out to be hilarious only to you. (aka. Kung Pow in my case) yet even though it's sad and lonely sometimes you can't help but feel anger the people who cling to something so ridiculously shit (aka. little britain) and yet the whole of society loves it. Lol, ya gotta love the human mind. :) (Seriously. LITTLE BRITAIN! They stuff a cross dresser JOKE IN EVERY BLOODY SEGMENT HOW IS THAT FUNNY OR ORIGINAL?!?!?!?)
  • scbyfn4evr - November 20, 2009 7:30 p.m.

    The original Monster Hunter. Not perfect, but perfect for me.
  • Japanjack - November 20, 2009 6:12 a.m.

    Dynasty Warriors: Gundam 2 is my guilty pleasure. I hate Dynasty Warriors, so damn repetitive and such; Dynasty Warriors Gundam 2 has robots and Char Aznable... Awesome.
  • sprog - April 15, 2009 10:51 a.m.

    Sorry everyone but I too am one of those responsible for the churning out of Dynasty Warriors year after year. I would stop if I weren't brainwashed by the eerie trances one goes into whilst ploughing through dozens of of the same character models at a time. It's strangely therapeutic in the way only simple and repetitive tasks can be...
  • somerandomchap - April 1, 2009 1:54 a.m.

    haha i have true crime: new york city it is terrible but i love it, there is something about cutting off someones head and using it as a weapon that makes me happy
  • xXgodlypunkXx - March 30, 2009 3:15 a.m.

    im not afraid to say it, i really liked sonic heros. in my opinion, its the only good 3-D sonic game. thanks justin, i thought i was alone on that one
  • Moleman42 - March 29, 2009 7:26 p.m.

    Planet Side! I loved that game, i played it when it first came out for a couple years. I have always wanted to get back into it. It was crazy how big the fights could get.
  • noobeater - March 29, 2009 4:57 p.m.

    i liked true crime streets of la that sais it never compared to gta but breaking peoples limbs was fun
  • Octaviux - March 29, 2009 3:39 p.m.

    omg True Crime, that was the last schatsoft I ever bought. That was the final straw that made me stalwart in never impulse buying again. I was pining for a GTA and got a total asian tird. I beta tested Planet side, not terrible but nothing special.
  • SteveOP - March 29, 2009 2:49 p.m.

    Sonic Heroes was unbelieveable! So fast and fun to play with friends... Ah those were the days...
  • Silentboy - March 29, 2009 2:01 p.m.

    Saints Row 1 and 2 are definately games i hate to love. Sure they're GTA clones, but fine good ones.
  • Teh_Ty - March 28, 2009 6:27 p.m.

    I'm suprised, I thougt I was the only person that liked Sonic Heros.
  • sadowolf - March 28, 2009 8:24 a.m.

    haha i loved clayfighter 63 1/3 too! i totally knew it was bad and ripped off other fighters, but i think the crazy (and large) cast of characters and the slapstick comedy won me over. it was flawed but i still had a blast playing it, and i actually did dive into what little nuances the game had. tao feng, on the other hand, was a different story. i loved the graphics, the interactive environments, and the limb and visible body damage (which, given who was behind it, i kind of expected that). but i just couldnt get into it. i just found it too clunky and not fun. i wanted to like it before i played it, but playing it made that impossible and i have no shame in admitting to being a wrestling fan, or a sd vs raw fan. the madden effect it has suffered lately has kept me from actually purchasing the games every year tho oh, and when i was younger i actually purchased shaq fu, and didnt it was that bad a game. of course as i got more into fighters i realize its garbage, but still dont think its quite as bad as people make it out to be. whew, glad to get that off my chest haha
  • Stabby_Joe - March 27, 2009 10:38 p.m.

    Haven't played any of them. Games that were thrashed but I liked (not great but alright) include Legendary, Godzilla Unleashed and Two Worlds. Two Worlds on the 360 was better when patched but you wouldn't know that when reading the initial release reviews where there were a ton of problems and a poor ass demo.
  • game-thugsta - March 27, 2009 10:23 p.m.

    i actually love true crime: streets of new york, despite how much people hate it
  • SaulFidgeonGuy - March 27, 2009 8:26 p.m.

    totally agree with harry potter games and msackdown vs raw games! just so much fun!
  • Bronzus - March 27, 2009 1:58 p.m.

    SONIC HEROES? Puh! (thank christ, I thought I was the only one) Brownlow, beloved (reCatared)
  • tmorgan - March 27, 2009 1:05 p.m.

    You aren't the only person. Even though the Harry Potter games keep getting worse and worse I still love them and have to keep playing them every time a new one comes out !! I have them all.
  • Cernunnos - March 27, 2009 11:23 a.m.

    the harry potter games are equally bad compared to the movies, as the movies are compared to the books. a lot. which makes sense really.
  • super-saint - March 27, 2009 5:34 a.m.

    hehehe... none of those are as bad as me... i had a moral battale over wether i should get sonic riders of shadow the headgehog... i then got both, played them to death, and now cant bare to look at them... okay i still play riders, sue me

Showing 1-20 of 72 comments

Join the Discussion
Add a comment (HTML tags are not allowed.)
Characters remaining: 5000