Quantcast

The Top 7... Best ports on inferior systems

Great versions of great games on lo-tech platforms

Words: Shane Patterson, GamesRadar US

In an overly simplistic nutshell, Sega’s Saturn was built primarily with respect to 2D gaming. In comparison, Sony’s PlayStation anticipated the future and was built as a 3D machine. That’s all well and good until it was time to port the fantastic tag-team brawler, X-Men vs Street Fighter to consoles in late 1997 and early 1998. Keep in mind, the PlayStation was already a resounding success and couldn’t even consider the Saturn competition. Could Sony pull off an amazing port? Not in the least.


Above: PlayStation owners saw this more than gameplay

Apparently, the PlayStation couldn’t handle 2D animated sprites with any regularity. Whole frames of animation were dropped, gameplay met with slowdown and there was no tag-team fighting (except with a code and only with the same fighters on either side) - arguably the key feature in the entire goddamn game. This was all due to the PlayStation’s criminally low RAM.


Above: Crap

Even if the Saturn version required the 4MB RAM cart bundled with the game, the saddest part of this story is that X-Men vs Street Fighter was never released in the United States because Sega had already cut its losses with the Saturn. US residents imported the game, which retailers began to stock. So, gamers would’ve rather paid out the ass for a port of an arcade game from Japan to play on a near-discontinued system, rather than play the next best thing. Harsh.


The tale of arguably the most popular puzzle game of all time is a sordid yarn, peppered with more twists than there really should be. In 1985, Soviet mastermind Alexey Pajitnov created Tetris, whose console rights were quickly gobbled up. Tengen - a division of Atari - created an NES version, to which Nintendo said “nuh uh, we totally have those rights.” The Tengen version - which had two-player mode, mind you - was pulled, leaving Nintendo to release their own version. And with only several colors and chip tunes at their disposal, the GameBoy copy surpasses these versions.


Above: The Tengen Tetris version is a rare collectible these days


Above: This is what Nintendo gave us instead. “Thanks”

How come? Well, in addition to being brilliantly packaged with the GameBoy for people on-the-go and endearing itself to adults - thus selling more than 33 million copies - GB Tetris featured two-player multiplayer, something the newly released Nintendo version did not.


Above: Now in monochrome!

Yes, the slight hassle of having two copies of the game, two copies of the gigantic GameBoy system, a link cable and only a smattering of green-tinted colors was still more popular than the closest alternative. Multiplayer games had been around a while before, but Tetris’s popularity certainly opened doors for a new way of thinking about competitive versus modes in games.


Now hold on; we’re not saying the 360 is inferior to the PlayStation 3 overall (the issue is subjective, but we’re willing to say the 360 excels over the PS3 in many key areas), we just mean the 360 underperforms in comparison via hardware and horsepower. With The Orange Box, there are five excellent games (three of which were old at the time of release) being shoehorned onto a disc. So how did five games disappoint on the system that supports the mammoth blu-ray disc’s memory capacity?


Above: The Orange Box when nothing goes wrong

Well, chalk that up to Sony’s uncanny ability to make every system completely irritating to program for. Microsoft’s Xbox systems are generally considered to be like programming for a PC, meaning porting the games to the console are relatively simple tasks. Not only that, but both the Windows and 360 versions were developed and published by Valve, while the development of the PS3 version was outsourced to EA. We’re willing to think EA did the best they could with the code given.


Above: Call us crazy, but we’re not supposed to be under the level

The most commonly cited issues with the PS3 version were pretty terrible frame rate issues throughout each game, sporadic glitches and slow loading times in Portal. A patch was issued to clear some up some of the issues, but we hear some of these problems still persist. No problem is game-breaking and The Orange Box is completely playable if you own a PS3, just be warned about what you’re getting into.


 
53 Comments
Order Comments: Newest First | Oldest First
T0M95  - 10 months 15 days ago 
- Comment removed by Community
Reported
P3N15  - 10 months 14 days ago 
if u want to "have" the first

at LEAST put something relevant to the feature with it
P3N15  - 10 months 14 days ago 
i can relate to most of the old school games

especially aladdin
sum gud memories with that game
Hurricrane  - 10 months 14 days ago 
fourth! and this was a great article
CuddlyBomber  - 10 months 14 days ago 
Hmm, I think I'm going to have to rub orange box in my friends face. His is a big PS3 famboy...
FierceDeity  - 10 months 14 days ago 
tbh im suprised you didnt mention okami
i know how you lot love that game
td823934  - 10 months 14 days ago 
Why do people go like "fifth" or "first to say 'cr@p''"? It's dumb as 776H (flip it upside-down).
GamesRadarCharlieBarratt  - 10 months 14 days ago 
I still remember how disappointed I was to find out that the SNES Aladdin wasn't the same as the Genesis one I'd seen kids playing at Toys 'R Us. So disappointed, in fact, that I eventually convinced my parents to buy me a Genesis for that reason alone.
BigBossOSE  - 10 months 14 days ago 
People who call "first" are retards. That's all I'm saying.
Tochy  - 10 months 14 days ago 
OMG PS3 FTW!!!111

Let teh war begin...
GoldenMe  - 10 months 14 days ago 
3 reasons why I love GR:

1. They likes the Genesis.

2. All the people in the comments either say "first" or they piss and moan about the person who said "first".

3. This reason. (but we’re willing to say the 360 excels over the PS3 in many key areas)

I love you guys. Awesome article. And 360 FTW.
lymanzaar  - 10 months 14 days ago 
in the top 15! awesome. great feature
NullG7  - 10 months 14 days ago 
The PS3 Xbox 360 thing has been going on too long! They have about the same performance and power, the main thing is prefrence if you like great graphics and some older games (not at the same time go PS3, if you like good online play and constantly evolving and updating games go 360. No point in arguing now pick and be silent my I pick 360 what about you?
Romination  - 10 months 14 days ago 
Hm...I didn't know Web of Shadow's was like that for the DS...interesting. What about every Castlevania game is better on the inferior portables? It's more of a series thing than a 'game by game' thing, but it's still valid
KREATIVEassassin  - 10 months 14 days ago 
Excellent article, Shane!
Defguru7777  - 10 months 14 days ago 
In addition to the points you mentioned, the 360 version of The Orange Box will also get the PC expansions. Take that PS3!! (Not a fanboy, I just like to stick it to the man)
Corsair89  - 10 months 14 days ago 
I played the hell out of Orange Box on my 360. It became so scratched that when I was working my way through Half-Life 2 Episode 2 with that damn, loathable, evil, infuriating, garden gnome and whenever I threw him aside to defense myself, if I stepped on the gnome he would fling me hundreds of feet off in the air and off the level. F***ing gnome.
Ninja-KiLLR  - 10 months 14 days ago 
the orange box was crap some parts were really awsome but over all it seemed kinda life less
phoenix_wings  - 10 months 14 days ago 
Good article, except of course the flame-war inciting comment. Hmm, Microsoft has PCs as well as the 360...so who is actually the man in this case? PS3 is better. I play it because I want my stuff to work, not mock me with red lights and its incapability to work. The 360 has better online play than the PS3, but I really don't want to listen to 12-year olds shouting out how big their p3n15 is. I don't want to have to buy half of my game through DLC, and when I do go online, I don't want to have to pay extra for the full online experience. And you might have the Orange Box better-ness, but Konami would first release a MGS for the iPod touch and iPhone before they would release a port for the 360....and those who say "first" without adding anything constructive to say are most definitely retards.
homie_cheese_slice  - 10 months 14 days ago 
This is totally unrelated to the article, but they should come out w/ gex on psn!
Related Games
The Orange Box
Xbox 360
Xbox
Xbox
Gamecube
GameCube
Operation Flashpoint: Dragon Rising - 2nd DLC Pack... N4G
PS3 News from N4G
Nov 27, 2009
Black Friday Deal: PS3 120GB with free Killzone 2,... N4G
PS3 News from N4G
Nov 27, 2009
New Final Fantasy XIII footage in promotional... N4G
PS3 News from N4G
Nov 27, 2009
Rogue Warrior PS3 Trophies N4G
PS3 News from N4G
Nov 27, 2009
EyePet Patch Now Available N4G
PS3 News from N4G
Nov 27, 2009