I Want
FIFA Soccer 09 (PC)

Unfortunately, FIFA 09 inherits all the faults of FIFA 08 - including the stupidly unreal Manager mode and the infuriating AI of Be A Pro mode - and throws in a few ...

Grand Theft Auto IV (PC)
The sequel to the carjack-fest of the century satisfies all your mob and hooker related fantasy, though it suffers from a few PC-porting related shortcomings.
I'm playing
Crash of the Titans (Wii)
This game was fun about five years ago. Now it's just mildly entertaining and somewhat annoying. Talk about losing your Mojo.
Destroy All Humans: Big Willy Unleashed (Wii)
Packing pounds of "pull my finger" quality jokes, the insult slinging alien, Crypto returns to open his own restaurant which features human flesh as the secret ingredient.
Call of Duty: World at War (DS)

Certainly a big production for a DS game, but like nearly all FPSes for the system, unnatural controls hold it back.

The Simpsons Game (PSP)
Not so much a cohesive game as a series of "episodes", this is still head and shoulders above the spin-off games that have clouded Springfield's finest down the years.
Nitrobike (Wii)
Bouncing over hills and watching the mud fly should be fun, but the unreliable controls suck most of the joy out of this motorbike racer.
Rig Racer 2 (Wii)
What's the point in driving around in circle in a big rig? It's just no fun racing a truck that takes 10 minutes to get into third gear.
I Love
FIFA Soccer 09 (PC)

Unfortunately, FIFA 09 inherits all the faults of FIFA 08 - including the stupidly unreal Manager mode and the infuriating AI of Be A Pro mode - and throws in a few ...

I Hate
Pimp My Ride (Wii)
It's nothing like the show and it isn't fun. Moreover, the Wii gets the game a year late with no upgrades except for motion-sensitive controls.