Pokemon XD: Gale of Darkness review

  • Great soundtrack
  • Emotional attachments you can develop
  • You can save anywhere
  • Missing features from previous versions
  • Scooter isn't controllable
  • Not having camera control is inhibiting

XD opens with a cutscene worthy of a much bigger screen. A cruise liner is set upon by a legendary Pokemon and a gang of helicopters from the extra dimension (which is what the XD stands for). The Pokemon, a Shadow Lugia codenamed XD001, drags the liner out from the waters and makes away with it through the night sky. It's a dramatic, well-executed set-piece which immediately establishes the blockbuster style of the game - Pokemon XD is the real deal.

At first you can't access any areas apart from Ash's home and Professor Krane's lab. But after interacting with the characters and searching through the house for your little sister Jovi, your mother sends you on your first mission. Moving around the world is not as engrossing as it could be - there's no Final Fantasy-style wandering involved and no treks. Instead, a single click on a location initiates a cutscene which shows Ash riding down a dirt track on his scooter.

The design of each location is such that you can choose to either follow sequences that progress the story, or take time out to investigate less central places and meet unimportant, but not uninteresting, characters. The advantage of following the second route is that more level-up opportunities arise, extra side-quests appear and new items can be found and bought. You're rewarded for not rushing through the game and as a result, you can easily get a good 20+ hours of engaging play from the main adventure.

Other Pokemon be obtained when a scientist comes up with a revised version of the Snag Machine, which enables you to snag other trainers' monsters during battles to be organized by your PDA. There are 83 Shadow Pokemon scattered throughout the game, all of which can be caught in this way. You can hold up to six Pokemon in your line-up, and you can make substitutions in battle. It's a versatile system that really gives it the spirit of a traditional team-based RPG.

By keeping things relatively simple, Nintendo has ensured that XD is a fun and progressive RPG without any of the hindrances that dog lesser games. And that's the definition of good game design, so give the developers a pat on the back.

It's no surprise that battles are the main feature, but they've never looked so good. In Genius Sonority's last effort, Pokemon Colosseum, character animations were blocky and the character models weren't particularly impressive. Although XD makes use of the same engine, the Pokemon themselves have been refined and look much better than they did.

It's certainly a delicious slice of role-playing cake, then. However, the solid and well-produced RPG element seems to have resulted in the sacrifice of some features outside the main game (like those found in Colosseum, or even the old Pokemon Stadium titles). The Game Boy link-up feature is cool if you want to battle the Pokemon youeve collected in the GBA games or if you want to trade Pokemon between XD and FireRed/ LeafGreen, but there isn't much beyond this basic facility other than a couple of mediocre minigames.

After trying their hand at Colosseum, it seems that Genius Sonority, a relatively new company, have discovered the two strands that make a great Gamecube Pokemon game - the role-playing adventure and the Game Boy interaction. Here's hoping that the next game will bring XD's better half together with Colosseum and Stadium's focus on linked play, and make the recipe even tastier. But as it stands, XD is a straight Pokemon RPG.

More Info

Release date: Oct 03 2005 - GameCube (US)
Available Platforms: GameCube
Genre: Role Playing
Published by: Nintendo
Developed by: Genius Sonority
Franchise: Pokemon
ESRB Rating:
Everyone: Cartoon Violence




Join the Discussion
Add a comment (HTML tags are not allowed.)
Characters remaining: 5000