I Want
The Godfather II (Xbox 360)

A commendable stab at living like a Don, The Godfather II suffers from last gen visuals and a clumsy menu system.

BioShock 2 (PC)

Taking place some years after the original title, BioShock 2 features the first Big Daddy returning to Rapture to stop the Big Sister and her ilk. Also, some long-awaited multiplayer ...

I'm playing
Fallout 3 (Xbox 360)
The freedom may scare people used to more linear shooters and the simplified customization might disappoint hardcore RPGers, but if ever a game was worth broadening your horizons for, this ...
NCAA Football 09 (Xbox 360)
An improvement to an already-stellar football experience, NCAA 09 delivers the goods in the most important places.
Guitar Hero World Tour (Xbox 360)
Guitar Hero branches out for its fourth core installment by adding drums and vocals to the mix, as well as allowing us to unleash our own musical creations upon the ...
City of Heroes (PC)
Shoot radiation beams from your eyes and smite evil in day-glo lycra. It's every comic-book fan's dream come true.
I've Beaten
Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots (PS3)
Snake's next adventure takes him out of the jungles and corridors he's used to, dropping him into the middle of full-on futuristic battlefields as a mercenary superspy.
The Godfather (Xbox 360)
A markedly beefed-up and improved version of the movie-themed Grand Theft Auto clone that casts you as a foot soldier in the Corleone crime family.
BioShock (Xbox 360)
Dive beneath the ocean's surface for a dark masterpiece of gameplay design. Scaring you is just the first of many, many things BioShock does spectacularly right.
Fable II (Xbox 360)

This is role-playing in the child's sense: dress up and pretend. Despite the long load times and clunky inventory screens you can be who you want and have a ...

Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare (Xbox 360)
We're still not sure what war this is and the solo campaign could have been longer; but it's the same Call of Duty that we all know and ...
Collecting Dust
NCAA Football 07 (Xbox 360)
An excellent sports game, with all the thrills and dynamics of real college football.
Guitar Hero III: Legends of Rock (Xbox 360)
When you actually get to bust out a Rage Against the Machine song by Rage themselves, there's nothing like it. It's another step in air-guitar fantasy fulfillment.
NCAA Football 08 (Xbox 360)
Transforming yourself from Gerry Faust into Bear Bryant takes effort, but the results can be fantastic.
I Love
BioShock (Xbox 360)
Dive beneath the ocean's surface for a dark masterpiece of gameplay design. Scaring you is just the first of many, many things BioShock does spectacularly right.
Guitar Hero II (Xbox 360)
The sequel to Guitar Hero promises 55 new songs and the option to jam with friends on bass, rhythm or lead guitar tracks.
Left 4 Dead (Xbox 360)

An incredibly tense multiplayer experience like no other. A must buy for shooter fans.

I Hate
Ninja Gaiden II (Xbox 360)
Unless the first game made you want to claw your eyes out in frustration, you are probably pretty excited to return to the blood soaked world of Ryu Hayabusa and ...