Im a huge Bungie fan, iv'e been around since Marathon and I love Halo cause it's great. I agree the campaigne wasnt the greatest (Halo2 = Best) but the multiplayer by far is the greatest of the series. (also Jacko415 you need to consider that you are only talking about 1/16th of the fanboy population)
Below is a list of things that somewhat brought down the game for me. (Remember this might just bother me or anyone) I also have a smaller than average TV
Some human enemies took to many bullets to the face. The font was sometimes hard to read, especially red lettering in weapon shops. When you brought up your journal the objectives were hard to read. There were a few annoying parts like the amoeba attack. Nightvision goggles made it too bright. Grenades were hard to use because you had to let the timer run down a bit before you threw it so the enemies couldnt run half a mile away before they detonated. I had a hard time figuring out how the gas gage on your watch worked mine would never be past yellow. And how hard it was to tell if you were sneaking or not because sometimes you could stand right infront of someone with yellow LED but others would see you from very far away with green LED. Turrets were hard to aim sometimes.
There were a few other minor problems with the game but I still think this game shouldnt get a 9 I believe it should get a 10 because it was quite an Amazing game.
You know what i really want to see is a Prequel to Bioshock that nothing is destroyed. Even something where nothing really happens it would just be cool to explore the whole city without it being destroyed. It could just be a free download for the computer or somthing but seriously that would be sick.
LOL U guys aree freaking out about a puzzle game. And Kittie is a chick by the way to all the people that said "guy" since she said boyfriend (could be gay) No but seriosly it was a good game, fun challenging and a pretty good story. I want number 2 but in a war theme. That would be funny in multiplayer have a portal to go behind someone and assassinate them.