ive got nothin against GH:WT, it has an awesome setlist from what ive seen so far, but i would never get it because of the fact that RB2 looks better. if GH:WT had the RB2 interface, id call it a tie.
i agree, you only ever get slightly scared the first time you play a game, for instance, the first time you play Bioshock and encounter the first Big Daddy, then you find out he's pretty easy to kill, depending on the difficulty, it looses the scaryness. also, if youre playing a game for the second time around, you'd pretty much know whats coming.
hmm, doesnt look too bad, looks quite neat compared to the old dashboard, im not too sure about the whole avatars thing tho. at least theres plenty of customisation to be done.