Pokemon HeartGold/SoulSilver

  • The Pokewalker
  • Integrated stylus controls
  • Nearly all 493 Pokemon in a single game
  • Core game is identical to the original
  • No tools for advanced training/breeding
  • Pokethlon offers few rewards

The coolest pedometer ever

In a series like Pokemon, where changes are small and subtle, an addition like the Pokewalker - a Tamagotchi-style pedometer you can transfer your Pokemon into for quick leveling on the go - is huge. and provides 2 minigames, Dowsing and a Poke Radar for catching Pokemon. The IR connectivity also makes using it a breeze, as you simply hold the Pokewalker’s sensor up to the game card, which has its own built in IR sensor.

Above: No Starfleet Engineer needed, transporting Pokemon onto the Pokewalker is a breeze 

Once the Pokemon is on the Pokewalker, he is considered “On a Stroll” and is removed from the regular game. From there, the Pokewalker keeps track of your steps, and awards experience and happiness to the chosen Pokemon, while also awarding Watts, a currency specific to the Pokewalker. Aside from unlocking new options and areas for the Pokewalker, Watts can be used to play two minigames: dowsing for items, or searching for other Pokemon to capture with the Poke Radar. Dowsing is a simple guessing game in which you select a patch of grass and look for an item, while the Poke Radar has you track a Pokemon through some grass and battle against it with a simplified menu. Pokemon captured in the Pokewalker can then be transferred back to the game the next time you connect.

Above: Also functions as a Max Repel against random girl encounters 

After transferring a Pokemon onto the Pokewalker, it took about 63 steps to level up my Mareep from six to seven. Low-level Pokemon tend to level extremely quickly on the Pokewalker, which makes using it immediately fun, if somewhat impractical. Knowing that your ‘mons are leveling as you're commuting to work or school is an awesome feeling, and there's a certain nerdy giddiness in knowing your Pokemon pals are in your pocket with you wherever you go. The only downside comes from the fact that the Pokemon may only level up once per transfer to the Pokewalker. Given how fast low-level Pokemon level, you'll find yourself constantly swapping Pokemon on and off the system as you walk around in real life, so that you’re not wasting steps on a Pokemon that's already leveled up. While it’s likely to dissuade cheaters from just placing the Pokewalker in a hardware store paint can shaker and getting a bunch of Lvl 100s, it hardly feels worth the effort in the early portions of the game, as traditional battles will level your young Pokemon much faster.

The struggle to evolve

It’s a minor complaint, but it’s kind of irksome that, even now, Nintendo and Game Freak still have not included ways to monitor all of your Pokemon’s stats. Ways to see your Effort Value and Individual Value stats are still M.I.A, and require you to do a number of roundabout things to track them. Advanced endgame Pokemon trainers may be a minority, but it wouldn’t require a lot of effort to add some extra functions to the Pokegear for the tournament players who are eager to breed and raise optimal Pokemon. Having to keep a notebook full of theorems and equations seems incredibly outdated and unnecessary. It could be argued that these aspects are intentionally kept obscure to prevent everyone from having top-tier Pokemon, but if all it takes is a visit to Bulbapedia to noodle out the secrets, why make them so difficult to implement?  

Above: Sealocanthachu, the Fossil Fish Pokemon 

The only major criticisms of HG&SS stem from the fact that this is still essentially the same Pokemon Nintendo and Game Freak have been releasing for years. It’s hard to shake the nagging feeling that HG&SS is something of a stopgap game to help make up for the difficulty of transferring Pokemon over from the original Game Boy and GBC games. All the original starters are available in HG&SS, albeit very late in the game, which is great because no one but the most dyed-in-the-wool Pokefreak is going to dust off their original Game Boy carts to trade Squirtle into the current generation. The recent (Japanese) announcement of the all new Generation V games, in addition to the rumblings of a new nVidia powered DS on the horizon may also cause the more casual Pokemon fan to hesitate on HG&SS.

Above: The Future? 

The Pokewalker, Pokethlon and the myriad updates and tweaks more than make this title worthwhile, but they’re all ultimately new coats of paint on the same creaky old house. Even so, the grindy RPG gameplay is so pure, it’s still fun after all these years. But if Nintendo wants to appeal to new gamers outside the fanbase, they’re going to have to finally make some real changes to the franchise. It's more than a little ironic that in a game full of constantly evolving creatures developing new abilities and talents, Pokemon has become a virtual coelacanth, nearly the exact same creature it was in its beginning, but somehow still alive eons later.

Is it better than...

Bakugan: Battle Brawlers? Absolutely. If Digimon was a pale imitation of Pokemon, Bakugan is paler than an albino at a WoW convention. A boring, generic spin on the already-taxed collect-‘em-all card game-hybrid introduced by Yu-Gi-Oh and Pokemon, Bakugan has one1 zillionth the depth of HG&SS, and none of the charm.

Invizimals? Yes. While Invizimals may someday be a worthy Pokemon opponent, it still has bugs to iron out with its camera technology and gameplay. Even so, it's got some great ideas, and Nintendo should be taking notes when it comes to the much more dynamic battle system and the way Invizimals embraces new technology.

Pokemon Platinum? Just barely. HG&SS comes out barely a year after Platinum and offers better graphics and more side quests, but virtually no new Pokemon and only a few places gamers haven't seen before. The clincher really is the Pokewalker though, as it adds a dynamic new aspect to the game that its predecessors can't offer.

Just for you, Metacritic!

HeartGold and SoulSilver are undeniable rehashes, but Nintendo’s signature polish and the Pokewalker make it easy to overlook the recycling. It’s hard to argue with a gameplay formula that still manages to be fun 15 years after the fact, but as usual, there’s little here to draw new players into the franchise.

Mar 10, 2010

More Info

Release date: Mar 14 2010 - DS (US)
Mar 26 2010 - DS (UK)
Available Platforms: DS
Genre: Role Playing
Published by: Nintendo
Developed by: Game Freak
ESRB Rating:
PEGI Rating:

Down are up ell, ex why be?

Join the Discussion
Add a comment (HTML tags are not allowed.)
Characters remaining: 5000
  • stevenjohnson - July 19, 2010 10:53 a.m.

    lol,ive got all 3 starters and i pwn wit all of them.arby and the cheif on utube is the most funniest video ive seen.look it up on utube
  • Demonflare - March 26, 2010 12:11 a.m.

    I respect the game, I would buy it, yet its the remake of the Johto region, Ive got all of the pokemon except minor legendary pokemon. Im saving money for the generation 5 game. Zoroark is sexy! I love Pokemon!
  • super0sonic - March 21, 2010 7:14 p.m.

    I bought it and i LOVE it. But then i skipped gold and silver so this is all new to me!!
  • starhaw - March 17, 2010 7:55 p.m.

    I have always loved pokemon...but I would just love for Nintendo to just ONCE let them make a pokemon game on the console you know true 3D where you can see the actual pokemon walking in the grass, things like that....I remember in a GR article when they asked the developers of Pokemon why they wouldn't and they said it was because they wanted pokemon to be a traveling experience you know as if you where actually a poke-trainer carrying your pokemon with you where ever you go....well my solution to that is why not make the idk Wii version include a DS version so you can take your Pokemon on the go? ( I know that sounds a little hard with constantly having to transfer saved games and such but they could do it if they really wanted to) Captcha: The Girlhood (wth is that? lol sounds like some book a girl would read... )
  • Metroidhunter32 - March 12, 2010 11:48 p.m.

    Monster Hunter, Other M, and Ikaruga can all go suck it, I'm buying a DS now.
  • hardcore_gamer1990 - March 12, 2010 9:33 p.m.

    I'm going to get an old DS from my local and this game and that shall be my one and only game :) I never got to play gold/silver, so it'll be a new game to me.
  • Pocotron - March 12, 2010 9:31 p.m.

    @McSpermie Its cool man. We're all here to get our Pokemon freak on! Ammiright? (That came out wrong)
  • jackthemenace - March 12, 2010 7:58 p.m.

    I do quite want this game, but forking out £35-£40 is stupid. especially since one girl actually likes me, it'd be stupid to chase her away
  • Sukururu - March 12, 2010 6:11 p.m.

    *drool* All my great childhood memories in a remake....and don't have the console... D=
  • McSpermie - March 12, 2010 7:15 a.m.

    @Pocotron I'll stop here but there are other ways you could have gone about saying what you said, though it wasn't my place to say it was childish because in truth it wasn't, just as you said it was fanboyish which isn't a bad thing at all. Sorry to have offended you :D
  • secretsearcher - March 12, 2010 4:50 a.m.

    Gold/Silver are still my favorites of the generations. So a remake would be fantastic :). But in my opinion, I liked the contests in the Ruby/Sapphire Games. The Diamond/Pearl contests were too gimicky, and now this Pokemon Olympic thing? Wayyyy too cheesy for my tastes.
  • Sanguinarius - March 12, 2010 4:21 a.m.

    The concept of having you prkemon follow you outside of the pokeball really is not that new. I still have my Pokemon Yellow that I won in a raffle and they had a Pikachu that you recieved as your starter follow you around, it even had indicators of its mood. Pokemon yellow came out when Red and Blue did, but it was like a special edtion version with extras such as the pikachu as a starter and a Jesse/James and Meowth (from the show) Team Rocket NPC's that you battle. Overall, I will probably buy this. Silver and Gold were the best that i have ever played of pokemon, mostly because I liked the day/night transition and the special pokemon you could get depending on the time of day. I can't remember but was Pokemon Crystal like Silver and Gold? I remember having it and it had like those dog legendariy pokemon that were like fire/ice/and somthing else. I also remember it having the Unknown (the pokemon shaped like letters that were encryptions) that you could capture. (at least I think they were called Unknown)
  • Rubberducky - March 12, 2010 3:10 a.m.

    I have absolutely no clue what Pokemon is about
  • johnthe5th - March 12, 2010 1:57 a.m.

    I can't wait for this one. The best part for me will be the recurring memories. My favorite Pokemon game was Crystal but I lost it along with Gold and Silver. Just thinking about this brings back a myriad of memories. The bug contest, Ho-oh's tower, Lugia's sea cave, I seem to remember something about an Espeon and Umbreon. I also remember a snow cave with some swinub and delibird. And other things like the Sudowoodo... oh I cant wait! All these subconscious memories will finally come to life!
  • Kytl - March 12, 2010 1:30 a.m.

    don't care much about the faults, this game is just filled with nostalgia. Silver was my first pokemon game and you can guess which one i'll get. besides, G2 was my favorite, G4 makes me cringe whenever i look at it
  • mubobi7593 - March 11, 2010 11:39 p.m.

    Wow, that's genuinely surprising to find out that the Pokewalker isn't just a quick cash-grabbing gimmick... Not that I wouldn't have gotten HG&SS anyway... But does it give EVs while leveling???
  • marioman50 - March 11, 2010 11:22 p.m.

    I have fond memories of the original Silver, and it's been a while since I've tried catching 'em all. I owe it to myself to re-experience the biggest of all Pokemon games in a new generation.
  • keroro47 - March 11, 2010 11:22 p.m.

    wow.. i remember when i got yellow... then gold and silver..... this brings back memories
  • Conman93 - March 11, 2010 11:07 p.m.

    Looking forward to getting it and battling my rival/friend ( by coincedence, his name is gary !)
  • Romination - March 11, 2010 10:02 p.m.

    Gold and Silver are my favourite of these games though. That's why I need to get this. But I have 2 Final Fantasy games and Disgaea for my DS already... that need to be beaten...