I played the closed beta of WAR and loved it. I quit WoW and rolled a few classes on destro. I was sick of all little kid crap on WoW and from the look of it, all the new abilities for the expansion were just taken from other classes and renamed. I didn't see much change. And with the "new" dungeons being ones from preBC brought back, for me, it would just be a waste of time.

WAR made questing fun and like they said in one of their videos before the game was released, as a healer, i don't just stand back and heal. I can actually lvl as a healer w/o problems.

And for guilds, with there being guild ranks/privledges/achievements, it makes the whole "guild" experience different and actually worth while.

The only thing atm that i see that could be a problem is there only being two main professions. I think w/o more, it will kill the economy but hopefully they'll come out with more when the new cities and whatnot are rdy.