the reasons for the 360 are dumb as hell, first off: the red ring doesent happen randomly! it is caused by plying the console too much, and it ends up melting the connectors on the primary processing card and then it redrings. secondly, who cares about wi-fi , i'd pick a good old ethernet cord over some crappy wireless thing that might have a chance of disconnecting at random intervals. thridly, the d-pad is fine, if you have a hard time using it there isn't something wrong with the controller, there is something wrong with you. and finally, the reason there arent achievements in community games is because the creators don't put any, it's not like, just because they are community games they are banned from having achievements.
here is a good idea for "guilds", you get to start chapters and whatnot, choosing the armor color and such at the very beginning, and the guild leader would be the chapter master and would get distinctive armor peices to identify them as chapter masters.